I think this is another example of a good cast with a weak script. It feels like a story being told by someone who doesn't understand what they're writing about. The ingredients for a good story are there, it just lacks true understanding, due diligence and polish. Props to hair and makeup, it must have been a chore to subdue the raw beauty of the cast members, it made me wonder how many supermodels are among the Amish. It's not one to avoid, it's just not great.