User Reviews (14)

Add a Review

  • fa-oy9 March 2013
    The story of a great man indeed. A man who, despite his poverty and unjustifiable way of life, finds happiness and appreciates the simple and basic things in it, and the people who make contact with him quickly recognize his great character and kindness. Toshiro Mifune may have just delivered one of his best performances in his whole acting career, so different from his usual expressions he would normally showcase in Kurosawa's films. In this film, while in some parts he impersonates a similar role to those he would do in Kurosawa's films, he mostly adopts a personality of a humble, charitable man. He is definitely the core and character that makes this film overflow with greatness, although many of the other people involved in the cast are just as important.

    The fact that this film is very rare and difficult to track, in my opinion, is comparable to the unfortunate life of Matsu (character enacted by Toshiro Mifune) who, being a wonderful man, goes through life mainly unnoticed and unacknowledged; only some people get to know him better and firmly state that he could have been someone big. Such is the fate of this film; it is highly underrated, but if you are fortunate enough to find it, you will behold the story of an admirable man.
  • In the turn of the Twentieth Century, the rickshaw driver Matsugoro "Matsu" (Toshirô Mifune) is a happy man and a troublemaker well-known by everyone in his village. One day, Matsu sees an injured boy, Toshio, and brings him home. His mother Yoshiko Yoshioka (Hideko Takamine) asks Matsuo to take the boy to the doctor and then her husband Capt. Kotaro Yoshioka (Hiroshi Akutagawa) asks her to reward Matsu. However the rickshaw man refuses the money and becomes a friend of the family. When Kotaro unexpectedly dies, Matsuo helps Yoshiko to raise her son. Soon he falls in love with her, but he does not dare to open his heart to Yoshiko since they belong to different social classes.

    "Muhomatsu no issho", a.k.a. "The Rickshaw Man", is a beautiful, sensitive and heartbreaking movie that begins as a comedy but ends in a melodrama. The story of the impossible love of a poor but good man in a Japan with a rigid social class structure has a very sad ending. The performance of Toshirô Mifune is impressive and the director Hiroshi Inagaki won a Golden Lion in the Venice Filme Festival (1958). I have just surprisingly found that this movie is a remake of the unknown 1943 "Muhomatsu no issho". My vote is eight.

    Title (Brazil): "O Homem do Riquixá" ("The Rickshaw Man")
  • CitizenKaneAAAAA16 September 2018
    9/10
    WOW!
    Oh WOW! this film is slipping out off the radar, played by the great Toshiro Mifune, it's a tragedy of a great man named Muhomatsu, a Rickshaw Man. if you're looking for a great classic tear-jerker japanese drama then this is definitely a must to see!
  • Like the other comments, this movie should be available on DVD or VHS. I remember seeing it 40 years ago and its brilliance stands out in my mind as if I saw it yesterday.

    Toshiro Mifune plays against type. No samurai warrior he, but a humble Rickshaw man secretly in love with an upper class woman. He shepherds her son throughout the years and the woman, while almost recognizing the Rickshaw Man has helped make her son a man, never comprehends the love Mifune has for her.

    A classic woman's film that caused this man to cry. And the fact that it stars Mifune and is directed by a macho director who likes to do period Samurai movies is amazing. Two macho stars making one of the great soaps of all time. And I mean that in the best of ways.
  • 72256-273729 July 2005
    10/10
    I agree
    I last saw this film nearly 35 years ago and would like to see an English subtitled DVD one more time before I go. Of all the films that Mifune Toshiro made, this is the one I love the most. Mifune's portrayal of a common man who does not apologize for his lot in life but instead lives it to it's fullest extent is both amusing and inspirational.

    There was also a version done by Mikuni Rentaro (Toei Studios) that I have seen. At this point in time, I am willing to watch any of the many remakes of this film.

    Hopefully someone with some "juice" will read these comments and act on bringing a good English subtitled version to DVD.
  • It's just a darn shame that this isn't available on tape or DVD. It is a delightful yarn about the upheaval in Japan at the coming of the 20th Century. Besides being a good tale, it gives the viewer a lot of insight into the metamorphosis of Japanese society away from the samurai code and into the Machine-Age. Funny and thought-provoking. Mifune got my attention with this film. I was a devoted fan after seeing "The Rickshaw Man" (as the posters proclaimed). Another bonus is the very excellent production design. There was no doubt in your mind what era the movie was transporting you to. And, for something shot in the '50s, you wouldn't find any complaints about the cinema-photography. You know, if a producer had half a brain, he/she couldn't go wrong with doing a remake of this film.
  • While filled with pathos, there is enough fun in this film to keep you on your toes. Set in Japan at the turn of the 20th century, it shows how a simple rickshaw man has to adjust to the modernization of his country. Menawhile, keeping his promise to a dead client, he cares for the wife and child of the dead naval officer. The hitch is that he loves the beautiful widow and child. Yet, is constrained by social boundries from ever expressing it to them.

    Only Mifune could have turned in a performance such as this.

    Just wish they'd remaster this rascal and offer it as a DVD.
  • liliput200222 December 2004
    Why on earth its so hard to get this film on video? Only an extreme bad English subtitled VHS, a good Chinese subtitle, but no German subtitle or German synchronized. I saw this film 40 years ago in German cinema, and except a Japanese VHS or DVD (see above)there's nothing to receive. This film is so good, that I even can understand the meaning of the Japanese Video. (With the help of my Japanese woman) The tragedy of a Rikshaman is shown in an excellent way, how he helps a young boy, when his father died, and that he cant marry the mother of that boy, because he is from a "lower Kaste". I hope one day I will get a German - or at least an English copy, to understand all the words, they say.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    MUHOMATSU, THE RICKSHAW MAN / THE RICKSHAW MAN / UNTAMED MATSU'S LIFE (LIT.) (MUHOU MATSU NO ISSHOO). Viewed on Streaming. Restoration/preservation = nine (9) stars; set design = nine (9) stars; cinematography/lighting = eight (8) stars; sound = eight (8) stars; subtitles = eight (8) stars; music = seven (7) stars; choreography = five (5) stars; script = two (2) stars. Director Hiroshi Inagaki (also credited as co-writer) delivers an apparent shot-for-shot remake of a Jidai-Geki (historical) tale (his first version was filmed/released in 1943) dealing with life-long unrequited love between members of vastly different socioeconomic classes: an illiterate rickshaw puller (played by Toshiro Mifune) and the highly-refined widow of a military officer (played by Hideko Takamine). The puller becomes a surrogate father to the widow's child, but nothing more (despite nascent inclinations for self improvement from the puller and a boat load of romantic hints from the widow!). This pedestrian (but big-budget) photo-play unsuccessfully relies on star power to save the day for wimpy direction based on an outdated and impoverished script. (It looks like Toho Studios was also counting on big-name stars when committing to such a lavish production.) The film starts off as a light comedy (there are a few great one-liners), but rapidly descends into melodramatic mediocrity. (What might have appealed to war-year audiences is simply too old fashioned for modern times.) Flash backs are marked with what looks like Vasculine smeared around the edge of the camera lens. Flash forwards are marked by spinning rickshaw wheels Ad Nauseam. Mifune is seriously miscast (although he played the same role in the 1943 version). He does not look or act the part, but here-and-there delivers lines that are not muttered/growled (and can be understood without resorting to subtitles!). (Given the screenplay and direction, it is likely that any actor would appear to be miscast in this role!) Takamine is given very little to work with and her considerable talent is wasted except in the closing scenes. (But she does look particularly stunning--and never seems to age-- in color!). Distinguished actor Chishuu Ryuu's character is used to bookend the story. He gets to deliver perhaps the best dialog in the script early on; not so much at the end. Cinematography (2.35 : 1, color), lighting, sound, subtitles, and restoration are very good. Opening boom shot is impressive. There are a few video artifacts with some scene changes (when switching between reels?). Sound is strikingly clear. Set design is especially well done and looks spectacular in the wide-screen format. Music is fine. Choreography needs some work--stunt actors fall down when swung at but not hit during fight scenes; drumming can be heard on the sound tract when a drum is clearly not being struck; etc. With a far better script and energetic direction, this could have been a film well worth watching. WILLIAM FLANIGAN, PhD.
  • crossbow010618 August 2012
    First of all, you could never go wrong with a pairing of Toshiro Mifune and Hideko Takamine, two of the greatest actors that have ever been in film. Second, this tale of a rickshaw man known at the "Wild Matsu" who helps a young boy named Toshio and becomes a part of his growing up is told vividly through numerous scenes over time. Ms. Takamine plays Yoshiko, who was widowed soon after she met Matsu, and her performance is understated but essential to the film. Mr. Mifune, who is best remembered for works with the great Kurosawa, stretches his acting muscles greatly here, showing some vulnerability in a challenging role. There are so many films to recommend with Ms. Takamine and Mr. Mifune that are alternately entertaining and heartbreaking. This has both those elements and its a treasure of Japanese cinema.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    "The Rickshaw Man" (1958) is an excellent comedy-drama film starring Toshiro Mifune, who plays Matsu, a rickshaw driver. This movie is also known as "Muhomatsu, the Rickshaw Man." The film is set in 1905 Japan, where industrialization is beginning to replace older traditions.

    When a military wife's husband dies, Matsu becomes a mentor for her son. Matsu secretly falls in love with the widow, yet knows he cannot have a relationship with her, because of his lower social status.

    Matsu is a tough, rowdy man, with a sense of humor and a great heart. Despite his poverty, Matsu lives his life to the fullest. He enjoys life, and can find happiness in many places.

    This movie is beautifully filmed in color, and there are scenes of traditional Japanese parades, fireworks, concerts and sports events. In one scene, Matsu skillfully drums a traditional song on a huge kodo drum, which delights the audience.

    There are also surrealistic recurring images of wheels, which represent the passage of time.

    This movie won the Golden Lion prize for Best Film at the 1958 Venice Film Festival. It deserves to be on DVD.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    Today it may be hard to understand the classed societies that prevailed pretty much everywhere before the 1800s and how slowly they changed to more egalitarian ones. Japan was a very class conscious society even up to WW II. There was a lot of imitation of the West but the attitudes towards the nobility changed very slowly. There were no peasants in the original stories Seven Samurai and the Samurai Trilogy were based on, but peasant heroes of noble character were portrayed in their movies to make a point about human equality.

    Both of those stories were retold from many older versions, Samurai trilogy was based on the real life of Miyamoto Musashi who was actually the son of a head of a fencing school, and not a peasant at all as he is portrayed in the movie. Seven Samurai was also retelling, though probably about how Samurai who had fallen on hard times retained their noble character. Even a very promising fighter would not have gotten a pass to join the group with a stolen birth record, certainly not one that indicated he was 7 years old! Having to resort to working for peasants was lowering enough. Portraying the revelation of Mifune Toshiro's character's character and abilities, his equality with his new comrades and their gradual acceptance of him, makes the point.

    In Rickshaw Man we have a much more direct message piece: a man of noble character whose position is way at the bottom of even the peasant class! I remember seeing this movie in the 1960s and it seemed obvious to me that it was set in the 1940s. The lady's officer husband (officers were Samurai class) went off to war and was killed. This was a common occurrence at several points between 1880 and 1945 and this makes her a very sympathetic character. She is also of course Samurai class. This gulf between their classes would have been unthinkable to cross for people who had grown up before 1940. S, more so for any of the possible prior years. Stepping between rich middle class and modest Samurai class may have been happening but was still a big deal. Notice that by showing the Lady's husband as being generous and thoughtful in desiring to reward the rickshaw man for his help he is carefully preserved as noble also; there is no making the upper classes villains here, just showing that others are virtuous also.

    In 1959 when the heir to the Emperor married a commoner, the daughter of the head of Nissan Flour Milling Ltd, it was a very big deal indeed! Much was made about how her upbringing had been the equal of a Samurai daughter, not by directly saying so, but by describing it and her accomplishments in detail. However, this too, was obviously a message. The Emperor wanted attitudes to change.

    So in Rickshaw Man we have the title character established not only as lower class than farmers but a trouble maker: as low as he could be without being a criminal or a traitor. Not only is he good-hearted, he has tremendous joy in being alive. He is also virtuous in his respect for people who are supposed to be his betters and noble in not resenting his own status. As Mifune Toshiro portrays him, he is positively inspiring. Clearly, this is a movie intended to change peoples minds and hearts. I can't imagine anyone who saw it leaving the theater without thinking that maybe the lower classes might be okay, at least some of them. Japanese culture was changing and these movies were helping it as much as they could. It was also inspiring news to all those not lucky enough to be born Samurai--which was maybe 90%, so this message would be popular, too.
  • When I think of Toshiro Mifune I usually think of the films he made with Akira Kurosawa, but he had a streak of excellent performances in interesting films directed by Hiroshi Inagaki. The first films I saw were the "Samurai Trilogy" (1954-56), three films based on the life of Miyamoto Musashi. That being said I was also impressed by The Rickshaw Man (1958). Mifune delivers his trademark "physical" role of Matsu "the Outlaw"(a title appropriated by Imamura in one of his documentaries) a larger than life rickshaw man in Kokura, Kyushu. Evidently, this is a remake of an earlier film, but i have never seen the previous film. Matsu befriends a small boy and becomes the surrogate father after the boy's father dies. He also carries a torch for the boy's mother played by Naruse regular Hideko Takamine. In this film we get to see Mifune win a running race,beat up several school boys in a big fight, and expertly play the taiko drum. The storyline is somewhat melodramatic, but Mifune carries the film with his charismatic performance-it is entertaining and worthwhile.
  • Really great movie. About a poor rikisha man, Matsu)mifune) who cares for Toshio and her son after her husband, Yoshioka suddenly dies. Matsu acts as the boy's fatherly figure, he spots the child with a tangled up kite..he parks his rikshaw with a customer seated and runs over to help out the kid; he plays games, tells stories about himself to the kid and the best bit is the games..during a parade he jumps up to a great big kodo drum and begins to play...that is the best part. I won't give the end away. Gotta see that for yourself. but it's not happy. Like all Toshiro's movies, it's well worth the time to watch.