Malaya (1949)

Passed   |    |  Adventure, Drama, Film-Noir


Malaya (1949) Poster

Newspaperman Royer convinces government officials of a plan to obtain rubber by stealing it out from under the Japanese. Carnahan is let out of prison to help.

TIP
Add this title to your Watchlist
Save movies and shows to keep track of what you want to watch.

6.7/10
1,020

Photos

  • Valentina Cortese in Malaya (1949)
  • Spencer Tracy and Valentina Cortese in Malaya (1949)
  • Valentina Cortese in Malaya (1949)
  • Valentina Cortese in Malaya (1949)
  • James Stewart, Spencer Tracy, Sydney Greenstreet, Valentina Cortese, and John Hodiak in Malaya (1949)
  • Spencer Tracy in Malaya (1949)

See all photos

More of What You Love

Find what you're looking for even quicker with the IMDb app on your smartphone or tablet.

Get the IMDb app

Reviews & Commentary

Add a Review


User Reviews


5 July 2001 | frank_olthoff
WW II adventure with, er, action heroes James Stewart and Spencer Tracy
(Version reviewed is the 90-minute German-language showing on ARD on July 5, 2001.)

There are two rather unbecoming aspects about this movie, one being its blunt nationalism, the other one its odd casting. Where you would have expected, say, William Holden as the daring journalist and, well, Humphrey Bogart as the cynical hotshot, you get Jimmy and Spence. It's not that they don't act well, but the rôles just don't seem to fit. What a difference with handsome Mexican Gilbert Roland who is chosen perfectly (as Romano).

Journalist Royer (Stewart) gets his rival/friend Carnaghan (Tracy) out of prison with help from official sides (fine thesping by John Hodiak) for the good of the nation, that is, to haul all possible rubber out of British, but Jap-occupied, Malaya for the United States. Of course, the European land-owners give all assistance possible to support the sacred case, including a voluntary beating that Ian MacDonald gets from Tracy. America's raw nationalism was curiously carried right into the German translation: dubious Bruno Gruber (played by "Charlie Chan" Roland Winters) is named Marty Robber (or so) in German dubbing version of 1955, because a badman just couldn't have a German name to German audiences... This should be worth a correction, although the forgery effect is not as high as in the original 1952 dubbing of "Casablanca", that was corrected in a new version as late as in 1968. (Stewart, by the way, is synchronized well by Eckart Dux this time, not by regular Siegmar Schneider.)

Although film's humour is well-measured, it cannot conceal, but rather contributes to, the dare-devil chauvinism, four years after the war ended. Tracy played something of a contrary rôle in "Bad Day at Black Rock", as regards the U.S. relationship to the Japanese.

There's a lot of epigonism of "Casablanca", though not as much as in its immediate successors, in "Malaya". We have Richard Loo's Col. Tomura marching into the bar like Maj. Strasser; Italy's Cortese in the European female part (the story might have done without her, were there not some nice dialogues with Tracy); and the wonderful Sydney Greenstreet, who somewhat resumes his Senor Ferrari rôle (that parrot of his is a blue one, I suppose).

Despite this emulation, Frank Fenton's screenplay has something interesting about it that makes this movie agreeable after all. But it wouldn't have taken the famous leading players, close to miscasts, for something that appears like an MGM "B" production to me. - Worst thing is, I couldn't spot DeForest "Bones" Kelley anywhere around, although he is said to be there.

Critic Reviews



More Like This

  • The Mountain Road

    The Mountain Road

  • Carbine Williams

    Carbine Williams

  • The Stratton Story

    The Stratton Story

  • Magic Town

    Magic Town

  • Thunder Bay

    Thunder Bay

  • Take Her, She's Mine

    Take Her, She's Mine

  • Pot o' Gold

    Pot o' Gold

  • No Highway in the Sky

    No Highway in the Sky

  • You Gotta Stay Happy

    You Gotta Stay Happy

  • The Murder Man

    The Murder Man

  • Navy Blue and Gold

    Navy Blue and Gold

  • Strategic Air Command

    Strategic Air Command

Storyline

Plot Summary


Genres

Adventure | Drama | Film-Noir | War

Should Arya Stark Train at Cobra Kai or Miyagi-Do?

The original Karate Kid decides which dojo best suits some famous fighters in film and TV history.

Watch now

Featured on IMDb

See what movies and TV series IMDb editors are excited about this month and check out our guide to superheroes, horror movies, and more.

Around The Web

 | 

Powered by ZergNet

More To Explore

Search on Amazon.com