Okay, I have read a lot of the comments, and can't get over how a lot of people really hated the film. IT is no Oscar winning performance but it was a light hearted film and yeah, maybe the girls are going over and over the same thing again but isn't' that what we girls do? We love to repeat ourselves and dwell on a situation.It maybe a little cliché, but with all the movies out at the moment, it will be hard to find a movie without a little cliché. And I was happy to know that she def end up with the musician. I would've been extremely upset if she ended up with workaholic Architect. Diane Keaton though maybe a little high strung reminds me so much of my mum. She can be very irritating and is always concerned that I will find the right man, blah blah, blah and thinks I manage to find all the wrong guys, which is mostly true, but no matter what I love her. I could imagine her doing something like that. I am no Diane Keaton fan, I still remember that horrible movie The FAmily Stone, where I felt sorry more for Sarah Jessica PArker and felt the family were ganging up on her, but this movie was not even close. So what if the photo Diane Keaton was holding was the same as in the Family Stone, who cares. It is a prop. The only reason why I didn't give this movie a 10 was because of the 2 old ladies kissing at the end, unfortunately that was a bit out of place and not necessary. So I am going to be brave and say give this movie a go. And yes, I can see why Johnny would fall for Mandy Moore's character.