J.D. Vance’s best-selling autobiography “Hillbilly Elegy” isn’t the most natural fit for the big-screen treatment, an often unwieldy mix of heartbreaking memoir, personal observations couched in sociological chatter, and cherry-picked factoids. In trying to understand how and why his Appalachian family faced hardships like domestic abuse, drug addiction, and poverty, critics noted that Vance’s perspective often revealed, at best, the limitations of his experience.
At worst, other critics said that Vance’s story was rife with racist and sexist ideology, a reliance on easily dispelled fallacies, and a resistance to blaming any of it on government and culture. As Sarah Jones put it in a searing “New Republic” piece, the book is “little more than a list of myths about welfare queens repackaged as a primer on the white working class.” It was also a bestseller, and one that many hoped might shine a light on segments of an increasingly divided America.
At worst, other critics said that Vance’s story was rife with racist and sexist ideology, a reliance on easily dispelled fallacies, and a resistance to blaming any of it on government and culture. As Sarah Jones put it in a searing “New Republic” piece, the book is “little more than a list of myths about welfare queens repackaged as a primer on the white working class.” It was also a bestseller, and one that many hoped might shine a light on segments of an increasingly divided America.
- 11/25/2020
- by Kate Erbland
- Indiewire
Similar News
Still Think Meryl Streep's Miranda Was a Legend? She's Still Very Much a Villain
- 4/24/2024
- by info@startefacts.com (Ava Raxa)
- STartefacts.com
Even Stephen King’s 1990 Psychological Thriller Is a Fairytale Compared to Netflix’s Biggest Hit
- 4/24/2024
- by benjamin-patel@startefacts.com (Benjamin Patel)
- STartefacts.com
Golden Kamuy Live-Action Film Releases International Trailer
- 4/24/2024
- by Paul Chapman
- Crunchyroll
HBO TV Show Ratings (updated 4/24/2024)
- 4/24/2024
- by TVSeriesFinale.com
- TVSeriesFinale.com
“They felt the period of my show was too far removed”: Oscar Winner’s Game of Thrones Spin-off Might Never See the Light of Day for its Mythological Idea That’s Too Controversial Today
- 4/24/2024
- by Subham Mandal
- FandomWire
Shogun: What Was the Battle of Sekigahara?
- 4/24/2024
- by Alec Bojalad
- Den of Geek
Turns Out, the Basic Recipe for Fake Blood Hasn’t Changed Much Since the ’70s
- 4/23/2024
- by Sarah Shachat
- Indiewire
The Creature From The Black Lagoon Lives! Is The Perfect New Comic For Horror Movie Fans
- 4/23/2024
- by Devin Meenan
- Slash Film
Can You Defeat Our Fiendishly Hard Universal Monster Movie Quiz?
- 4/22/2024
- by Louisa Mellor
- Den of Geek
IMDb.com, Inc. takes no responsibility for the content or accuracy of the above news articles, Tweets, or blog posts. This content is published for the entertainment of our users only. The news articles, Tweets, and blog posts do not represent IMDb's opinions nor can we guarantee that the reporting therein is completely factual. Please visit the source responsible for the item in question to report any concerns you may have regarding content or accuracy.
More to explore
‘Wednesday’ Season 2 Casts Thandiwe Newton (Exclusive)
- 4/23/2024
- by Joe Otterson
- Variety - TV News
Terry Carter, ‘Battlestar Galactica’ and ‘McCloud’ Actor, Dies at 95
- 4/23/2024
- by Lexi Carson
- Variety - Film News
Billie Eilish Says Upcoming Album ‘Hit Me Hard and Soft’ Is Like Returning “to the Girl That I Was”
- 4/24/2024
- by Christy Piña
- The Hollywood Reporter - Movie News
Podcast Workers File Unfair Labor Practice Charge Against iHeartMedia
- 4/24/2024
- by Katie Kilkenny
- The Hollywood Reporter - Movie News
AMC Theatres Building Distribution Team With New VP Hire After ‘Eras Tour,’ ‘Renaissance’ Box Office Success
- 4/24/2024
- by Rebecca Rubin
- Variety - Film News
Julio Torres’s “Problemista” Is Proof That The US Immigration System is a Relentless Maze
- 4/24/2024
- by Johanna Ferreira
- Popsugar.com
Chuwi Is the Voice of a New Puerto Rican Generation
- 4/23/2024
- by Juan Arroyo
- Popsugar.com
Camila Mendes on Why We Need More Latine Representation in Rom-Coms
- 4/22/2024
- by Brenda Barrientos
- Popsugar.com
Saraciea Fennell: "The Black Girl Survives in This One" Is the Representation I Didn't See in Horror Books
- 4/22/2024
- by Saraciea Fennell
- Popsugar.com
Tell Me Más: Bodine Talks New Album "Quemo Lento" and Growing From Hardships
- 4/22/2024
- by Juan Arroyo
- Popsugar.com
Brian Helgeland Shares Details On David Fincher’s Unmade ‘Cleopatra’ Film Almost Starring Angelina Jolie
- 4/24/2024
- by Christopher Marc
- The Playlist
‘The Big Cigar’ Trailer: André Holland Goes Undercover in Hollywood
- 4/24/2024
- by Proma Khosla
- Indiewire
Cormac McCarthy’s ‘Blood Meridian’ Being Adapted by ‘Gladiator’ Writer John Logan
- 4/24/2024
- by Brian Welk
- Indiewire
‘Jim Henson Idea Man’ Trailer: Ron Howard Directs New Doc About Beloved ‘Muppets’ & ‘Sesame Street’ Puppet Genius
- 4/24/2024
- by Valerie Thompson
- The Playlist
ID Sets Nick and Aaron Carter Docuseries as Its ‘Quiet on Set’ Follow-up — Watch the Trailer
- 4/24/2024
- by Samantha Bergeson
- Indiewire
Brian Helgeland Shares Details On David Fincher’s Unmade ‘Cleopatra’ Film Almost Starring Angelina Jolie
- 4/24/2024
- by Christopher Marc
- The Playlist
Netflix's Best New Show Teaches Us A Hard Lesson About The Streamer's Worst Habits
- 4/24/2024
- by BJ Colangelo
- Slash Film
John Logan boards ‘Blood Meridian’ adaptation for New Regency
- 4/24/2024
- ScreenDaily
AMC Theatres Building Distribution Team With New VP Hire After ‘Eras Tour,’ ‘Renaissance’ Box Office Success
- 4/24/2024
- by Rebecca Rubin
- Variety - Film News
‘The Big Cigar’ Trailer: André Holland Goes Undercover in Hollywood
- 4/24/2024
- by Proma Khosla
- Indiewire
‘Wednesday’ Season 2 Casts Thandiwe Newton (Exclusive)
- 4/23/2024
- by Joe Otterson
- Variety - TV News
Terry Carter, ‘Battlestar Galactica’ and ‘McCloud’ Actor, Dies at 95
- 4/23/2024
- by Lexi Carson
- Variety - Film News
Tina Fey and Steve Carell Will Weather The Four Seasons in New Comedy Series
- 4/24/2024
- by Jean Bentley
- Tudum - Netflix
‘The Big Cigar’ Trailer: André Holland Goes Undercover in Hollywood
- 4/24/2024
- by Proma Khosla
- Indiewire Television
Actors Access, a Top Casting Site, Hit With Class Action Lawsuit
- 4/24/2024
- by Gene Maddaus
- Variety - TV News