The Hand in the Trap (1961) User Reviews (4)

Behind the closed door

[jotix100 · 8/10 · 1 February 2004]

Leopoldo Torre Nilsson was probably the best film director in Argentina. He was a man with a vision. He was the one that elevated the local cinema and put it on the map in the late 50s and early 60s. He almost always worked on screen plays based on his wife, Beatriz Guido's novels, as is the case here.

This gothic tale of hidden monsters and well kept secrets among the provincial bourgeoisie had more impact for me the first time I watched it. On second viewing what seemed so eerie before doesn't hold true any more.

The Lavignes, one of the patrician families of the town, having lost their fortune, are now living humbly making dresses for the moneyed classes still around. They make exquisite work. They don't lack clients, as it's evident by the visits from their wealthy locals.

Into this household Laura arrives for a summer vacation. She feels the spookiness that surrounds the household and she wants to get to the truth behind the closed door of the room on the third floor. She will find out the horrible secret the family has kept hidden from everyone in town. When she discovers what really happened many years ago, it will already be too late to rebel from a fate far worse than what originally happened to a member of the family. Shame, honor and the fear of ridicule played a major part in this story and sealed the fate of the family.

The beautiful Elsa Daniel plays Laura, the young girl at the center of the story. She is a beautiful presence among the darkness around her. A younger Francisco Rabal plays the aristocratic member of another patrician family of the town. Maria Rosa Gallo plays the enigmatic woman at the center of the secret.

Jane Eyre Re-visited

[jcappy5 · 7/10 · 23 April 2004]

(contains spoilers) "The Hand in the Trap" is much like "Jane Eyre." Laura Lavigne (Elsa Daniel) is Jane and Ines Lavigne is Bertha Mason. Francisco Rabal plays the Mr. Rochester character. Both young women need to know about a mysterious figure dwelling an in an attic. Both learn that the inmate is female and both sense a sisterly alliance which provokes a deeper investigation. What each learns is that Bertha and Ines have been imprisoned and driven mad by their male `lovers." Also, Jane and Laura are each `in love' with the man who put away these older women. The one key difference is that Mr. Rochester suffers for his act and does, in the end, change, while the Francisco Rabal character does not. In fact the latter, a more realistic and modern version of the same Mr Rochester, manages to imprison Elsa too. So, what we have in `The Hand in the Trap,' is a modern and perhaps more realistic version of the Jane/Rochester/Mason relationship in Jane Eyre.

The film's strength is its anarchic development, honesty, and restraint. The acting is superb--no weak links. But Elsa Daniel is very special--her presence centers the film--making it so much more compelling. Yet her inner strength does not seem to match Jane Eyre's more worldly resources, because unlike Jane, she fails to hold out on her deadly "lover." Some might prefer a different ending, given the inward power she sometimes seems to display in the film.

The best movie no one's ever seen

[antcol8 · 8/10 · 23 January 2006]

I saw it on TV, on a great cable independent movie show. I also saw it twice. The first time I tuned in a bit late and missed the opening. I spent a lot of time trying to figure out whose film it was. Some of it looked completely like classic - period Antonioni, some like Mexican Bunuel. There are some great scenes: the "Founders Day" festival for example. It's all really murky and ambiguous. Although blond people are lit dizzyingly high key. There's lots of creepy sexual weirdness. All that good stuff... I'd love to see more of Torre Nilsson's films. Maybe he doesn't have his own voice; maybe he's another hidden treasure, like Imamura. Who knows?

"It's bad enough you went snooping around..."

[melvelvit-1 · 8/10 · 1 December 2016]

There was a time when a deformed or "loony" relative was kept locked up in the house never to be spoken of except behind the back and the once wealthy Lavignes keep one on the top floor of a mansion that's seen better days. Young Laura, home from boarding school, is determined to finally get a glimpse of the half-brother who's been confined upstairs for twenty years but when she does, she discovers a completely different relative under lock and key and, as her aunt tells her, "it's bad enough you went snooping around but now you've gone and put your hand in the trap"...

Family honor and the dark secrets of a provincial Argentinian town propel this perverse variation on JANE EYRE with a heroine not unlike Jean Seberg in BONJOUR TRISTESTE and although it's not exactly horror, the downbeat ending comes close enough as "those who can't learn from the past are condemned to repeat it". Director Nilsson was nominated for a Palme d'Or for his gloomy, black & white adaptation of wife Beatriz Guido's novel.