User Reviews (12)

Add a Review

  • Column South is directed by Frederick de Cordova and written by William Sackheim. It stars Audie Murphy, Joan Evans, Robert Sterling, Dennis Weaver and Ray Collins. Music is scored by Joseph Gershenson and photography by Charles P. Boyle.

    The Breach Between The North And South Was Rapidly Widening. A Grim Spectre Of Civil War Hovered Over The Land. It Was A Time of Crisis. . .A Time For Choosing Sides.

    Story essentially involves Jed Sayre (Murphy), a friend to the local Navajo Indians, relinquishing his command of Fort Union to Captain Lee Whitlock (Sterling), who after arriving with his sister Marcy (Evans), demands changes to how the Fort is run and expects Jed to end his friendship with the Navajo. When a prospector is discovered murdered it is presumed the Navajo are the guilty party, so setting in wheels in motion for Jed to try and quell the impending war with the Indians and thus having to fight his friend Menguito (Weaver) In the mixer is the impending Civil War, with deserters, traitors and political shenanigans at HQ also taking a hand in proceedings. While Jed and Marcy dance around the inevitable with their love/hate relationship.

    In spite of dangling some interesting narrative threads, Column South sadly doesn't rise above being a routine Cavalry Vs Indians Western. But it's never dull and Murphy fans get the usual committed performance. What is of most interest here is the location for the shoot, shot in Apple Valley, California, it's an appealing Oater location with its surrounding hills and craggy rocks that are formed down in the valley. To my knowledge, Apple Valley was only used in one other Western film, Richard Carlson's Four Guns to the Border in 1954, which is a shame because as I say, it's both a looker and carries a harsh edge that some of the great Western movie photographers really could have done great work with.

    As it is, Column South is better than average, and certainly an easy film to while away the time with. But the running time doesn't allow the interesting factors in the story to get expanded, thus leaving the film with unfulfilled potential. 6/10
  • Westerns that feature a cavalry theme don't hold much attraction for me but this one managed to hold my attention. It has an above average story by William Sackheim that helps - an above average and hard working cast, with above average photography by D.O.P. the Award nominated Charles P. Boyle (Anchors Aweigh '45)

    The DVD copy I was given by a friend is from the Umbrella series: Six Shooter Classics (they really must do something about that silly marketing title). Universal originally used the magnificent IB Technicolor process for this film but this disc is well below average (compared with Umbrella's earlier 'Tumble Weed' that looked perfect). Sound transfer is also below standard. Robert Sterling ('Roughshod' '49) is good as the Fort Commander, with good support from Ray Collins, Greg Palmer (Lee) and Joan Evans. Dennis Weaver does very well as the Indian chief with his motley Hollywood tribe. Music is mostly from the Universal stock library and offers little help. Audie Murphy is reliable as always in his way. Veteran director Frederick De Cordova keeps things moving and probably helped with the good dialogue (as he was known to do). Have certainly seen far worse.
  • Column South finds Audie Murphy as an army lieutenant in acting command at Fort Union in New Mexico. The new commander Captain Robert Sterling with his sister Joan Evans arrives to take over and he's a spit and polish short and his disposition ain't helped when he comes into the fort and sees a brawl going about politics. It's 1860 and the country is getting ready to divide sectionally.

    But it's still one army with a mission to keep the peace with the Navajo represented by Chief Dennis Weaver. But the growing divide may let the Indians conquer and Weaver is one smart and courageous warrior.

    In fact Weaver is the best one in the cast, the one who steals the film in every scene he's in. There's also a good performance by Ray Collins who is a visiting general with a big agenda all his own.

    Column South is a well done western with a good cast and a good story for this cast to perform. Definitely one of Audie Murphy's better westerns.
  • Taking place just prior to the start of the civil war, Audie Murphy plays a junior army officer who is sympathetic to the plight of the local Navajo Indians and is a good friend of Navajo chief Menquito. A new commanding officer who is from the south is appointed to the post who convinced by Confederate agitators to stir up trouble with the Navajo Indians and send Audie and large column troops out on wild goose chase so the Confederates can gain control of the western territories. Of course Audie gets wind of nefarious plot and prevents further bloodshed.

    This film would be an otherwise routine "Indians unjustly forced to go on the warpath by scheming white men" story, had it not been for the Confederate conspiracy angle. Audie Murphy is well... Audie Murphy. If you like Audie Murphy (I do) you will like him here. If you don"t there is no reason why you should like him here. Robert Stirling and Joan Evans are unconvincing as Southerners. Their Southern accents vary through out the film. Film buffs will enjoy seeing many familiar faces in the cast (Bob Steele, Greg Palmer, Russell Johnson, Dennis Weaver and Ray Collins.)
  • An Audie Murphy Western from 1953. Murphy plays a cavalry officer stationed at a fort just before the outset of the Civil War. He is adept w/dealing w/the Navajos particularly the leader named Menguito, played by Dennis Weaver of TV's McCloud fame, but he continues to butt heads w/his superior officer, a transplant from the old South who has recently been joined by his self-righteous sister who has an axe to grind w/any natives (a telling episode occurs when the scout of the base is seen at her window & she raises holy hell). The noose is tightened when a shipment of rifles goes missing & the military higher-ups suspect the Navajos of the theft so Murphy dejectedly conducts an investigation, finds the missing arms & orders Menguito & his tribe to a reservation but Murphy suspects foul play & as his suspicions are deepened, a more insidious plot asserts itself putting all parties on the road to an inevitable clash. More heft is given to this particular story-line then the majority of Murphy's oater output & this one ranks as one of his best which deftly fuses action, drama & racism in a well told package. Along for the ride are Russell Johnson & James Best as Murphy's subordinates & a special mention should go to Joan Evans who's portrayal of an uptight bigot who changes her ways is very vivid & telling.
  • The Civil War is about to break out, and there's trouble afoot with the Navajos on their reservation. Let. Audie Murphy has a good relationship with the Indian Chief Dennis Weaver, but his C.O,, Captain Robert Sterling doesn't trust them and is a Southern sympathizer. So when General Ray Collins, who is in on the plans to form the Confederacy wants the Navajos to revolt, he has Sterling plant guns, then issues orders that if they are found among the Indians, to move them to an inhospitable bit of territory.

    It's a pretty good Audie Murphy vehicle directed by Grederick de Cordova, who would spend decades producing THE TONIGHT SHOW. Joan Evans is Sterlings Unionist wife, and there a nice small role for Bob Steele, Look quick for Denver Pyle as a Confederate spy for that double BONANZA feeling.
  • This movie's would have been much better in black and white.All of the canvas painting of backgrounds would have looked a little bit real... maybe? It had to be tough on Murphy playing a fake soldier. I imagine the actors were in awe standing beside of the most decorated soldier in War World Two. Murphy's baby face always made it difficult for him to be taken serious as an actor. A real life liberal who was playing mostly conservative characters. This film is just a simple western in which the studios used Murphy to draw an audience. John Wayne was always in demand but I never could see why he, Wayne, who, to the surprise of many, avoided the draft while Murphy volunteered and was only 19 years old when he was given medals for his valor. Murphy died broke in a plane crash without ever reaching the stardom he deserved.
  • Column South is an interesting western, fusing drama and tension throughout. There isn't much action but the tension between the Indians and the cavalry is well done. The north-south angle makes it more interesting. The finale ends with a well-made action. It's interesting that the Indians are in the fort firing at the cavalry.
  • This is a passable western but no extraordinary, a routine cavalry versus Indians yarn with thrills, attacks, treason and fort assaults. A standard Western in which Audie and the US cavalry face off and defeat the enemy. Set 1961, New Mexico, earlier the American civil war with Lt. Jed, Audie Murphy, who really efforts to conciliate his troops and the local war-crazed Navajo tribe commanded by Menquito : miscast Dennis Weaver. But his attempts are undermined by the superior officer, Captain Lee : Robert Sterling and a racist commandant : Ray Collins. Along the way Murphy is sent to command a detachment forming a long column across Indian territory while are assaulted by Indians .There are some Confederate sympathizers who undertake dark machinations to Indians follow a warpath. At the end occurs the last flamingo stand at Fort Union . Against treason and Navajo fury, the US cavalry rides!

    This is an acceptable, but nothing special Western in which Indians are coerced to go on war by scheming US commanders who try to gain control Southern territories when next to take place the imminent American Civil War : 1861 to 1865. The picture with various pacing threads was well starred by Audie Murphy, playing in his usual style as an officer who fights to prevent war tensions and quell the impeding battles while has a peculiar love/hate with the heroine . Audie was the most decorated soldier in WWII and performing his self-bigraphy : To hell and back. And he starred a lot of Westerns as Texas Kid, Legend of Sam Guard, Cimarron Kid, Sierra, Legend of Billy Kid, Apache rifles, Night passage, Posse from hell, Arizona raiders, The unforgiven, Red badge of courage, 40 guns to Apache Pass, Guns of Fort Petticoat, among others. Remaining cast formed by nice actors as a tough officer interpreted by Robert Sterling, his beautiful sister played by Joan Evans who falls for Murphy and Ray Collins as cunning commanding who attempts to trigger war between Navajo Indians and cavalry to his command as for the Confederates can gain control of the South territory. And support cast with plenty of familiar faces as Dennis Weaver, Russell Simpson, James Best, Gregg Palmer, Johnny Downs, Ralph Moody, Richard Garland , Bob Steele, Denver Pyle, among others.

    It contains a colorful cinematography in Technicolor by Charles P. Boyle, but an allright remastering being extremely necessary. As well as thrilling and atmospheric musical score by uncredited Henry Mancini and Herman Stein. Well produced by Ted Richmond who subsequently to have an important career financing blockbusters as Salomon and queen of Sabah, Villa rides, Red sun, Return of Magnificent Seven and Papillon. The motion picture was professionally directed by Frederick De Cordoba, though with no originality. Cordoba was a craftsman who made all kinds of genres with penchant for comedy, musican and adventure, in films as Buccaner's girl, For the love of Mary, Bedtime for Bonzo, Frankie and Johnny, I'll take Sweden, He come the Nelsons. Rating 5.5/10. Passable and acceptable.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    The title presumably refers to the peaceful departure of Confederate sympathizers among the Union army at Ft. Union, NM Territory, upon news that war had broken out between the Union and CSA. However, it may also refer to the prior southward troop march from Ft. Union toward Ft. Stanton, supposedly to deal with the increased Apache hostility, but actually to join Confederate troops in nearby Texas. The historic General Sibley, who had served before the war in trying to subdue the Navajoes, did resign his position, along with other Confederate-sympathizers, and led the campaign, mostly staffed by Texans, to conquer NM Territory for the CSA.

    The plot alludes to and combines several distinct historically relevant happenings just prior to and during the early phases of the Civil War in the New Mexico Territory, which then included the later state of Arizona. However, it fails to mention the historical secession of the southern half of NM territory, dubbed Arizona, later incorporated into the CSA as a provisional territory. Initial military events supported the legitimacy of this political entity. But, due to subsequent military reversals, this entity essentially ceased to exist by April '62. The Navajos and Apaches did step up depredations on settlers and the army in this area during the Civil War, after many troops were evacuated to serve in the East. However, the central involvement of General Stone in the film in engineering 'Indian' hostilities and supply shortages to weaken the ability of Union forces to resist a planned Confederate invasion from Texas is pure fiction, if adding considerable interest to the plot.

    There was a historical Ft. Union, to the east of Santa Fe, which did play a significant role in Civil War hostilities. However, in the film, it takes on the character of historic Ft. Defiance, which was established in the heart of Navajo territory to discourage depredations on nearby settlers. As in the film, a large Navajo force did attack Ft. Defiance around this time, although they didn't capture it, as in the film. One of the chiefs in this raid was named Manulito, which somewhat resembles the Navajo chief Menguito in the film, played by Dennis Weaver. The forced relocation of Menguito's Navahos in the film to the hated 'Yellow Spring' has a historical corollary in their forced 'Long Walk' to a hated reservation near Ft. Sumner late in the Civil War. They were repatriated in part of their homeland in 1868. These drawn out events are compressed into a short time period in the film. Thus, the happy ending for Menguito's surviving Navajos in the film takes place in 1861 instead of 1868.

    The Confederate plan discussed by General Stone, to initially capture NM Territory, then capture the rest of the southern portion of the West, and prevent shipments of gold and silver east to support the Union war effort, has a historical basis. Portly, folksy, veteran character actor Ray Collins plays the traitorous General Stone. Poetic justice is served in the General's ultimate fate in the film. General Stone can be thought of as incorporating aspects of 3 historical personages: the thoroughly Yankee blue-blood General Carleton; General Sibley, who tried to conquer NM Territory for the CSA; and, much more obliquely, the (past) second president of the Texas Republic, Lamar, who much earlier dreamed of extending his nation to the Pacific Ocean.

    We might think of Audie Murphy's character(Lt. Jed Sayre) as representing a modified Kit Carson, who served as chief Indian Agent in northern NM Territory before the war, then led army raids against the Apache and Navajos during the war. Like Lt. Sayre, Kit was sympathetic to the 'Indian's' interests, but recognized that their depredations on settlers had to be brought under control. Audie tends to exhibit a stiff smug know-it-all presence. In part, it's justified in this film, because Lt. Sayre has had long experience with the local Navajo, whereas his new commanding officer, Capt. Whitlock(Robert Sterling) is fresh from the Southeast, and subscribes to the the 'Indians' as vermin mentality. The relationship between Lt. Sayre and Captain Whitlock very much reminds us of that between Captain York and Colonel Thursday in the previous "Fort Apache", among some other film examples among westerns. Handsome Robert Sterling is fine in his role as the insecure new fort commander, who reluctantly agrees to act as one of General Stone's puppets in his grand scheme of conquest.

    Of course, there is a woman included, although she plays a very subsidiary role as someone Lt. Sayre initially hates, then gradually falls in love with. Joan Evans as Captain Whitlocks's sister, initially suffers from severe culture shock in this primitive Navajo-ridden fort and surrounds. She's certainly not likable. But, she undergoes a sudden change in attitude after learning Lt. Sayre's reason for standing up for the Navajos and importance in preventing her brother from suicidal encounters with the Navajos. Just why she arrived with her brother is unclear. Awkward!

    In all, I found it an enjoyable Technicolor film, with an interesting plot with some historical relevance. Dennis Weaver was quite good and convincing as the Navajo chief. It does lack any substantial musical or humorous elements. However, "Dixie" and "John Brown's Body" are sung simultaneously by southern vs. Yankee pre-Civil War soldiers, at one point.

    Presently viewable at You Tube, and perhaps Encore Westerns
  • Warning: Spoilers
    If you like Audie Murphy, you will like Column South. Murphy, plays Jed Sayer an Army lieutenant trying to keep the peace between the soldiers and the Indians. The problem is a treacherous Brig General named Storey ( Ray Collins), who knows the Civil War is coming and is for the Confederacy, and wants to stir up trouble. Besides that his Commanding Officer Captain Lee Whitlock ( Robert Sterling). Is also for the Confederacy. Yo be honest, Whitlock is a decent man, but is also weak and is easily manipulated by Storey. Jed also has a love interest, Lee's sister Marcy ( Joan Evans), who goes from a person who despises the Indians and will not eat with them (I do not call her a bigot, because she was very naive), to someone more then just a love interest. Spoilers ahead: Jed, Lee and Marcy are part of a squad ordered to leave the fort with few troops knowing the Indians will attack. However, while they are camped out, Jed finds a letter of Whitlock's explaining the plan to help the South, which will result in people dying, while the Confederates led by Whitlock head south ( hence the Title 'Column South'). Jed and the troops loyal to the Union head back to the Fort, but are ambushed by the Indians. Fortunately for Jed and the troops, Marcy explains she is embarrassed by Lee's conduct and is a Southerner with honor also, and the South would be embarrassed to win this way. Whitlock realizes she's is right, and goes back and helps defeat the Indians ( the Indians attacked because they were framed by Storey for a theft of guns and were forced off their land). Storey who was earlier captured by the Indians had to confess his crime, and the Indians went home. Then the Civil War started, and Whitlock and the other Confederates went to join the South, while Marcy stayed with Jed, The last thing Whitlock said is "Take good care of her." I like the character growth in Marcy going from someone who looked down on the Indians, to the person who by saying what she thought, saved lives, and helped her brother regain his sense of duty and honor. Again it is a very good Murphy Western. I give it 8/10 stars.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    If I remember well, in this movie - and perhaps I confound with another Audie Murphy film directed by Nathan Juran: TUMBLEWEED, there is something very unusual in this little feature. In a sequence, the Indians are inside the fort and are attacked by US cavalry !!!

    Isn't it interesting? I watched it when I was a kid and I was shocked at this time. In the meanwhile, I got this film, but it is lost in my collection and I have no time to search it. Actually, I have them both. If I am wrong, if the sequence of Indians fighting IN the fort against US cavalry - at the OUTSIDE - is in TUMBLEWEED I hope an IMDb user will tell me my error.

    Thanks