Poll: The Scariest Urban Legends

A poll by DoctorBuster

Results of 458 votes:

  1. 76

    Camilla Belle in When a Stranger Calls (2006)

  2. 73

    Natasha Gregson Wagner appears as Michelle Mancini

  3. 36

    Tony Todd in Candyman (1992)

  4. 30

    Marley & Me (2008)

  5. 29

    Jessica Lucas in Evil Dead (2013)

  6. 25

    Muse Watson in I Know What You Did Last Summer (1997)

  7. 25

    This sinister message greets Natalie the morning after her roommate is found dead in their dorm room.

  8. 24

    The Mothman of Point Pleasant (2017)

  9. 22

    Tania Saulnier in Slither (2006)

  10. 20

    Night of the Living Dead (1990)

  11. 19

    Katheryn Winnick in Amusement (2008)

  12. 15

    Brendan Gleeson in Lake Placid (1999)

  13. 12

    Nick Stahl in Mirrors 2 (2010)

  14. 11

    #13

  15. 8

    Carlos in Max (2015)

  16. 8

    Rob Bottin, Ric Moreno, Lee Socks, and Tommy Lee Wallace in The Fog (1980)

  17. 7

    Heather Mazur in A Night Of The Living Dead (1990)

  18. 7

    Mark Viniello in Chupacabra Terror (2005)

  19. 6

    Spike Jonze, Paul Dano, and Sonny Gerasimowicz in Where the Wild Things Are (2009)

  20. 4

    Lou David in The Burning (1981)

  21. 1

    Dwight Yoakam in Panic Room (2002)

Related Polls

Favorite Bathtub Scene in a Movie

Taking a bath in your bathtub can be the most relaxing time of your day. However in Hollywood, even those relaxing moments can get ugly. Murders, ghosts, hallucinations - we have witnessed it all in a bathtub. Which of the following bathtub scenes is your favorite? Discuss the poll here

Enough, From the Clown!

Which of the following clowns from movie and TV would you least want to meet in the middle of the night? After voting, you may discuss the poll here.

Iconic Horror Movie Weapons

A knife? A chain saw? A hook? Horror movies, along with their villains, have been as creative as they have been horrifying with their weapons of choice, and have mentally scarred us as a result. Lock your doors, shut your shelves and hide your appliances from these guys! Which of these iconic horror movie weapons is the most creative use of violence? After voting, you may be spooked out here.