All the Memory in the World (1956) User Reviews (7)

Alain Resnais's project

[benoitlelievre · 9/10 · 22 February 2005]

Alain Resnais is a damn wizard! You have to see Toute la mémoire du monde, than Nuits et Brouillards, than Hiroshima mon amour to understand the power of the message being sent there.

With Toute la mémoire du monde, Resnais is setting the basis of his cinematographic project about places of memory. Within 20 minutes, Resnais is surgically, methodically analyzing the national library of France. With an hyperactive camera, he's sneaking, he's smelling, he's feeling this huge building. Very fast paced and organized movie that sets up more than ever, the cut between him and the other directors of the french new wave. In my humble cinephile opinion, Resnais is in a league of his own.

ALL THE WORLD'S MEMORY (Alain Resnais, 1956) ***1/2

[Bunuel1976 · 8/10 · 27 February 2008]

Celebrated documentary short by soon-to-be “New Wave” film-maker Resnais about the mausoleum that is the Bibliotheque Nationale in Paris: whether consciously or not, it’s photographed in a way as to seem like an alien building from some sci-fi piece (a genre with which the director’s ensuing cerebral, maze-like work would be inextricably linked); indeed, it’s the stunning direction and indelible strains of Maurice Jarre’s music which elevate this one above being a mere documentary about a public library.

This fascinating film makes a case for both the intrinsic value of literature of any kind – back in a time when books (rather than the Internet) were the main source/store of information – and the often painstaking conservation of same for future reference, even by generations to come (the inference here being that an analogous consideration should be applied to film as well, involving a relatively similar process with respect to its maintenance).

Incidentally, ALL THE WORLD’S MEMORY is available on the R2 DVDs of both Resnais’ own LAST YEAR IN MARIENBAD (1961; released by Optimum) and Jacques Rivette’s playful but no less didactic CELINE AND JULIE GO BOATING (1974; a 2-Disc Set from the BFI)!

Of building and mind, an excellent documentary short

[Bloodwank · 8/10 · 10 September 2011]

As an aspiring librarian this film holds natural interest to me. And it's fascinating in its perusal of the work of librarians, the conversion of books, manuscripts, letters et al from disparate beings into objects of the one great whole. The one great whole is the core of the exercise though, the film represents library not just as mind, not just one persons process of drawing in, of classifying and cataloguing knowledge, but that of the whole world. A collective mind then, but not a natural occurrence, an edifice constructed purposefully to forestall the overwhelming force of the great mass of knowledge out there. Camera angles show library workers both as ants and masters, atmospheric controls are likened to the control board of Nemo. In the Nemo reference there is both the notion of obscure mastery, and the literal meaning, nobody. So the library seeks to control and make impersonal the corpus of knowledge so that it may be best used, while in its construction and its workers (each representative of operation of the mind) perhaps controls, makes impersonal the mind itself, making it an idealisation of mind, clear and functional. In some ways it isn't much of a human affair in that there's no passage into the thoughts, minds of librarians themselves, what we are seeing is very much an intellectualised, a lofty and philosophical take. One could take from this that its thoughts are undermined, that what we are seeing is not real experience but one mans speculation, but I think the camera gives it more of a universal appeal. Mostly slow, exploratory, pausing sometimes at what is interesting, when browsing the library bowels it takes on the quality of a human visitor quietly browsing. And the intent score from Maurice Jarre gives it a sense of dynamic, of real human impression. And of course for people not versed in how libraries operate this is a first rate primer in the sort of things they do, it has not even dated much despite factors such as the growth in electronic content (though I'm a little dubious as to whether volumes were ever physically inoculated, I suspect this may just have been a handy metaphor though I'm not certain). Overall its a terrific work I think, considerable merit in its own right and presaging Resnais' later work in its use of physical world as headstate, illustration of mind, its twists and turns and shabby corners. Very much worth a look, 8/10

Space of memory, preface

[chaos-rampant · 13 May 2011]

This one prefaces Resnais subsequent work, memory and what forms appear in it. The consistently brilliant touch of this is that he visualizes memory by means of cinema, a space which the camera can literally explore.

Here he stumbles upon a fitting metaphor for the mind, the National Library of France. We see how knowledge is routinely amassed and categorized there, how people daily wade through so much information which then is merely stored away for future reference. What looks frightening to me is not that what is infinite and beyond words is believed that it can fit into shelves, but the megalomania behind the enterprise, the belief that among these shelves the secrets of the universe may be unlocked one day.

But what is stored away there is merely thought or the objects of it. Our civilization destroyed by some imaginary catastrophe, how will an alien visiting the ruins of this library know how we experienced through our eyes a gust of wind or a sunset?

To accommodate with the ever increasing influx of information, we're shown how the library burrows further underground, digging deeper inside of us. Resnais explores this cavernous place with a camera that recalls the future endeavors of Sacha Vierny, and although a bit obvious in what is intended by it, as a prologue of what was then to come, it's a great watch.

Toute La Mémoire Du Monde-Monsieur Alain Resnais has made the best film about books.

[FilmCriticLalitRao · 10/10 · 15 August 2013]

France is one of the few nations in the world where books and literature are held in very high esteem. This is an extremely propitious sign which symbolizes the vitality of the true 'book culture'. This culture finds its reflection in French documentary film "Toute La Mémoire Du Monde" which has been directed by Alain Resnais-one of French cinema's greatest directors. Apart from books, Resnais also discusses all forms of printed information. Although this film was shot in 1956 at Bibliothèque Nationale De France (BNF), French National Library, one could still find intact many of the places shown in the film. This is because even after an interval of 57 years, BNF continues to grow at an amazing pace without sacrificing even an ounce of its resources. One should not wonder if one is told that the use of technology to do all activities related to books have increased significantly at BNF. Toute La Mémoire Du Monde has been shot like a feature film with a mellifluous background score, taut narration and highly professional camera work. As a film, it is an extremely important work of art for students, librarians, information seekers, cultural enthusiasts and anybody who is interested in the enigmatic world of books.Lastly, it must be mentioned that Resnais has used memory as knowledge for this film as it is through knowledge that human beings would be able to overcome all their differences.This is the reason why "Mémoire" is as important as "Connaissance".

A library as a mind

[Red-Barracuda · 6/10 · 9 May 2014]

Toute la mémoire du monde is a short documentary that Alain Resnais made before he became one of the giants of the New Wave. In some ways it does prefigure some of the ideas he would explore in his future feature films. For instance, while this may be a documentary about the Bibliotheque Nationale in Paris, it is also interested in exploring the mazes of the mind; in this respect it has much in common with Resnais most famous film Last Year at Marienbad. We look at this famous library and liken it to a physical representation of a mind. We see how knowledge is organised within it, with the purpose of storing it away for some future reference not yet known. The library is depicted as a growing entity; almost alive. As more books are published it burrows deeper into the ground to accommodate them and to ensure that the memories of our culture are never lost.

Aside from this, it works as an interesting look at a famous institution. When you watch it now, it's difficult not to think that the smallest of computers could now store the entire contents of the library back then. Advances in technology have changed things irrevocably. But I like to think that this old library is still growing and evolving to accommodate physical media and always will do. Some things are worth preserving and to never be forgotten.

Read a book instead

[Horst_In_Translation · 4/10 · 17 July 2015]

"Toute la mémoire du monde" or "All the Memory of the World" is a French black-and-white film by Alain Resnais from 60 years ago. It's interesting that two of the three people involved with this documentary became over 90 years old and the third also made it past 80. Admittedly, most of the books in this documentary are much older still. And that's basically what it is: a 20-minute documentary about a gigantic library in the French capital. I have to say it was never really interesting and even to people who often go to libraries I'd rather recommend to read a good book than to watch this one here. It's really only worth a watch for nostalgic reasons, maybe especially for French or even better Parisian citizens. The rest can really do without it. Not recommended.