Personally I think several of the opinions here are awfully harsh and take unfair advantage of 20/20 hindsight. Yes, WW2 was horrible--- and you've got innumerable references to topical characters that've faded from the average person's knowledge. But a Ken Burns documentary this ain't! Valid criticism: it suffers from being an MGM musical shot in black & white with a 40-year old Dick Powell who'd had his more than his fill of such stuff. But there's a lot it on the plus side too: Virginia "The Shynx" O'Brian is terrific, June Allyson (possibly where she first met Dick?), Bert Lahr doing some of his finest signature work (it left me wondering why he was never in the running for the Fred Mertz role--- the cast seemed to love him) and honestly, Lucille Ball looks amazing, dubbed voice and all. And there's also the seemingly incongruent mix of Spike Jones and Vaughan Monroe. The stage version was already several years old and several of the (admittedly unremarkable) songs were updated for the war effort. Look for MGM-contract star Mickey Rooney's dad, Joe Yule, in the role of "Shorty," Bobby Blake doing his best to remain on the Metro lot during the waning days of Our Gang and Rags Ragland, less than two years away from his very premature death. This is an entertaining, very loose stage adaption of a modest Broadway hit geared to wartime audiences just wanting to be entertained. Far from a classic but worth watching.
Add a Review
-
jbacks38 April 2008
-
jotix10030 November 2006For having been made at MGM, "Meet the People", didn't get the usual treatment by the studio. The film was shot in black and white and there are no lavish production numbers. The movie was based on a musical revue that played in Los Angeles during WWII. It has its share of propaganda, since most of the action takes place around a navy yard where war ships were constructed.
The best thing in the film are some of the songs that were composed for it. The best song heard on the film is "I Like to Recognize the Tune", composed by Richard Rogers and Laurenz Hart. The other great number is one in which Spike Jones and his City Slickers appear dressed as Mussolini, Hitler, and figures on the wrong side of the war, as they sing a parody of a sextet of "Lucia di Lamermoor".
Lucille Ball plays Julie Hampton. She was at the height of her good looks and cut a lovely figure. Her love interest is played by Dick Powell, an actor with a lovely manly voice who was also at a good point of his career. Bert Lahr, Virginia O'Brien and a young June Allyson, soon to be Mrs. Dick Powell, appear in supporting roles.
The film was directed by Charles Reisner and the black and white cinematography was by Robert Surtees that has kept its crispness in spite of having been shot more than sixty years ago. The film would be a curiosity piece by fans of Lucille Ball. -
utgard1427 September 2023Let's put on a show for the war effort...or some arrogant playwright or something. Dick Powell plays a pompous jerk who somehow finagles a famous actress (Lucille Ball) into not only falling in love with him but also getting his play produced. The movie is basically the struggle to get the play made. The struggle, by the way, is only such because of Powell's temper tantrums. Good grief who thought this character was appealing? Powell is a likable actor but here he sulks his way through the whole film. "My show! My show! My show!" Shut up already you whiny baby. This guy wants his precious play to be authentic to real working class people, but he never seems real or working class himself.
Powell also has poor romantic chemistry with Lucille Ball. For her part, Lucy is a bit wooden and lacking the brilliant spark we all know she possessed. The supporting players like Virginia O'Brien, Bert Lahr, and June Allyson are the best part of the cast. There's also an annoying guy doing bad impressions. I'm not going to bother looking up the actor's name. Just know he's awful.
The movie is way too long for such a thin plot and commits the cardinal sin for any musical comedy: it's hardly ever fun. The musical numbers are so-so, with O'Brien's "Say That We're Sweethearts Again" being the standout. It's probably the only thing that you walk away from this film remembering. -
ksf-224 April 2023One of lucy's (wartime) films before she found her groove in "I love lucy". This one has some pretty big names... rags ragland, virginia obrien, dick powell. Bert lahr ( the cowardly lion) and june allyson. Even dick elliott (the mayor on andy griffith) bill swanson wins a date with big starlet julie hampton. But what he really wants is for her to help put on the show he has written. But when the producer changes it all around, swanson goes back to his day job. Will this show ever get made? Some pretty raw humor, for a show made in the 1940s. Although it's pretty tame, compared to modern standards. Some funny bits. And digs at mussolini and hitler, since the united states had been in the war for a couple years by now. Performances by groups that were popular at the time. It's a little un-even, but the overseas troops were probably glad to see entertainers and familiar faces on the big screen. Too many songs for me. Did bert lahr really need to sing so long? They should have let virginia o'brien do more songs! It's okay. Not much of a story, but great to see all the familiar faces together in one film. Directed by charles reisner.... he had worked with the marx brothers and buster keaton.
-
tedg11 April 2006The movies I choose to watch are sometimes suggested by events. Recently. I encountered yet another incomprehensible act by the American War Department and took refuge in this.
It is from an era of justified involvement in a war. Death camps, master race.
It is rank propaganda, subsidized by political leaders. It has other offenses. Blacks are shown twice: a man as a yassa porter and women happily picking cotton.
And yet its charm is in the thing it celebrates. You likely will never see this. It is dated and not very good as a film. The strings it pulls... well, they're broken. So let me describe it.
It features Lucille Ball before she made herself a joke. In this era, she was a desirable pinup, even at 33. She parades her legs and glamor as a famous stage actress. She meets and falls in love with a wartime shipworker who aspires to be a playwright. He, it turns out, has written a play featuring the good souls of the shipyard representing all the "ordinary people" of America who labored for the war effort, which at root was a competition of manufacturing infrastructures.
That play is the device around which all sorts of narrative effects are folded. There's the bit which forms the plot: she likes the play and attempts to put it on. But it gets too glamorized for the author. It isn't "real" enough and rather than demean the subject, he forgoes wealth and fame and closes it down. She follows him back to work in the shipyard to charm him into letting the show go on. As scripted, she discovers and comes to appreciate the goodness of the honestly laboring people.
At the end, she puts on the play as he intended it to be, at the shipyard. Inside the play's performance, he literally enters the play and reconciles with our girl. End of story.
Along the way, there are an amazing number of other excuses pulled to have song and dance numbers. Its purpose, after all was to mix entertainment and "the message."
So you have:
lunchtime shows at the shipyard (with Spike Jones and Hitler played by a chimp). Also, an evening show with several elaborate numbers.
a love song when the two go on their first date, the song half him demonstrating the song to her and half wooing her in the story by song.
a bit as if the movie were a musical comedy. In this case, the story itself bends into comic song as Burt Lahr's character christens his boat.
imitations of famous war leaders, performed randomly whenever a certain character appears. Some of these are unrecognizable today.
And that's in addition to seeing bits of the title show in New York and the shipyard.
A lot of entertainment. All the shows, every one, are miniature versions of the larger movie: celebrations of ordinary folk and then American values.
Ted's Evaluation -- 2 of 3: Has some interesting elements. -
The songs are ridiculous. What Hitler is portrayed by a monkey, which is appropriate, the words were inane, especially when they kept saying his real last name- Shikelgruber.
At his first song, Vaughan Monroe sounded as though he had his jaw wired. June Allyson belting out I Don't Recognize This Song was also inane, as the words were silly.
As shown in your page, Lucy as Julie Hampton, was a Broadway star and not a Hollywood luminary. She is caught up with Dick Powell, a shipbuilder, who has written a play Meet the People. The two, of course, fall in love, but tangle over what kind of version his play should take, he wants it centered around the ship-builders and the people of war-time and she prefers a more glamorous rendition. He later accuses her of using the play for publicity. What was the headline about jobs being frozen causing the Ball character to remain among the ship-folk?
Bert Lahr also appears, but his funniest scene is where a tuba practically goes on top of his nose.
Silly fanfare with the predictable ending. -
bkoganbing22 June 2009It's curious that the two stars of Meet The People were a pair of movie stars who went into the new medium of television and became even bigger successes and who both went into the production end of things and enjoyed tycoon status on the small screen. Lucille Ball however was not a major star, that would come with television. As for Dick Powell he desperately wanted to get out of doing films like Meet The People and his career salvation would be coming in his next film.
I think the only reason that Dick Powell did the film was because a young player from MGM was cast in a specialty number and he was seeing her at the time. His private time with June Allyson was far better than what we see on the screen. Powell looks crashingly bored and can't summon up any kind of emotion at all.
He was probably tired of doing these musicals with silly plots, the kind he ran from Warner Brothers from. The original show Meet The People was not a book show, it was a revue and it ran in the 1940-41 season on Broadway for 160 performances. When MGM bought it, they scrapped everything but the title and the title song. The rest of the score was patched together from various and sundry songwriters, none of the songs is memorable. Odd when you consider some of the source material is from Burton Lane, E.Y. Harburg, Harold Arlen, and Rodgers&Hart. These guys just must have emptied the trunk for material.
The plot is sillier than even most of the musical propaganda pieces of the time. Powell is the writer of a revue called Meet The People and he's a shipyard worker who wins a lottery date with movie star Lucille Ball. She's interested, he's interested, they're both interested in the revue, but creative differences keep them apart of course until the finale. That's the film in a nutshell.
MGM did give Powell and Ball some good musical acts which are the main reason for watching Meet The People. The big bands of Vaughn Monroe and Spike Jones are here and the highlight of the film for me is Bert Lahr dressed in a commodore's suit like Lou Costello had in the dream sequence in In The Navy. The song Heave Ho is written by Arlen and Harburg who wrote for Lahr, the Courage number from The Wizard Of Oz. And as just about everyone in the world has seen that film, you have an idea of Heave Ho is like.
Dick Powell's next film was Murder My Sweet in which he finally bid a not so fond adieu to musicals. And Lucy would have to wait for television before the world got to see what she really could do. -
mmhorvat11 October 2005I went into this movie hoping for the best. I like wartime musicals in general. Dick Powell and Lucille Ball did good jobs with their roles; however, the writers gave them boring dialog. The love-interest between the two of them was not given any real growth; just suddenly it was there. I did not think much of the music; the best number was the snippet we heard of Spike Jones with "Der Fuhrer's Face." The one complete number that Spike Jones did had little of his great musical comedy; pretty tame stuff,even with the monkey. Bert Lahr's comedy skits were interminable.
There were parts to enjoy: Lucille Ball was quite a looker, and there was a good selection of bit players who really deserved more time on screen. -
planktonrules6 June 2018Although the war industry in the United States during WWII produced huge amounts of weaponry, you'd never think so if you watched "Meet the People"! Although it's supposedly set at a shipyard, you never see anyone work at all! Instead, they sing, dance and put on shows all the time...or at least that's what I learned from this movie!
The story begins at the shipyard and a famous actress, Julie Hampton (Lucille Ball), is there for a bond rally. Naturally, the ship builders are a very loyal lot and they invest heavily in the bonds. What they also have is a soon to be discovered playwright and singer, William Swanson (Dick Powell). Soon he and Julie are working on getting his play produced but soon Swanee stomps off and refuses to allow them to put on the play. The director is sure Swanee will change his mind but when he doesn't, Julie returns to the shipyard to convince Swanee to change his mind.
What follows is essentially a giant talent show spread throughout the rest of the film. Folks are breaking into song and dance numbers every few minutes (complete with costumes that appeared from no where) and practically ANYTHING encourages them to perform. As for me, it felt like a showcase for MGM's second and third stringers....and I felt as if they should have pared down the number of numbers and emphasized the plot more than they did as it was a bit tedious at times. Back when it debuted, films like this were not that uncommon and it probably did well at the box office. Today, however, it seems a bit dated and is more a time-passer than anything else. -
Hup234!28 October 1999This is typical wartime let's-pull-together propaganda, and it's very entertaining. A tour-de-force with a great cast, leading to a riotous "Heil, Schicklgruber!" sequence with the fabulous Spike Jones entourage, and a sieg-heiling chimpanzee as Adolf Hitler! It holds up well today as both great entertainment and as a glimpse into the national mood of the time. Highly recommended to all!
-
SnoopyStyle2 August 2023Broadway star Julie Hampton (Lucille Ball) visits a shipyard for the bond drive. William "Swanee" Swanson (Dick Powell) wins a date with her after some fast talking. On their date, he tells her about a musical that he has written.
I don't like the style of music and it's made worst by the fact that Lucille Ball is not the one singing. I'm definitely more interested in Lucille Ball and her non-singing is a real disappointment. These leads are not necessarily most known for their song and dance. The story is obviously a nod to all the women working the hard-hat jobs. It's even making fun of the Axis leaders including a monkey Hitler. In a way, it feels very constructed for its time and the humor feels forced. The closest to a laugh comes from Lucille Ball putting on her dress. For a moment, she does a little bit of physical humor. Maybe the monkey Hitler got some bigger laughs back when it was released. -
cougarblue-696-8061281 January 2019Lucy has made a few musical stinkers, The Big Street, Du Barry was a Lady, Best Foot Forward, Meet the People is just one more to add to the list of forgettable classics. Yup partner, the old gang Virginia O'Brian, and June Allyson are there to support Lucy, Dick Powell takes over the position formerly held by Red Skelton, or Henry Fonda. As for the music, I'm not saying June Allyson and Virginia O'Brian can't sing, but after the 4th or 5th song you long for the pleasant and comforting sound of a dentist drill. The best part of the music comes from the ever entertaining Spike Jones. The plot centers on a WW II shipyard, in a Stage Door Canteen-ish way. However it's not all that important in this collection of dated gags, and unrelated songs. Lucy is the starlet visiting war industry locations to encourage the folks, Dick Powell ace riveter and unknown playwright, schemes his way to a date with Lucy wherein he presents his play. Will Lucy be impressed by the work of our riveter and bring in backers to actually get it staged? You need to see Meet the People to find out. Personally, I'm going to view The Harvey Girls one more time.
-
mark.waltz11 January 2018Keeping the movie star image going after "Best Foot Forward", Lucille Ball plays a stage star doing her part for the war effort by agreeing to star in a musical revue commenting on the conditions of the factory worker. Unfortunately, author Dick Powell has a one sighted view of what wartime entertainment should be. Hoping to get him to change his mind about how the show should be done, Lucy goes to work in the same factory he works in, one ironically that puts on shows the way she believes that his show should be like. Of course, she falls for him, and hopes that his feelings for her will also open his eyes about the type of entertainment that will keep the audiences uplifted in addition to being enlightened.
I find that unless you are familiar with the styles of entertainment done during this era, you might be aggravated, bored or even angry of what was considered funny in the 1940's. Even I, having studied the war years through movies, theater and music, can be annoyed by some styles of comedy. Bert Lahr, beloved for "The Wizard of Oz", is definitely a comic of his time, and his styles are best in small doses. I cringe at parts of "King of the Forest" and here, he gets only a few moderately guffaws from me. Virginia O'Brien comes off a lot better, but her comic solo about being a physical abuse victim may not be amusing to some. I admit that I found it hysterical the first time I heard her sing it 20 years ago, but perhaps it's her deadpan style that is funny.
Specialties by Spike Jones and Vaughan Monroe's orchestras and a bit of rising star June Allyson offer some swinging moments, featuring a chimpanzee as Hitler and a bumbling actor as Mussolini. Lucy, of course, is glamorous, but the lack of color (which was used to great advantage in four big MGM musicals) is a missed opportunity. Powell, desperately trying to get away from musicals, only briefly sings. This is the type of film that represents an era, more MGM's viewpoint than the real worlds, and not at the top of the line for MGM musicals or the many Hollywood musicals that were rushed into release to keep the public uplifted. It has curiosity value, though, and a few moments shine while others dim the lights of what they had intended on producing. -
mossgrymk7 November 2021This is the kind of film Preston Sturges would have made if he had lost his comedic talent but found an interest in musical rom com. Crappy songs too.
-
inframan5 April 2001Forget the period propaganda or the corny jokes. This movie has some sensational music in it, great arrangements & great singing, especially one of the greatest songs written by one of the greatest teams: Rogers & Hart's "I Like to Recognize the Tune". A gorgeous rendition by one of the most beautiful pop songs ever written or performed. Worth reviving this movie (& then there's Spike Jones).