I know what you're thinking: "Nobody votes this as their best. It wasn't even a big hit. What about Moonstruck? Or Sleepless in Seattle? Or Philadelphia Story? 'Screen7' can't have seen those." I have seen all the great romantic comedies and many more. And multiple times. I own many of them. I like them all.
But "Only You" remains at the very top of my list. I just love it! In my mind, it is near-perfection in the romantic comedy:
1) The two leads (Downey and Tomei) have absolutely terrific chemistry. Every bit as good as Hepburn and Grant or Cher and Cage or anyone I can think of. And they look great!
2) The plot has plenty of twists and turns that you are always entertained. But it doesn't make the mistake of being overly clever.
Making this also a "road-trip movie" and a "buddy movie" really livens things up. Also making it a soft tribute to Roman Holiday gives it some depth.
3) The setting in Italy is lovely! The cinematographer really takes advantage of the natural and cultural beauty without turning it into and art-flick.
4) The supporting cast is great.... leading role quality performances. Bonnie Hunt. Billy Zane. Joaquim de Almeida. And they are perfectly cast
5) It has some warm fuzzy "lessons in life" but is not heavy-handed about it.
6) It is a lovely safe fantasy -- there is temptation but goodness prevails. (I won't spoil the plot)
There probably is no "absolutely best" romantic comedy because you can't account for personal taste but, as for me, "Only You" is definitely on the short list.
13 out of 15 found this helpful