Bulldog Courage (1935) User Reviews (6)

"No, I'm the man who held up the men who held up the stage."

[classicsoncall · 6/10 · 28 July 2007]

This is one of the more solid 'B' Westerns you'll find going back to 1935, with Tim McCoy cast in a dual role as swindled mine owner Slim Braddock, and later as the grown up son Tim Braddock, back for revenge on the outlaw that stole his father's mine claim. The picture even does an admirable job of aging bad guy Williams (Karl Hackett) over the course of the generation that Tim Braddock grows up to manhood, even though McCoy looks closer to his real age of forty four at the time of the film, as opposed to ten years younger as the story suggests. Funny, but this was the first time I noticed McCoy's resemblance to the young Lloyd Bridges, they could have been brothers - take a look!

Probably the most entertaining part of the film had to do with the introduction of explosives expert Bailey, wonderfully portrayed by Paul Fix. If you followed the classic Western TV series 'The Rifleman', you might recognize him as future Marshal of North Fork, Micah Torrance; there are times in the picture that his profile gives it away. Even better, Tim McCoy picks up on Bailey's palaver in a subsequent scene to impersonate someone who actually knows what he's talking about. It's one of the most creative devices I've seen in a Western going back this far.

I had to go back and replay a couple of scenes to be sure, but check out the first time Tim Braddock enters Brennan's mine - there's a sign posted above the entrance that states 'Blue Ridge Mine'. Later, when Braddock and Brennan leave by the same way, the sign is no longer there. It makes it's appearance and disappears again later in the story.

You've got to give credit to the film makers (Puritan Pictures) for maintaining a consistent story throughout, even with the shifting plot elements. It's also one of the few early Westerns where the second billed female lead really doesn't figure very much in the story, even as a romantic interest for McCoy. In fact, she's told a couple of times to mind her own business as the men figure out how to trap villain Williams. Check out the early court room scene that had me scratching my head - when Williams' lawyer objects to the judge! He was over ruled.

"as long as the mine is paying - I'll keep collecting!!!"

[kidboots · 6/10 · 29 November 2007]

Tim McCoy's first film was "The Covered Wagon" where he was employed as an Indian technical director and also did some trick riding.

In 1935 McCoy made 10 Westerns for Puritan Pictures, in which he tried to expand his acting abilities.

Even though he was in his 40s when "Bulldog Courage" was made he was definitely believable in the dual roles he played - that of father and son. Tim McCoy plays Slim Braddock, a mine owner turned stage coach robber. His mine has been taken by the sheriff and as he says in a note "as long as the mine is paying - I'll keep collecting". He is known as "The Phantom" and after he is killed his son, Tim (also played by Tim McCoy) comes back to try to bring his father's killers to justice. His father's old friend is being forced to sell his mine. He is trying to stand firm but his mine is being sabotaged. Joan Woodbury is the old friend's fiery daughter.

Paul Fix, makes an early film appearance as a dynamite salesman. There is a scene where Tim McCoy impersonates the explosives expert in a very insightful way - he becomes very animated and has his personality down pat.

Yes, there are mine explosions before the rather abrupt ending. For 60 minutes, it is a pretty good western.

Solid B-Western

[Snow Leopard · 1 February 2006]

This is a solid B-Western that's mostly carried by the plot, with some interest added by the dual role of Tim McCoy, as a father and son. The story has mostly familiar elements, but it moves at a steady pace, and the production gets decent usage out of generally inexpensive settings and other resources.

McCoy's first character is one of many men who have been swindled by the villain, a dishonest banker who is not above using illegal means, including violence, to seize valuable properties. The fraud victim is succeeded by his son, who carries on the battle against the banker and his cronies. Much of it is predictable, but there are some interesting developments and a couple of good sequences. The best scenes are toward the beginning. The first holdup sequence features some entertaining touches, and the subsequent chase also adds a couple of interesting details.

The father character, who is only in the first few scenes, is actually the more interesting of the two. McCoy also gives him quite a bit more personality and depth than he gives the son, who is the main character the rest of the way. Joan Woodbury is nice to look at as the daughter of his father's old associate, but her limited role doesn't give her very much to work with. The supporting cast features a few good moments from Paul Fix, as one of the banker's shady contacts.

There are some obvious ways that it could have been better. The son character is one-dimensional and is not really that interesting, at least when compared with his father. The editing is also rather ragged throughout the movie, which occasionally becomes a distraction. But the pluses are easily enough to make it entertaining and to be worth watching for the hour or so that it runs.

The Revenge of the Son of the Phantom

[wes-connors · 3/10 · 28 December 2007]

Western miner Tim McCoy (as Slim Braddock) is cheated out of his claim by Karl Hackett (as Williams), but he can't prove anything. So, he becomes "The Phantom" bandit, and robs stages carrying Hackett booty. During a confrontation, Mr. McCoy is wounded; he dies in the care of son Eddie Buzard (as young Tim Braddock). Mr. Buzard quickly grows into McCoy (as old Tim Braddock), which is the main Braddock role. After pretty Joan Woodbury (as Helen Brennan) is introduced, the characters' ages are difficult to discern.

McCoy is an odd "Phantom"; he makes no effort to hide his identity, and is plainly visible as "Slim Braddock". He also terrorizes citizens with kindness, and makes minor repairs on the coaches he robs. The most entertaining part of "Bulldog Courage" occurs when Paul Fix (as Bailey) arrives to blow-up a mine; he really uses his "noodle." After Mr. Fix is detained, McCoy does a wild impersonation of "Bailey"; with his obvious ability to memorize dialogue, and capture a character, "Braddock" should have been an actor instead of a minor.

Chock full o' B-Western clichés and dull performances

[planktonrules · 2/10 · 26 July 2009]

The film begins with a Robin Hood-like bandit fighting the forces of evil (lawyers and the like). When he's shot and lies dying, he passes on his legacy to his son. This kid grows up to become Tim McCoy and carries on his father's one-man crusade against lawyers and bankers and telemarketers (okay, the last one wasn't in the film).

Okay, it's best I admit up front that I am not a huge fan of B-Westerns--especially the series films of Gene Autry, Roy Rogers and the like. I have nothing against them, but after seeing just a few I just can't see much difference between them. On a lark, I decided to watch my first Tim McCoy film and found that it really wasn't any different. Like the typical series film, Tim never seems to shoot anyone except in the hand, he catches people trying to murder him and takes their guns--then lets them go, and never slugs anyone unless it absolutely can't be helped. Now I understand that he's playing a good guy, but this routine is ridiculous. For example, in one case, a man shoots at him as he's riding his horse. McCoy pretends to have fallen off the horse and died. And, when the perpetrator comes to look for the body, he's caught by Tim. Tim doesn't hit him, shoot him or even yell at him--just takes his guns and tells him to git! No one is THAT wonderful! If Gandhi had lived in the Old West, I bet he would have plugged a guy who tried to bushwhack him like this--or at least busted him up a bit!! The complete and total lack of realism or violence of any kind make this a film only for the most undemanding audience.

The bottom line is that although in real life Tim McCoy was a great guy (look at his WWI and II record for proof of this) but he has all the on-screen charisma of a block of blue cheese! By comparison, he makes Autry, Rogers and the Lone Ranger look like Howie Mandel on crack--he's THAT dull! It's like he's just walking through the film, trying to be sure to keep his blood pressure under 100/70. Heck, the guy never even breaks a sweat!

Mediocre Western.

[DigitalRevenantX7 · 3/10 · 24 January 2017]

Slim Braddock, a mine owner who was cheated out of his mine by Williams, a shady businessman, becomes a bandit, robbing any stagecoach that carries Williams' ill-gotten profits. Williams sends a posse out to kill him. Slim is fatally wounded but manages to save his son Tim from the posse. Years later, Tim takes up his father's fight & tries to save a family from ruin by protecting their mine from Williams' plans to demolish it.

To be honest, I'm not much of a fan of Westerns. Aside from a few notable exceptions – the Sergio Leone spaghetti Western trilogy & the likes of Rio Bravo and anything Clint Eastwood makes – the genre has been highly limited in what kind of story it could tell about life on the Wild West. And the stories that it did manage to tell were highly simplistic & followed an unfairly rigid pattern of clichés.

Bulldog Courage is a minor effort from the early days of the "talkie" – the 1930s to be exact. The story is nothing more than a simple Robin Hood-style tale that is heavily clichéd & almost completely one-dimensional. That said, there are some minor high points in the production – everyone gives a passable performance, particularly Tim McCoy, who excels in the dual roles he is given & Paul Fix is hilariously daft as the jittery demolitions expert hired by the villain to blow up the mine. The biggest bugbear I had with this flick was the el cheapo DVD's poor quality – the film ends abruptly with a shootout that is unresolved (probably due to poor quality of the original master copy).