A Wicked Woman (1934) User Reviews (7)

A Little Too Much Self Sacrifice To Be Believable...

[xerses13 · 6/10 · 6 April 2010]

While watching this film I kept trying to place Actress MADY CHRISTIANS. Then in a flash I remembered, ALL MY SONS (1948) with BURT LANCASTER, EDWARD G. ROBINSON, HOWARD DUFF, HARRY MORGAN, etc. Ms. CHRISTIANS spent most of her career making films in Europe or appearing on the Stage, so is not well remembered here (U.S.A.), but once she spoke I recognized her.

A WICKED WOMEN (1934) is the struggle of a Woman raising her four (4) Children after killing her 'Criminal' Husband in self defense. Disposing of the body, she moves her family from the prying eyes of her former community. Raising them and herself too Middle-Class respectability and finding love again. Of course being a 'code' film she has to be called out too justify her crime. How they found his remains and any evidence that would hold up after all those years strains credibility. After all we are not talking about DNA and 21st Century technology. In those days though you had to tidy everything up before the happy ending, which this films does.

This is a melodrama typical of the period. Most of the acting is credibly done and the 'middle-aged' romance between Naomi Trice/Stroud (CHRISTIANS) and Pat Naylor (CHARLE BICKFORD) is believable. The supporting Actors do their parts well also. A young ROBERT TAYLOR in only his fourth role is presented in a early romantic lead. Something he would do for practically his entire career. Like most 'production films' made by the 'factory system' it is well made and worth watching. M.G.M. had a knack for making these 'B' level melodrama's.

Compelling Soap Opera

[abooboo-2 · 7/10 · 3 September 2001]

It would seem that the "woman sacrifices everything for her children" storyline was rather popular back in the 1930's. This is yet another one out of that pipeline and it's a competent effort with fluid direction from a veteran of silents, Charles Brabin (he puts together a couple of striking montages and seems to handle actors well). Interestingly, it was his last film. I had never EVER heard of Mady Christians going in but she certainly comes across as an especially passionate and forceful actress. She over-does it a bit at times but no one will ever accuse her of lacking conviction. Film is also noteworthy in featuring a relatively young Charles Bickford (he was in his early 40's) in a romantic role. He seems a tad uncomfortable when required to swoon, so he says his lines as quickly as possible in an effort to get it over with. Guess he was just born crusty.

The real tragedy here is the pairing of beautiful young Betty Furness with that cartoon-voiced scarecrow Sterling Holloway. If Christians' plight doesn't put a lump in your throat, Holloway's charmless, bewilderingly successful pursuit of Furness definitely will.

More Than Just a Soap Opera

[judithh-1 · 8/10 · 11 October 2014]

"A Wicked Woman" hit the screens in 1934. It is a melodrama with a solid core of morality. Nono Trice (Mady Christians) is a young woman living in extreme poverty with her moonshiner husband. On the run from the sheriff, the husband is going to dump Nono and take the eldest boy with him. She can't allow this and ends up shooting the drunken husband and dumping his body in the bayou. The next day she gives birth to her fourth child, a boy with a deformed leg.

The young mother leaves town with the children and begins to turn herself into a different woman through education. She is an extremely strict disciplinarian--so harsh that a modern viewer would disapprove. She changes her name to Naomi Stroud and eventually becomes a high end dressmaker.

When the children grow up, Naomi cannot let go of them, trying to hold them in childhood for their own protection. They, naturally, rebel-- discovering alcohol, dancing and dating. Naomi herself acquires a boyfriend in the person of a local newspaper editor (Charles Bickford). The youngest girl (Jean Peters) is dating a young, sleek and villainous Robert Taylor. Taylor is a louse who ends up injuring Curt (William Henry), the oldest boy. Naomi bargains with God (for the second time) that if Curt lives she will go back and turn herself in for murder.

Naomi's defense is that she was protecting her children but she produces no children in court and is about to be convicted. At the last moment her whole family arrives, with her boyfriend, and she goes free and marries the boyfriend. The cast also includes Betty Furness as the older daughter and Sterling Holloway as her boyfriend.

So why is this more than a soap opera? Because Naomi is self-sacrificing (perhaps a bit much so) but she is determined to better herself and bring her children up to be responsible citizens. In our current era of anything goes, this message probably seems laughable to many viewers. Education, honesty, propriety and courage may seem out of date, but they are not.

Note: At this point MGM did not know what to do with Robert Taylor. No one anticipated that he would eventually earn the studio well over $150,000,000.

A good film from MGM!!

[SkippyDevereaux · 17 March 2001]

Another good film performance by that GREAT actor, Charles Bickford, and also by Mady Christians. In fact, it is the performance of Miss Christians that this film hinges on, as without her, it would be a very dull film. It is too bad that Miss Christians never had a chance to become a big star in America as she had been in Europe, as she is a very good actress!! This film has one of the first performances of Robert Taylor and he does a very good job, as does all the supporting players in this film. I enjoyed this film and think you will too, if you get to see it on television.

family sticks together in hard times

[ksf-2 · 6/10 · 7 June 2019]

Mady Christians, Jean parker, Betty Furness star in "Wicked Woman" from MGM. Christians is "Naomi", pregnant when her abusive husband Ed decides to leave with one of the sons. Naomi tries to rebuild her life on her own, but of course the sheriff comes looking for the husband, who never seems to be found. Naomi teaches the kids right from wrong, and makes a go of things. opens her own shop. Sterling Holloway is in here as a minor part. he frequently did the voice for winnie the pooh! and one of Robert Taylor's early roles. Charles Bickford is their guardian angel. It's pretty good. almost too sugary sweet.... mom is teaching all the kids right from wrong, at any cost. moves pretty slowly. takes a long time to get going. all's well that ends well.. hopefully. Directed by Charles Brabin... this was the last one he directed!

Wake me up when it's over...

[planktonrules · 3/10 · 11 May 2010]

This is an amazingly dull film that just never seemed to gel for me. Despite a very, very promising initial scene, the film never seemed to capitalize on this or establish much momentum. Perhaps some of this was the leading lady's fault, Mady Christians, as her Austrian accent came and went throughout the film. More of the problem seems to be that the writing was poor--with uninvolving characters and plot.

The film begins with an extremely melodramatic but exciting scene. An abusive husband returns home--announcing he's leaving his pregnant wife and taking his oldest son. When she tries to reason with him, the brute attacks her and she shoots him dead in self defense. While she had LOTS of provocation, she chose to throw the body in the swamp. Then, in an odd twist, she learns that this jerk had just shot the sheriff (but he didn't shoot the deputy) and the injured sheriff came looking for him. So, he's wanted for attempted murder and he just attacked his wife. So why, then, did she not bother to tell the sheriff that she shot him and did the world a favor?! Why not resolve this plot element? And, most importantly, why was this plot element all but forgotten by the next scene.

In a bizarre bit or writing, apparently Christian decides that being nice to her kids will make them weak and irresponsible. So, she becomes tough and a bit emotionally abusive...but she also works her butt off for the kids. Suddenly, years pass and the poor family has somehow made it thanks to Christian's hard work--though, oddly, some of the kids seemed to never age. Now, the story becomes a bit of a soap opera with lots of truly boring subplots--a daughter who wants to grow up too fast and run off with her boyfriend (Robert Taylor), this boyfriend subsequently injuring Christian's son, Christian finding a boyfriend (Charles Bickford) and a variety of other plots. Had the viewer actually cared about these people, then this soap would have been more interesting. But, as it is, the plot elements come but seem to have no impact. And, incidentally, the story just bored me to tears--even if it did feature one of Robert Taylor's earliest screen roles. With a title like "A Wicked Woman", you'd sure expect something wicked or exciting! Too bad.

Mother love justifies murder.

[mark.waltz · 5/10 · 26 July 2018]

After killing her brute of a husband, the long-suffering Mady Christians raises her children with a combination of discipline and love in order to set them on the path to a righteous life. She has vowed that she will return to their home town to turn herself in for the murder so she can atone for her "sin" when they are of age, but not allow them to be involved in her own day of reckoning. Going from the cold dingy cabin with her three older children and new born baby to the lights of the city and becoming a well loved clothing store designer and owner, Christians deals with the typical teenaged angst of the three growing children and the lame younger son who is the light of the family with his goodness. When one of the daughters is exploited by the town playboy (a young Robert Taylor), violence erupts which threatens to send the older son (William Henry) to prison for assault. The family, with the help of Christian's new companion (Charles Bickford), deals with both traumas with the dignity and loyalty that they learned through their mother, even when she had to be "wicked" to teach them right from wrong.

Somewhat sappy but well acted (especially by Christians and an understated Bickford), this is a gripping mother love drama that has many plot holes but isn't wrenching to try to get through. Jean Parker and Betty Furness, as the two daughters, are completely unalike in every way, with Parker set on getting the rogue Taylor to marry her, even if it means losing her chastity, while the easier going Furness spends time with the comically nebbish Sterling Holloway, too much of a clod to be surly to her. The mixture of comedy and drama works here, and it's nice to see Bickford tone down his sometimes brutish manliness to be much more tender, although one sequence of him insisting on being the man of the family (to have the last say with "obey" a key word) goes against the gentility of his character. The trial scene at the end shows Christian's "Wicked Woman" to be quite not so, with Charles Lane as her defense attorney presenting a case that even has an impact on the D.A. In less capable hands and a less magnetic actress than Christians, this could have been extremely cloying, but her performance makes you root for her from the start.