After the events of "iLost My Mind", Sam and Freddie begin a rocky relationship, but problems circulate around Carly when she has to resolve their every fight (even one at 3 am). Meanwhile, Gibby finds a puppy and he wants to share it with Carly, in an attempt to get closer to her. At the near end of the episode, Freddie and Sam go on a date, but take Carly with them to resolve a fight if they get into one. After Sam and Freddie criticize each other, Carly steps in and tells them "if they can't go one day without arguing then they shouldn't be going out at all." Spencer spends time hanging out with his new lawn in the apartment.
—Anonymous