So disappointing I'm honestly so disappointed with this show. I love these books so dearly, I've studied them in depth and written essays on them, and this show doesn't do it justice.
The casting is awful, the Golden Compass Movie may have completely abandoned the true plot, but that Lyra was absolutely perfect. Dafne Keen just isn't right, her only emotion seems to be raising her voice in anger. Lyra is supposed to be incredibly vibrant, imaginative, clever and Dafne portrays none of those things, she just comes across as a moody teenager constantly yelling at everyone. I find her acting so terribly annoying that I can barely watch this series. I love Ruth Wilson, but her portrayal doesn't express that indescribable charm and poise that is so essential to Mrs Coulter's demeanour, something Nicole Kidman embodies perfectly.
Secondly, where are all the deamons? They're so essential to this story, they're a part of every character that represents their true personality. They should be with the characters at every moment, so much so that the idea of someone who doesn't have one is repulsive, and yet most scenes don't include them, just implying that they're somewhere unseen off to the side. I understand that they're expensive to animate, but you shouldn't commit to making a series like this if you can't afford to depict such an important aspect of the story.
I'm also confused about how much plot information is being revealed so early on. In Episode 2, Lyra breaks into Mrs Coulter's Office and finds blueprints for what they're building at Bolvangar, which does not happen in the books and has completely spoiled the dramatic revelation for what will happen later. In Episide 1, Lord Asriel thoroughly explains exactly what his plans are in the North, even explaining what Dust is, Lyra is supposed to spend the whole book desperately searching for what this curious word Dust means, and Lord Asriel keeps his experiments shrouded in mich more mystery from the scholars. I understand this may seem to be nitpicking but the plot of Northern Lights, and the reason Lyra is so desperate to go North is a desire to learn more about Dust and they've seemingly taken that away.
The producers have tried to go for a more Game of Thrones approach and depict multiple storylines and characters at once, rather than following the story through Lyra's eyes and finding out information as she does, but I feel this falls flat and will backfire on them later. We are already being introduced to characters and plot points that don't come into effect until much later in the books, and now those moments won't have the same gravitas when they come around, or will there just be lots of scenes of Lyra being explained things we already know?
I'm honestly just very confused by this series, and I'm so utterly disappointed in it, I've been looking forward to it since I first heard it was commissioned. Maybe I just have too high expectations or the books are just too close to my heart for me to ever be happy with a series, but I actually enjoyed the Golden Compass Film until they did away with the ending. I'm honestly surprised that Phillip signed off on all this, it doesn't feel like whoever had translated it to the screen understood the appeal of the books in the first place.
Although it's very highly rated so I guess it's enjoyable as a stand alone series, for those who haven't read them or just don't know them as well as I do.