Il buono, il brutto, il cattivoGoofs
- 102 entries
- see 15 spoilers
After Blondie tells Angel Eyes of six being a perfect number because it is the number of bullets his revolver can carry, the latter gives off a laugh that audibly belongs to neither Lee Van Cleef nor Simon Prescott (Van Cleef's voice-over actor in the extended version of the film). The laugh belongs to Angel Eye's voice actor in the Italian version, Emilio Cigoli, so the presence of his laugh in the English version is a dubbing error in the extended English-language version.
A man in Tuco's profession should have realized before engaging in the final three-way showdown that his revolver would not have fired. It is clearly visible that the percussion caps on his revolver have been removed. In contrast, such percussion caps are clearly visible on the cylinder of Angel Eyes' pistol.
Crew or equipment visible
Right after the scene where Blondie places the rock in the middle of the courtyard, (presumably containing the name of the grave), there is a close-up shot of Angel Eyes' face lasting about one second. To the right of Angel Eyes' head, you can see a person running in the far background. They are moving right to left.
Errors in geography
During the three way showdown (also known as a "Mexican standoff"), Tuco slowly pulls his pistol out from his pocket and dangles it beside him, which unknown to him Blondie has emptied. But a professional gunman like Tuco is supposed to be, would easily be able to tell the difference in weight between a loaded gun and an empty one.
The man pointed at as the Confederate General Sibley (by the hotel owner) is actually a Confederate Captain according to the rank insignia on his collar. The buttons on his uniform is furthermore misplaced compared to that of a authentic Confederation Captain. A genuine uniforms buttons would have been closer to the chest.
When Wallace is escorting Tuco on the train to their destination, presumably another prisoner of war camp, Tuco pushes him off the train and after rendering him unconscious, tries to sever the chain joining the handcuffs on both of them. But Wallace would have held the keys of the handcuffs, so why didn't Tuco search his pockets, as a first measure. After Tuco manages to sever the chain on the rails, he would still have had his part of the hand cuffs on his wrist, but shortly after, we see Tuco in the bath and no cuffs are to be seen.
Incorrectly regarded as goofs
When Tuco and Blondie ride their coach up to the mission to recuperate from the desert several power poles are visible in the background to the left. (May only be visible in the wide-screen version). However, one can make the assumption that these are telegraph lines since the telegraph was a common form of long-distance communication during the civil war. Power poles are even visible by the train tracks when Tuco escapes his captive which makes sense since telegraph lines were commonly built along railroads.
The bounty hunters that Blondie saves Tuco from at the beginning are waiting for Tuco to come riding towards them. Tuco hasn't being stationary, and he isn't being pursued to set him into a trap, so there's no way the bounty hunters could have possibly tracked him and predicted where he was going to be.