Matthew Blevins, a controversial cast member of teen parent reality series Unexpected, has a terrible reputation for cheating, disrespecting others, and ignoring his daughter. Matthew initially denied being the father of Hailey 2's baby, but later claimed the child as his own after their breakup and rumors of a potential reconciliation. Matthew's relationship with his first child, Kinsley, is strained, and his recent arrest for robbery and assault adds to his troubled history. Both Hailey 1 and Hailey 2 should stay away from him for the sake of their children.

The drama on teen parent reality series Unexpected can get pretty wild, and Matthew Blevins was a controversial cast member. Season 3 introduced fans to perhaps the most dramatic of all the storylines: the tale of Matthew and the two Haileys. Co-stars and fans alike were totally unprepared for the shock of Matthew and Hailey "2" Tilford announcing their pregnancy in the season three Tell All.