Abraham Lincoln
Abigail Clay
Mary Todd
Sarah Clay
Efe Turner
Ann Rutledge
Matt Clay
Prosecutor John Felder
Adam Clay
Judge Herbert A. Bell
John Palmer Cass
Carrie Sue (uncredited)
Man with Lynch Mob (uncredited)
Townsman Dancing at Party (uncredited)
New Salem Townsman (uncredited)
Peach Pie Baker (uncredited)
Loafer (uncredited)
Sheriff Gil Billings (uncredited)
Townsman (uncredited)
Townswoman (uncredited)
Sam Boone (uncredited)
Jeremiah Carter (uncredited)
Servant (uncredited)
Hawthorne (uncredited)
Tug-o'-War Contest Official (uncredited)
Mr. Clay (uncredited)
Adam Clay as a Boy (uncredited)
Matt Clay as a Boy (uncredited)
Scrub White (uncredited)
Mrs. Edwards (uncredited)
Juror Bill Killian (uncredited)
Juror (uncredited)
Court Clerk (uncredited)
John T. Stuart (uncredited)
Baby Clay (uncredited)
Bailiff (uncredited)
Big Buck Troop (uncredited)
Party Guest (uncredited)
Dancer in Ballroom Seen Dancing with Old Woman (uncredited)
Woolridge (uncredited)
Stephen A. Douglas (uncredited)
Ninian Edwards (uncredited)
Barber (uncredited)
Apple Pie Baker (uncredited)
Boy on Right of Bean Shooter (uncredited)
Admiring Boy in New Salem (uncredited)