I recall an old friend telling me of this thoughtful film years ago. At the time I had little interest in early talkies so made no attempt to see it. Even though, at that time I was watching and enjoyed several vintage gems on TV, it was not until that same dear friend screened several classic's (on 'film' in his home thr) for me, that I came to fully appreciate the importance and power of strong writing, combined with professional craftsmanship, as a serious art form in film making.
I imagine many folk today may still not know how to look at a movie like "Emma" ~ even I was wondering if it would sustain me to the end. While I might have edited a short sequence from early on, I soon found myself being drawn in...the striking mobile camera shots, the subtle controlled direction, the changing moods of a well written story. This films young photographer, Oliver T. Marsh ('San Fransisco' '36 ~ A Tale of Two Cities' '36) seemed to work so well with the great humanities director Clarence Brown, each bring such rich imagery to a variety of diverse moods within some unexpected situations. Such a pity this superb image maker was lost to us at just 49 yrs of age - seemingly to the demon booze - more wasted talent!
For those who know (or have yet to learn) how to 'read' vintage classics and don't give up too soon, this could prove rewarding. BUT, let yourself run with the varied emotions as situations alter. While this may not be known as one of Clarence Brown's major works, it is never the less, a fine one. Besides, how often do we see an overweight, aging matronly female, as the main 'star' (not easy to sell to the 'glamour' generation) she plays a character who gives unconditional, selfless commitment to her charges (even harder to sell to the 'me' generation). Award winning silent star Marie Dressler manages to convince all the way and gets good support from various troopers of the day, like youngster, Richard Cromwell (the DiCaprio of his day) playing her employers last born son and aviation enthusiast 'Ronnie', Jean Hershold as her gentle inventor employer, with a strong portrayal from John Miljan as the committed District Attorney. In the background is truly glamorous star-to-be, Myrna Loy, not yet in her top billing professional form. It's pleasing to see TCM being more generous with adding some surprisingly long missing pioneering gems!. Keep em' coming please.
KenR................
11 out of 12 found this helpful