High, Wide and Handsome (1937) User Reviews (14)

Scottie shows off his acting chops

[HotToastyRag · 7/10 · 23 July 2021]

The first fifteen minutes of High, Wide and Handsome are very silly. Irene Dunne, her father Raymond Walburn, and his sidekick William Frawley are part of a snake oil salesman act. Then their wagon (full of oil) burns up and they're left with nowhere to go. Randolph Scott and his mother Elizabeth Patterson put them for the night. You might as well fast-forward through all that because it's so stupid you'll want to turn it off. I actually did turn it off, only to resume it a couple of years later for Randolph Scott's time as Star of the Week.

The rest of the movie is really good, so I'm glad I gave it another chance! No one knows exactly why Randolph Scott left traditional Hollywood and did westerns with his own production company, but when you see him in the 1930s, you'll see him giving his heart to different performances. Although his westerns were very popular, my heart aches that he wasn't given the A-tier Hollywood movies. He could have easily stepped into Shane, High Noon, or any John Wayne flick. He had the talent, the looks, and the onscreen energy to take Hollywood by storm. But I've never seen him exercise his acting chops more than in this movie. In one passionate speech, he's actually moved to tears in order to inspire the workmen to finish the job. He's romantic, determined, and ambitious, convinced that there's oil in the hills. No matter what anyone says, he continues to drill - and one day, it all pays off. But Irene loves him for the country bumpkin he used to be; will everything change when they're rich?

This movie didn't need to be a musical, especially since Irene Dunne only sings a few songs that don't really matter to the storyline. Scottie McScottie Pants never sings, but he does get to gaze adoringly at her as she serenades him. They have such fantastic chemistry together in this movie (and a steamy bedroom kissing scene) it makes you wonder if the sparks flew off the screen, too. With the love shining from his eyes, his blonde curls, and his strong muscles as he drills for oil, you almost forget anyone else is in the movie. But there is Irene Dunne, who loves him above all else, and you'll also see Dorothy Lamour briefly, and a young, brown-haired Charles Bickford!

The story itself is interesting...the singing is unnecessary.

[planktonrules · 6/10 · 17 August 2019]

Without all the unnecessary singing, I'd score this on a 7 or possibly an 8...as I really did enjoy the plot. But the singing was a distraction...and what's worse is that it wasn't very good. I love Irene Dunne as an actress but as a singer...well, she was a fine actress.

The story is an unusual one because it's about the nation's first oil wells which were created in Western Pennsylvania in 1859. It begins just before this and a medicine show arrives in town. After a freak fire breaks out and leaves the show stranded, some of the locals take in the medicine show folk. One of them is Sally (Irene Dunne) and soon she is in love with the son of the old lady who took her into her home. As for Peter (Randolph Scott), he looks like a perfect catch for Sally...but little does she know that he's about to strike oil and the oil business would dominate their marrage and sour it as well.

In many ways, this reminded me of the later MGM film "Boom Town", as it's also about the oil business as well as its negative impact on a new marriage. Both are worth seeing, but I'd prefer "Boom Town" simply because it lacks the pointless songs of "High, Wide and Handsome"....none of which are memorable and just seem unnecessary.

Overall, worth seeing IF you don't mind the songs. The finale is pretty neat and the acting quite good.

Oil on the east coast explodes...with song!

[mark.waltz · 7/10 · 11 September 2016]

O.K., I thought I'd never see a musical about the creation of an oil pipeline. I knew that Larry Hagman could sing, but this isn't about the Ewing's of Texas. It's about Randolph Scott, his singing bride Irene Dunne and oil wells in Pennsylvania. Like a monopoly game, this takes the viewer a chance to ride on the Pennsylvania railroad through a little town named Titusville, just spitting distance from Lake Erie.

Like many musicals set in this era, it starts with a medicine man (Raymond Walburn), introducing his daughter (Dunne) who sings the title song, an instant hatred between Scott and brutish Charles Bickford, a fire that destroys Walburn's wagon and their being invited to stay with Scott's no- nonsense granny (Elizabeth Patterson), and the sudden love between Dunne and Scott.

Songs by Jerome Kern and Oscar Hammerstein II give the impression that this is an intended follow-up for Dunne after the previous year's tremendously successful film version of "Show Boat". It's certainly unique, but the story isn't anywhere near as groundbreaking as that was, although it is unique. Songs pretty decent too.

In her first scene, saloon singer Dorothy Lamour looks rather garish, like something out of a Carol Burnett show sketch. Her attempts to emulate Helen Morgan fall short, although she does play an important part in Scott's rivalry with Bickford and the equally ruthless Alan Hale Sr. whose overly high prices to ship Scott's oil causes him to create the pipeline. Patterson, as usual, has some great moments, even getting to sing a bit of the title song in a duet with Dunne. A youngish William Frawley also adds a few laughs as one of the medicine show employees, getting to sing solo as well.

Dunne Sings "The Folks Who Live on the Hill"

[drednm · 14 September 2005]

High, Wide, and Handsome is a forgotten gem of a movie from 1937. Jermone Kern and Oscar Hammerstein created this sprawling musical adventure for the screen following the popularity of the 1936 film version of their musical, Show Boat, which also starred the great Irene Dunne.

Here Dunne plays a singer in a traveling snake oil show run by her father (Raymond Walburn). They bottle "rock oil" and sell it as an elixir. Dunne sings and dances in the show while daddy hawks the tonic. William Frawley plays a fake Indian who is also part of the show. After their wagon burns down, they are taken in by a local farmer (Randolph Scott) and his grandmother (Elizabeth Patterson). Of course Scott and Dunne fall in love, but Scott is sidetracked by his ideas for drilling for oil in 1850s Pennsylvania.

Songs, romance, and action combine to make this an unusual film as the couple battles the local bible thumpers as well as the crooked railroad men, led by Alan Hale. Along the way Dunne rescues a saloon singer (Dorothy Lamour) and runs away with a traveling circus. They pack a lot of story into this 112-minute film.

Dunne is, as always, a total pleasure to watch. She gets to sing almost all the songs in this musical (Scott never sings) and duets with Lamour on "Allegheny Al." The best song is the wonderful "The Folks Who Live on the Hill," which Dunne sings in closeup with a gentle breeze rustling apple blossoms and her lace bonnet. Scott is good in a role usually played by Joel McCrea, but Scott and Dunne have good chemistry. They also worked together in Roberta and My Favorite Wife.

Supporting cast is fine, headed by Patterson as the feisty grandmother, Walburn as the father, Frawley as the Indian (he also gets a number), Ben Blue as a mute, Lamour as the dumb-cluck who sings "The Things I Want" in fabulous close-up, Hale as the corrupt railroad man, Helen Lowell as a gossip, Irving Pichel as the bible thumper, and Akim Tamiroff as the saloon owner. Also of note is Charles Bickford is the bully. Bickford had starred with Dunne is the previous No Other Woman.

Worth looking for.

Good "Eastern Western" Musical Sustained by Paramount Polish

[boblipton · 6/10 · 17 August 2019]

This beautifully presented Hammerstein-Kern musical is about the oil rush in western Pennsylvanian just before the Civil War. With oil wells gushing, farmer Randolph Scott and circus singer Irene Dunne fall in love and get married; the wedding ceremony is capped by the well on his land coming in. Yet that harbinger of prosperity is the death knell of their marriage, as laughing railroad tycoon Alan Hale determines to take over the industry, and Scott has to work hard, and Irene sees their love slipping away. So she returns to the circus.

Paramount obviously had high hopes for this movie, assigning Rouben Mamoulian to direct and cinematographers Vic Milner and Theodore Sparkuhl to supervise the cameras. The cast is likewise excellent: Dorothy Lamour, Raymond Walburn, William Frawley, Charles Bickford, and Akim Tamiroff are just two of the actors adding their talents to the spectacle.

Unhappily, the score is not among the best of the Hammerstein-Kern efforts. Other reviewers have expressed their admiration for Miss Dunne's rendition of the sentimental "The Folks Who Live on the Hill." I prefer Frawley's "Will You Marry Me Tomorrow, Maria?", but there isn't much to it, and and old-fashioned orchestration -- suitable for the 1860 setting -- makes the songs unmemorable.

What's left is the "little guys against greedy capitalists", and there are some beautifully shot sequences, especially when the circus (complete with elephants) comes to the rescue of the men building the pipeline. Yet while the camerawork makes the movie always engaging, the tired story and bad score limit it to that.

In the days of Old Pennsylvania

[lugonian · 8/10 · 31 January 2003]

HIGH, WIDE AND HANDSOME (Paramount, 1937), directed by Rouben Mamoulian, is an underrated musical-drama set in the great outdoors of old Pennsylvania, circa the 1850s. Done in elaborate style, it stars Irene Dunne, following her recent success to the 1936 screen version of SHOW BOAT (Universal). Currently riding high and wide with her brief cinematic period in movie musicals (1935-1938) before focusing more on comedy and dramas, Dunne is cast opposite the tall and rugged Randolph Scott for the second time, the first being ROBERTA (RKO Radio, 1935) opposite Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers. With a handful of contemporary song and dance, college, and backstage musicals hitting the theaters during this period, HIGH, WIDE AND HANDSOME (is the title pertaining to Randolph Scott or the scenery of old Pennsylvania?) takes a different turn in locale, combining outdoorsy western scenery with songs that has been said to have been an inspiration to the highly popular Rodgers and Hammerstein Broadway 1943 musical, OKLAHOMA, and others like it.

The story begins with Sally Watterson (Irene Dunne), a young girl traveling with her medicine sideshow father named "Doc" (Raymond Walburn), singing the title song as they settle in a western Pennsylvania town. As "Doc" tries selling some medicine bottles to his patrons, which proves to be a fraud by spectator Peter Cortlandt (Randolph Scott), a fight ensues amongst the crowd, damaging their wagon. Being given the hospitality of her home by Peter's grandmother (Elizabeth Patterson), the stranded Sally earns her keep by helping with the farm animals, and soon gets to know and love Peter, a rugged oil prospector, whom she eventually marries. Their marriage, at first, is a happy union, until Peter neglects his wife in favor of keeping his promise with the neighboring farmers by banding together in laying oil pipelines in order to prevent Red Scanlon (Charles Bickford), a corrupt railroad president, from monopolizing the industry. After Sally is found entertaining on top of the table in the barroom with Molly (Dorothy Lamour), a saloon girl she and Peter had earlier rescued from a lynch mob, the couple find themselves in an argument which sends Sally to leave her husband and return to life entertaining in the passing circus show and to her father, while Peter tries to fulfill his pipeline dream, which, at the present time, proves to be more important than trying to find Sally and resolve matters. The elaborate and well staged sequence with thousands of prospectors racing against time to get the gigantic oil pipeline finished on schedule is almost similar to King Vidor's conclusion of OUR DAILY BREAD (1934) where the farmhands are seen rushing to ditch a waterway in order to save their dying crops, but with this production, an added bonus of rugged fighting scenes and one near miss scene adding to the suspense in which the unconscious Scott is nearly crushed by a falling pipe that lands inches from his head. Whew!

Almost forgotten today and rarely seen in recent years, HIGH, WIDE AND HANDSOME has its share of good tunes, with music and lyrics by Oscar Hammerstein II and Jerome Kern, including: "High, Wide and Handsome," "The Simple Maiden," "Can I Forget You?" (all sung by Irene Dunne); "Will You Marry Me Tomorrow, Maria?" (sung by William Frawley); "The Folks Who Live on the Hill" (sung by Irene Dunne); "The Things I Want" (sung by Dorothy Lamour); "Allegheny Al" (sung by Dunne and Lamour) and "Can I Forget You?" (reprise by Dunne). Of the songs, "The Folks Who Live on the Hill," sung by Irene Dunne wearing her old-fashioned wedding gown, comes off best and memorably, as she sings it to her new husband, Peter (Scott) after showing her the dwelling they are to live. Another memorable moment is seeing William Frawley (years before his "I Love Lucy" TV series days in the 1950s) in full voice singing "Will You Marry Me Tomorrow" during a ceremony. While Irene Dunne is no Jeanette MacDonald or Grace Moore when it comes to vocalizing, many forget how well she singing delivery is, and she does it quite well, but unfortunately, on the whole, the songs did not become as immortal as the other Hammerstein and Kern scores.

In the supporting cast are Alan Hale as Walt Brennan, the head of the transportation syndicate; Akim Tamiroff as the foreign gambler, Joe Varese; Irving Pichel as Mr. Stark; Lucien Littlefield, Purnell B. Pratt, and some light "comedy relief" supplied by Ben Blue playing Zeke, a hired hand. Raymond Walburn, a fine character actor appearing here as Irene Dunne's father, performs his task well, almost as if this role were intended with W.C. Fields in mind, especially with similarities in his medicine show man who tries to defraud his public with phony medicine bottles, etc.

Running ten minutes short of two hours, HIGH, WIDE AND HANDSOME is entertaining, quite original for its time, but sadly, a neglected item. A lot of effort went into this nostalgic production, and it shows. The only thing missing, and a real oversight, is Technicolor. Around this time, Paramount produced some fine Technicolor outdoors films, notably THE TRAIL OF THE LONESOME PINE (1936) with Sylvia Sidney, and EBB TIDE (1937) with Frances Farmer. How cinematic this handsome film would have looked in color. But overlooking this minor flaw, it's a movie worth seeing through once, and after its THE END title and list of actors and their roles (and underscoring to "The Folks Who Live on the Hill") before the final fadeout, it may make one wonder why this is among the rarely-seen western-type musicals gems (even with Turner Classic Movies showing August 16, 2019) from the "golden age of Hollywood" period. (***1/2)

The Folks Who Live on The Hill

[HarlowMGM · 8/10 · 13 April 2011]

HIGH HIDE AND HANDSOME is an big expensive Paramount musical directed by Rouben Mamoulian that tries to combine a MGMesque romantic musical production with a Cecil B. DeMille-sized dramatic epic with fairly successful results thanks to a lovely original Oscar Hammerstein III - Jerome Kern score and an excellent cast headed by Irene Dunne, Randolph Scott, Dorothy Lamour, Elizabeth Patterson, Alan Hale, Charles Bickford, Ben Blue, Raymond Walburn, and William Frawley.

Irene Dunne stars as a singer/dancer who travels the country as part of pop Raymond Walburn's medicine show. When the medicine show wagon burns up during a stint in Pennslyvania, Dunne, Walburn, and faux Indian entertainer William Frawley are stranded and put up for the night by farmer Randolph Scott and his grandmother Elizabeth Patterson. The trio works their way into Scott and Patterson's heart and stay on as help to earn their keep until Walburn can rebuild an old wagon Scott has given him. Irene and Randolph fall in love and she encourages him with his dream as he drills for oil on the family homestead. When the wagon is built and it's now time to go, the sheepish Scott can't bring himself to propose to Irene but as the wagon leaves and encouraged by grandma, Scott rides off to meet them and fetch Irene back.

At their wedding, the oil well hits a gusher and Scott and the local farmers are ecstatic about their potential fortunes. Alas, evil railroad magnate Alan Hale is out to milk them of every penny of profit by excessive fees to ship the oil on his railroad, hoping to make them sellout to him. Scott gets a brainstorm to build a pipeline to move the oil which Hale repeatedly attempts to thwart with his gang. Meanwhile, the Scott-Dunne union is crumbling due to his excessive devotion to the oil wells and when Irene is seen by Randolph singing in a saloon along with her poor friend Dorothy Lamour, a former shanty boat singer whom Irene is trying to help land a job, they have a big fight and Irene leaves to join her father in his current position with a traveling circus. Meanwhile, Hale continues his dastardly plans to ruin Scott's pipe dreams.

Irene Dunne is excellent as Sally, the rather elegant medicine show entertainer and Randolph Scott more than holds his own in a superb performance as her dashing bucolic white knight. Irene has several beautiful numbers including the classic "The Folks Who Live on the Hill". Dorothy Lamour is also excellent as the saloon singer who at one point is run out of town by the prudish "good people" of the area and sings the very lovely "The Things I Want". Elizabeth Patterson is always an asset to a movie and has one of her larger film roles here as the tough but loving grandmother and terrific comic support is supplied by William Frawley (who has also has a good song number at the wedding) and Ben Blue.

HIGH WIDE AND HANDSOME appears to have been only a modest success at the box office and is one of the least seen Irene Dunne films, as of early 2011 I don't believe it's ever aired on a cable network nor has it ever been released on video or DVD. While not a classic and not without it's flaws (the oil saga with good guys fighting powerful villains has perhaps been done in too many old films and the surprise heroes of the final reel give a rather absurd touch to the climax) it deserves to be seen and it's excellent songs and performances and beautiful set design and cinematography make it a quite memorable movie musical.

Our Jerome Kern Girl

[bkoganbing · 8/10 · 12 December 2007]

Irene Dunne had the good fortune in her singing films to have one of the greatest of American composers writing for her. In her career she did the lead roles in such Jerome Kern classics as Showboat, Roberta, and Sweet Adeline. And also she Kern write songs for the screen for her in Joy of Living and this film High Wide and Handsome. She was for a while known as the Jerome Kern girl of the screen.

For reasons I don't understand, except for Showboat she was not given a singing leading man. The story lines were rewritten to give her all the good songs and the leading man none. Not that Donald Woods in Sweet Adeline or Douglas Fairbanks, Jr. in Joy of Living or Randolph Scott in Roberta and High Wide and Handsome had any ambitions to sing, but it might have been nice to have her teamed with someone like Allan Jones again as she was in Showboat.

High Wide and Handsome is set in western Pennsylvania just after Edwin L. Drake invented the first practical oil derrick to drill for the stuff. Up to that time oil was considered a nuisance at best, a positive calamity at worst for some poor farmer who had the stuff oozing through to his soil. Randolph Scott is such a farmer who has the idea of marketing for heating fuel.

Others agree with him including Alan Hale who is in a part normally reserved for Edward Arnold. He's the boss of the railroad and who would be shipping the stuff and at the rate he determines, but him only.

Not beaten Scott conceives the idea of the first oil pipeline and then its a fight to the finish with the Hale and the railroad. By the way in real life this is how John D. Rockefeller cornered the oil market and gave the Rockefeller family the wealth it enjoys today.

Irene Dunne is in a medicine show that breaks down and she, Raymond Walburn and William Frawley are given shelter by Scott and his grandmother Elizabeth Patterson. Of course the usual boy/girl stuff happens.

Scott's an earnest of guy, but a bit of a prude as well. Later on when Dunne aids another entertainer in trouble, Dorothy Lamour, Scott and she break up when he finds the two of them trying to put over an act in a saloon to get her hired.

Two very big songs for Jerome Kern and Oscar Hammerstein, II came out of High Wide and Handsome both sung by Dunne, Can I Forget You and The Folks Who Live On The Hill. Again this was a case of one hand washing the other as Paramount no doubt convinced the leading singer in America who by no coincidence was a Paramount contact player to record them and plug them on his radio show. Bing Crosby's records of them are classic and they sold a few platters back in the day. In fact why didn't they have Bing in this film? It certainly had more of a budget than the musicals Paramount was giving him.

Other villains in High Wide and Handsome are Charles Bickford and Irving Pichel. Bickford is just a plug ugly who does Hale's dirty work and probably would pay Hale to do it for him as he and Scott hate each other and that's made clear right at the beginning of the film. Irving Pichel plays a strange Puritan type individual, self appointed keeper of the community morals. His was a strangely underdeveloped character in the script that Oscar Hammerstein, II wrote.

Rouben Mamoulian who directed his fair share of musicals on screen and on the stage did a good job with his cast. And you can never go wrong listening and singing Jerome Kern's wonderful songs.

Important musical! Take note!

[david-1976 · 9/10 · 23 June 2010]

Oscar Hammerstein II and Jerome Kern had already made theatre history with "Show Boat," a deathless example of American Theatre, which is still best preserved by Universal's 1935 production, directed by James Whale (now remembered for "Frankenstein"), a wonderful movie that is also the most perfect representation of Irene Dunne, who is amazing in the role of Magnolia. Every time I watch it, I am blown away by the work of the entire cast, which includes many of the staples of the American stage.

The following year, Paramount hired Kern and Hammerstein to write them a movie, and indeed, the pair came through, writing some great songs for Dunne to sing, and, on the part of Hammerstein, coming up with a script that can't help but remind the literate of "Oklahoma!" in many ways. It also generated two of Kern's most lovely songs: "Can I Forget You?" and the perennial favorite--of singers if not of audiences--"The Folks Who Live On the Hill".

This show is interesting in many ways: one, it takes Dunne back to an earlier time--the 'teens of the twentieth century--in her interpretations, especially of "The Folks Who Live on the Hill," where she elaborately rolls her "r's" and sings in an elaborately formalized manner. It also fails to provide her with an adequate male singing lead, which she certainly had in Allan Jones with "Show Boat."

The story presages the ideas that Hammerstein brought to full bloom in his other masterpiece, "Oklahoma" (Masterpiece number one being "Show Boat".) The archetypes are all there: Irene Dunne as Laurie/Magnolia, Randy Scott as Curly (not the weak male lead required by Edna Ferber), Dorothy Lamour as a somewhat muted Ado Annie/Queenie, Charles Bickford as Jud/Frank, Dorothy Patterson as a peppy Aunt Eller/Parthy, Raymond Walburn as a textually removed but otherwise enjoyable Ali Hakim/Captain Andy (although what could go wrong with Charles Winninger in that role?). Add to that Alan Hale as the supremely evil railroad magnate--any comparison would be a stretch, and this is a perfect example of playing against type for Hale, the consummate cheerful sidekick--and you have a delightful Hollywood ensemble company, and I have neglected to mention the beloved Ben Blue, who probably parallels Rubber Face/Will Parker.

Talk to me sometime about my ideas anent archetypes: it's for sure--at least as far as I'm concerned--that Hammerstein had some definite "slots" in his scripts not only for particular actors but also for particular characters, and you can find them in subsequent hits like "South Pacific" and "The Sound of Music."

My print of "High, Wide and Handsome" was evidently videotaped off a television broadcast: the result is a posterized version whose commercial breaks were edited out; nonetheless, it is a pretty good representation of the film; I don't think that much was missing. Rouben Mamoulian, one of the great directors of film ("Love Me Tonight") and Broadway ("Carousel," need I say more?) added many of his signature effects to this movie, which also may have had some influence from John Ford, but the latter is something I'm flashing on, and I'm not sure what! Please see this sui generis film: it's not a copy of a Broadway hit; it was designed, as were many of Mamoulian's productions, as a film to be appreciated on its own.

Paramount should re-release this movie, in the most pristine version available. There are aspects of it that are antiquated, especially since two years later Hollywood brought us "Gone With the Wind" and "The Wizard of Oz," with all their technical accomplishments; but as a musical film achievement, there is a distinctive place for "High, Wide, and Handsome."

A multi-genre, entertaining film, worthy of classic preservation

[SimonJack · 9/10 · 11 November 2017]

There's a lot packed into this film, and it's all top quality. "High, Wide and Handsome" is a musical with some light humor. It's a love story and drama. It's a pioneering story with adventure, intrigue and crime. It's historical for the time and subjects covered, and the authenticity of the costume and sets. About the only thing it's not, but which it is billed as, is a Western. Perhaps any movie that has horses in it, or that's set before the advent of the automobile, is considered Western by Hollywood. But I doubt if many movie fans or anyone would consider a setting in Pennsylvania to constitute a Western movie.

This is a superb and entertaining movie. Jerome Kern and Oscar Hammerstein collaborated for the music and lyrics, and Hammerstein helped write the story. It has a complex plot with a few subplots, but the screenplay is excellent and the direction, shooting and film editing enable one to follow the story well. Add an excellent cast and first-rate performances by all, and "High, Wide and Handsome" is a wonderful, interesting, and satisfying film. The title comes from a song that Irene Dunne sings in an early scene.

The very talented Dunne has top billing as the female lead, Sally Watterson. She plays the young daughter of a medicine show shyster, Doc Watterson, played by Raymond Walburn. Dunne was nearly 40 years old when this film was made, but appears to be in her young 20s. She didn't get started in Hollywood until she was 32 in 1930, but quickly rose to stardom. Her tremendous talent ranged from drama to comedy, and included a great singing voice, which she used in this film.

Randolph Scott also was 39 years old when this film was made, and he seems to be in his youthful early 20s. Within a couple of years, Scott's appearance would change so that in most of his films he comes across as more his real middle age. Both Dunne and Scott give wonderful performances in this film – running the gamut from light humor, to seriousness with very dramatic and intense scenes, and then to tender moments.

The supporting cast all excel as well. Alan Hale is out of his usual character and plays the tyrant in this film, but still with a jovial nature. He is Walt Brennan, a railroad tycoon who wants to take over the thriving oil discoveries around Titusville. I think it's interesting that the name of the railroad doesn't appear anywhere in the film. Perhaps Hollywood was getting too close to the truth, where fiction might begin to resemble real history. Charles Bickford is very good as the bitter, mean-spirited Red Scanlon who has been feuding all his life with Cortlandt.

Other superb performances are given by most of the supporting cast. Walburn is very good as Doc, and William Frawley is very good as his assistant, Mac. Dorothy Lamour is Molly Fuller, who sings a couple of very good songs. Elizabeth Patterson is superb as Grandma Cortlandt, and Akim Tamiroff was very good in a minor role as Joe Varese. The neighbors and friends of Peter, and some of the circus and carnival players are very good.

Much of the historical and pioneering aspects of the film may have been lost on the audiences of 1937, but in the 21st century, those help make this movie a classic to be preserved for posterity. The story takes place in 1858 and one of the main plots of the film concerns the drilling of the first oil wells. In fact, the first producing oil well in North America was established that year (1858) at Oil Springs in Ontario, Canada. And the first well to be drilled successfully in the U.S. was in 1859 at Titusville, PA. That's where this story takes place, only the well driller isn't the historical Col. Edwin Drake, but Peter Cortlandt, played by Randolph Scott.

Beside the costumes, and pioneer period sets, the movie has some wonderful scenes of props that were the true items of the period. This is one of only a couple of movies I can recall that showed lighting of public places with huge chandeliers of candles. In a late scene, this film has two such chandeliers with many dozens of candles on each. They are in a circus tent when Sally comes out to sing a song. Men in Indian costumes first set up a small circle stage for her to stand on in the middle of ring. Then, they surround the small stage, and crouch down holding torches to illuminate the stage. Of course, the movie doesn't need the torches for the light in the film, but Paramount gets credit for showing this and other aspects about the time realistically.

Here are some other things that the film showed authentically. A wedding portrait took 115 seconds to shoot -- with the photographer counting. Its no wonder that very old photos don't appear clear and sharp before the use of flash photography. When the oil well comes in and oil shoots through the derrick, the wedding party is drenched with oil. And, the building of the pipeline above ground is a touch of reality from the past.

The oil discovery and drilling near Titusville, PA, was the birth of the oil industry in America. Here's my favorite lines from the film. For more dialog samples, see the Quotes section under this IMDb Web page for the movie.

Mac, "I'll bet Sally will be glad to get away from here." Doc Watterson, "You think so, Mac?" Mac, "Sure. She's always fightin' with that Cortlandt fella. She hates the sight of him." Doc Watterson, "You know human nature, don't you Mac?" Mac, "From A to Z." Doc Watterson, "You must have skipped W. The women come under W."

Interesting Genre Mix

[LeonardKniffel · 8/10 · 7 April 2020]

A cross between "The Grapes of Wrath" and "The Harvey Girls" (both of which were made later, the directors having presumably learned not to mix genres) this musical with its David and Goliath message clearly sets out to expose the kind of greed that made America grate time and again, grinding the honest working man to pulverized shreds for the sake of company profits. Told through the courtship and marriage of a farmer and the star in a traveling entertainment troupe, the film is set against the historical backdrop of the discovery of oil in Pennsylvania in 1859 and the ruthlessness of the railroad barons who tried to prevent the poor landowners from building a pipeline. With music by two of the greatest American composers, Jerome Kern and Oscar Hammerstein, this movie should have been greater than it is--not for want of trying, perhaps too hard, causing a confusing split between drama, romance, and musical. Only two songs really stand out, sung by the inimitable Irene Dunne: "Can I Forget You?" and the classic "The Folks on the Hill." The supporting cast is outstanding, with character actress Elizabeth Patterson as Grandma and Dorothy Lamour as the sultry woman of ill repute. Check out William Frawley (Fred Mertz on television's "I Love Lucy") singing "Will You Marry Me Tomorrow, Maria?"

Memorable for the song "Can I forget You"

[ACThomJr · 22 April 2004]

I saw this movie at the Belmont theater in Nashville, TN when I was 5 or six years old. I have been looking for this movie for years. The only thing I could remember was the song, not the movie title, the composer, the actors: nothing but the song and that it came from a movie. Only tonight, 22 April 2004, did I learn the name of the movie. If anyone could tell me how I could get a copy of this movie I would be deeply grateful. Thank you. I have three versions of the song: by Bing Crosby recorded in 1937, by Arthur Tracy, The Street Singer, and by Andy Williams. None of the albums credit the movie or the composer or lyricist. Any information of other renditions would also be appreciated. NEW UPDATE: I now have a complete VHS version of this movie. I would like to thank all of you who helped me in this endeavor. If anyone would like a copy, please contact me and I will be happy to help you also.

Ambition at what price?

[clanciai · 8/10 · 10 April 2020]

No objections against Rouben Mamoulian's expert directing, not against Irene Dunne with her reliable singing and acting either, but Randolph Scott never qualifies as an A-actor, he always appears as rather inferior to those he plays against, and here also the intrigue is rather mellow. His girl Irene Dunne is only good for acting and singing with her circus in musicals, while Randolph's only interest is his ambition for oil and money. How could they possibly go well together without skirmishes? Naturally, Randolph gets enemies for his ambitions, and his great project gets constantly sabotaged by brute force used in foul play by his enemies, leading to one disaster after the other. The finale is grandiose in its final battle, but this is no film for those interestd in human psychology and depth of intrigue. It is a very superficial story of ambition and success, and not even the music is very good - Jerome Kern certainly could do better, and you miss the charm of "Love Me Tonight" and its gorgeous spirituality with a dominating sense of everything important missing.