Add a Review

  • Warning: Spoilers
    "The Feathered Serpent" is unique among Charlie Chan films for a number of reasons. For one, we learn the identity of the master criminal well before the movie's end. Professor John Stanley (Robert Livingston) has kidnapped colleague Henry Farnsworth to learn the location of an ancient Aztec treasure. Only Farnsworth can decipher the Aztec hieroglyphics that may reveal the location of the riches.

    Perhaps even more meaningful for fans of the Chan series, Keye Luke has returned after an eleven year absence to reprise his role as Number #1 Son Lee. The last time Luke appeared in a Chan film was in 1937's "Charlie Chan at Monte Carlo", then with Warner Oland in the title role; he had never appeared in a Sidney Toler Chan film. On top of that, this is the only pairing of Keye Luke with Victor Sen Yung, who again appears as Number #2 Son Tommy (although he was Number #2 Son Jimmy in all the Sidney Toler Chan films in which he worked).

    The movie takes it's name from the ancient Aztec practice of worshiping a feathered snake or serpent. It's a bit difficult getting used to Roland Winters' speech pattern as the Chinese detective in this film, it seems a bit more exaggerated than in his earlier pictures. And I can't imagine why the film makers chose to have Chan run around the Mexican wilderness in his trademark white suit and hat, when a safari suit would have made a lot more sense.

    The end of the movie plays a lot more like an Abbott and Costello film than a Charlie Chan picture. There's a lot of animated fighting and the Chan brothers actually get a bit violent in pummeling the bad guys, particularly Tommy who repeatedly pounds his opponents' head against a stone step inside the discovered temple; it's actually quite gruesome if you analyze what's going on. But probably the most off kilter moment comes when Charlie himself warns his party to be careful in handling a weapon intended for himself - "Poison dart probably dipped in poison".
  • This is a somewhat entertaining little venture. Charlie's eldest sons accompany him into the Mexican jungle to try to find an archaeologist who has disappeared while searching for an ancient ruin. As it turns out, there are other guys who would like to accomplish the same thing and they are holding him prisoner. He has knowledge they want. An expedition set up by the guy's sister heads into the jungle. Once again, the old "light- goes-out-and-someone-gets murdered" bit is used. This time an oil lamp gets put out. Anyway, the bad guy are knuckleheads. People's lives are simply a part of the landscape. Killing doesn't seem to bother anyone. Two other things. In this one, Birmingham (Mantan Moreland) is really tiresome. His whole fear thing really gets tiresome. Secondly, has anyone ever wondered why Charlie Chan is wearing a three piece suit and tie in the jungles of Mexico. At one point he mops his brow. My goodness, he should be on the point of passing out. Just a thought.
  • In a Mexican village, a team of Americans plan a trip into the mountains to search for an ancient treasure and two missing scientists. Charlie Chan stumbles into the case and joins their expedition, along with his number one and number two sons and chauffeur. Soon they are all tenting it, spying on each other and sneaking in and out of camp.

    Bob Livingston is part of the search party but we soon discover that he actually heads a gang that's after the treasure. They have kidnapped the missing professor and are holding him in a secret temple whose hidden door swings open when you step on a certain big rock.

    Roland Winters does okay in a fairly active role as the great detective. Keye Luke is a rather mature and serious Lee Chan. Victor Sen Young and Mantan Moreland, as Tommy Chan and chauffeur Birmingham Brown, are teamed up as usual to handle the comic relief. No explanation is offered for Keye Luke's surprising return to the series; we can only note that at the beginning of the picture the Chans are setting out on a family vacation, and guess that Lee must have been invited.

    The plot is a little different from most in this series--we know who the villain is from early on. The production, of course, is cheap and the dialog seems hastily hashed out, although Mr. Chan does offer one or two of his wise sayings. ("Very difficult to estimate depth of well by size of bucket.") Overall it's really not very good...but enjoyable enough for fans.

    Note: a fun double feature would be this picture preceded by 1937's Riders of the Whistling Skull. Not only is this Chan picture is a remake of that Three Mesquiteers western, but the earlier movie also featured Bob Livingston--as one of the good guys, in that case.
  • Yeah, it's bad but the fact that both Keye Luke and Victor Sen Young appear as No. 1 and No. 2 Sons make it worthwhile. I like the outdoor atmosphere and the wind howling at night. It's like Charlie Chan goes camping.
  • Here, Charlie and crew (Mantan Moreland; Keye Luke & Sen Yung), are on vacation in Mexico. They stumble upon a man, who is in terrible condition, walking in a nearby field. Charlie takes him into his auto and heads quickly to the nearest city for help. The man is delirious so Chan can get little information out of him other than the fact he was held prisoner and he was on an expedition hunting for a lost Aztec treasure.

    Chan arrives in a nearby city and soon meets members of an expedition who are also hunting for this lost treasure. In fact the sick man is a member of their group. The ailing man and another archaeologist went missing during their search. Before the ill man can explain what happened he is murdered.

    Charlie and company join the expedition with the purpose of finding the missing archaeologist and perhaps the lost treasure. Much is made out of the fact that this film features the return of Charlie's son Lee (Keye Luke) and the only teaming of Charlie's Number One and Number Two sons. It's interesting but the screenwriters don't pull off the union effectively. Lee is much more domineering here than he ever was in the Fox films. So it is a bit of a miss, but still of interest to a long time Chan fan.

    Lastly, I'll comment on the other reviews who need to call the Monogram Winter's films garbage. Yes, they don't have the skilled writers of the Fox series. Yes, the production values don't match Fox, and the plots can be a little oddball. But these are solid little mysteries and quite good compared with other independent studios.
  • "The Feathered Serpent" is the only Charlie Chan film featuring both Keye Luke and Victor Sen Yung together as Charlie's sons. Charlie here is portrayed by Roland Winters. He does a very good job, but I prefer Warner Oland in the role. He was also so warm and cheerful. Toler was very good, but more sardonic and sarcastic.

    In this film, Charlie and two of his sons are asked to investigate a gang who has kidnapped an archaeologist to force him to search for a treasure in Mexico.

    Mantan Moreland plays Charlie's chauffeur, Birmingham. I know his characterization is not politically correct today, but what a funny and talented man he was. I always enjoy him in these films.

    By this time, Charlie Chan films were being made at a poverty role studio. As offensive as they are today, I take them for what they were and like them. We cannot view everything from today's viewpoints.
  • This Charlie Chan film is unique in that both Victor Sen Yung and Keye Luke appear in it together. During the climax with the bad guys they handle the rough stuff to bring the culprits to justice and Roland Winters is going to need both of them despite them constantly coming to the wrong conclusions.

    Charlie and the boys and chauffeur Mantan Moreland are on a holiday in Mexico when they hear of the disappearance of an old friend of the Chan family, an archeology professor who has disappeared while looking for Aztec treasure, the equivalent of King Tut's tomb in the western hemisphere. They find a colleague of his friend out on the desert, but no sooner do they rescue him than he's murdered. Another murder follows and the the Chan family leads a search party out on the Mexican desert.

    This film is more of manhunt than a mystery at least to us because the brains behind all the villainy is revealed just about halfway through the film. Why that was done who knows because it robbed us of any suspense.

    That's a pity because for Monogram Charlie Chan feature it's not a bad one.
  • The 'Feathered Serpent' from the title is a reference to Quetzelcoatl, the Aztec reptile god. This is appropriate since the film is set in Mexico and is about evil doers who are trying to steal Aztec treasure.

    As usual, Charlie Chan and his entourage (including #1 and 2 sons as well as Birmingham Brown) is on vacation when murders start taking place around him. First, they find Professor Scott dying and they rescue him...only to soon have an unseen hand bury a dagger into Scott! Considering Scott is a member of a missing expedition who was investigating a lost temple, it's a good bet this and further mayhem are the work of some folks trying to steal the treasure for themselves. However, instead of just making deductions, this one ends with Chan and his party catching the baddies in this temple...baddies who seem willing to stop at nothing to get rich.

    The film has two huge problems against it. First, Roland Winters is the third and least interesting actor to regularly play Chan (there was a guy who played him in one early film). Second, after dozens of Chan films, the stories are getting a bit old and familiar. Not a bad film....just not up the usual higher standards of the franchise...though it is nice to have #1 AND #2 sons (Keye Luke and Victor Sen Yung) on hand for this one instead of the usual single son assisting their father.
  • As most of you probably know, throughout the Warner Oland Charlie Chan films at Fox, his sidekick was "Number One Son" Lee, played by Keye Luke. Lee was the best of all the Chan children and sidekicks. He was charming and funny but you could also take him seriously as a potential detective, unlike son Jimmy (Victor Sen Yung), who was pretty much always played for laughs. After Oland died, Luke left the series and returned here many years later. But the Charlie Chan series was in the sewer by this time. The series was at Monogram and on its last legs with the worst of all Charlie Chans, Roland Winters, as the star. Since Monogram's answer to every problem with the Charlie Chan series was to add more sidekicks, that's exactly what they do here. Welcome back, Lee Chan.

    The plot sees Charlie and his sons Lee and Tommy investigating a kidnapping in Mexico. There's also some stuff about an Aztec treasure but that never goes anywhere interesting. This is the penultimate Charlie Chan film at Monogram. It's crap, of course, as all of the Winters Chans were. It seems likely to me they took some sort of jungle adventure script and shoehorned Chan into it to make it a mystery. Still, it's probably the best of the Winters Chan films because of the return of Keye Luke as well as seeing him team up with Victor Sen Yung as the erroneously-named Tommy. Unfortunately, there's also Roland Winters and Mantan Moreland. You take the good, you take the bad I guess.
  • admjtk170120 April 2000
    Dreadful Monogram Chan film with weak Roland Winters starring. The only item of interest is the paring of both Keye Luke (as Lee Chan) and Victor Sen Young (as Tommy Chan.) Set amidst Mexican pyramids, this is a boring poorly done film. It is sad that Luke and Young together didn't have a better script or budget.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    Oriental detective Charlie Chan(Roland Winters)with chauffeur Birmingham Brown(Mantan Moreland)and both #1 son Lee(Keye Luke)and #2 son Tommy(Victor Sen Yung)is on vacation headed to Mexico City when a struggling man collapses in their view. The man is Prof. Farnsworth(Leslie Denison), who has been missing since his search for fabled Aztec treasures. Before being stabbed to death he reveals his son is held hostage and his daughter Joan(Beverly Jons)hires Chan to now find him. Since Winters signed on as the revered Chan the franchise has rapidly lost enthusiasm and popularity. You would think that the one positive thing being the first movie with Luke and Yung together would save face; but the predictable script only have the brothers providing some comic relief with Brown. Other players: Robert Livingston, Carol Forman and George J. Lewis.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    We begin with a Birmingham driving a car with Charlie in the back seat, Tommy (Victor Sen Young) in the passenger front seat, and behind him a sort-of familiar face, Keye Luke, returning to his old role from 11 years ago, # 1 son Lee Chan. This is the only Chan movie in which sons # 1 and 2 appear together.

    The Chan clan is en route to Mexico City, but their trip is interrupted when they spot a man staggering in a field just off their rural highway. They drive into the field, find a very weak man and take him to the nearest town to find a doctor.

    In this city, they encounter some people meeting in a restaurant with the chief of police. They are seeking two missing archeologists who came to this area months ago seeking a lost Aztec tomb full of treasure. When Charlie leads the chief out to his feeble old man, the chief recognizes him immediately as one of the missing archeologists.

    In the group of seekers are two women. One is the sister of the other missing man, the other his fiancée. This sister persuades Charlie to call of his vacation and go with them the next morning to hunt for her brother.

    Most of the rest of this film takes place in the Mexican jungle, where we see how everyone gets into this tomb by pressing on a large rock which slowly sinks down toward the ground to open a large rock door nearby. Somehow, it closes on its own after the people have gone inside. It seems to have some magic eye to know when the last of the people wanting to enter have come in, for it closes right after the last member of the new party enters.

    I am skipping most of the rest of the plot because many others have already reviewed it. I wish to focus on the scenes that bothered me.

    Almost as soon as he meets this party of seekers, Charlie sits down with them and point-blank tells each of them why they might be suspected. There seemed to no reason for this and the Charlie Chan we've known for 45 previous movies (or at least we've seen most of those, some are lost to history) would never have wanted to tell his suspects why he suspects each of them.

    The chauffeur character of Birmingham was not funny like usual, but just annoying. He kept interjecting whenever Chan was talking with the others about going to try to help them find the missing man, just whining about wanting to go home, and not wanting to go to any Aztec ruin. Throughout the film, every time Charlie wanted Birmingham to do something, the man had to voice his desire to stay away from danger, and to just go back home. It's one thing when he was snooping around with Tommy/Jimmy alone to complain about how they should go back to the hotel, or whatever. But here he was being directed by his employer, being asked to do useful things, and he just kept whining about wanting to go home.

    I thought it cool to see both Lee and Jimmy (who is in the Winters' films known as Tommy, but he'll always be Jimmy Chan to me) together. I thought of a couple of scenes they could have had that would have been cool to see. At the beginning, Lee could have said, "Pop, it's been too long since I've been able to work with you on a case. Are you eating OK, you look different somehow." It also would have been a nice idea if Lee had counseled his younger brother, something like: "When Pop and I used to work together, I always tried to..."

    Indeed for almost the whole film, there seemed to be no real need for two sons...until we got almost to the finish. Then they were there for a big fight scene, quite like the kind the Lone Ranger usually had, where he and Tonto would be at the bad guys' hideout and would suddenly get into a big fight that wound up with the heroes capturing the bad guys. This was extraordinarily unusual for a Chan film, and I guess the director and writers could not figure out what to have Charlie do during the fight.

    What they did was the stupidest choice they could have made. Charlie just stood back with the female and watched as his sons did all the fighting. He threw one vase, I think, but that's it. Understand the fight went on in the small room for at least a couple of full minutes, but the famous Honolulu police lieutenant just stood there and watched. Absolutely pathetic!

    Now throughout this series of films, we expect to see a group of suspects and while we have plenty of chance to see some clues and guess "whodunit" in this film we are robbed of that fun. Almost as soon as someone is murdered, we are told by Charlie that it had to be one of the small group in the room near him, not the man seen just outside the window right before the lights went out.

    And almost as soon as the detectives and the others arrive near the scene of the tomb, we see the ringleader of the outlaws, directing his underlings. It was the person we would have most suspected anyhow, but it was just a matter of seeing how Chan could catch him later, as we knew half a movie earlier than Charlie did who was the ringleader. There was no regular revealing scene at the end.

    Before reading that this script was somewhat lifted from a 1937 movie, it seemed painfully obvious to me that this was a script with Charlie written in to it, that wasn't really designed as a Chan film.

    We didn't get any real humorous scenes with anyone, no guess the killer opportunity, and had Charlie almost appear afraid to enter into a fistfight to help his sons. I give this clunker a 2.
  • I don't comment on many movies, but felt compelled to on this one. I have nearly every Chan film made, (Oland, Toler, Winters), and Winters doesn't come near par, in this one. Good: Keye Luke & Victor Sen Yung, maybe Mantan.. Bad: Everything else. Seems like actors are simply reading their lines. "Action" scenes look like a elementary school play. This one just dragged on. I've made it through it once.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    A very late entry in the long-running Charlie Chan series, "The Feathered Serpent" is cheap, dull and instantly forgettable. For some reason, it shows you who the bad guy is somewhere in the middle, thereby removing the element of mystery from a mystery movie! (although they do throw in a - literally - last minute surprise, for those who stick with the movie until the end, who I suspect are always fewer than those who start watching it). Another problem, which I have had with a couple of other Chan films I've watched, is that the supporting characters (outside of Chan's family and Birmingham) are not distinct enough for the viewer to tell them apart; and yet another is that the sound recording quality is poor and sometimes the lines sound garbled. When you can hear them clearly, admittedly there are a couple of great ones, my favorite being "Number One Son very clever now and then. Must be then!" *1/2 out of 4.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    It's been a decade since Charlie Chan has done a case with his first born Lee (Keye Luke), and he's still putting him in his place. But Charlie (Roland Winters) also has #2 son here, and the family thanks to the script writers, have forgotten that #2 was actually Jimmy, not Tommy. Victor Sen Yung must have kept that to himself as this is the last film in the series for him, although the hint of a sibling rivalry was an interesting element. Luke looks only slightly older and has matured, but the script won't let the character fully act his age, obviously to try and make Charlie seem younger.

    As #1 assistant, Mantan Moreland is back with the comic relief, although Tommy desperately singing "La Cucaracha" over and over does get a few ironic giggles. They are all down in Mexico when they stumble along a mystery concerning archeologists and lost treasure, the sound stages filled with the sound of crickets to make the viewer think they are outside camping. As the second to last film, I wouldn't call this a bad entry, but it's obviously time for the series to wrap up before the series ends up going further south.