Primetime Emmy Awards (1961)

Primetime Emmy [Nominee]

Outstanding Program Achievement in the Field of Drama

Primetime Emmy [Nominee]

Outstanding Single Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role

Elizabeth Montgomery

Primetime Emmy [Nominee]

Outstanding Performance by an Actor in a Series (Lead)

Robert Stack

Primetime Emmy Awards (1960)

Primetime Emmy [Winner]

Outstanding Performance by an Actor in a Series (Lead or Support)

Robert Stack

Primetime Emmy [Winner]

Outstanding Achievement in Film Editing for Television

Ben Ray
Robert L. Swanson

Primetime Emmy [Nominee]

Outstanding Program Achievement in the Field of Drama

Directors Guild of America, USA (1961)

DGA Award [Nominee]

Outstanding Directorial Achievement in Television

Howard W. Koch

Directors Guild of America, USA (1960)

DGA Award [Nominee]

Outstanding Directorial Achievement in Television

Tay Garnett

Edgar Allan Poe Awards (1960)

Edgar [Winner]

Best Episode in a TV Series

David Karp

Grammy Awards (1961)

Grammy [Nominee]

Best Soundtrack Album or Recording of Music Score from Motion Picture or Television

Nelson Riddle

Writers Guild of America, USA (1961)

WGA Award (TV) [Winner]

Episodic, Longer Than 30 Minutes in Length

William Spier