User Reviews (10)

Add a Review

  • Warning: Spoilers
    1963. Anne is in 7th grade or so. Her sister Frédérique is in 9th grade or so. They go to the same school. 'Diabolo menthe' is a nicely observant and fast-paced series of vignettes about their life, especially their school life. The film is the definition of slice of life.

    We get to see the differences between the lives of the two sisters, and their commonalities. Anne often is in a hurry to grow up, to catch up with her big sister. She wants as much pocket money as her, is happy when she gets her first period after which she immediately demands to join her sister when she goes to the dance club, she steals (or tries to), she plays a prank on Frédérique, she goes to a café after school for the first time but has to go home when Frédérique sees her there, she runs away from a guy on the street who's wearing a coat (presumingly because she thinks he is a flasher, or maybe he really did flash her before), etc. She has a classmate who knows all the things grown-ups now, like about sex and white slavery and such. Of course most of it is utter nonsense, but the other children believe her anyway. Every little thing that happens in her life feels like a tragedy, everything seems so terribly important, in school and out of school.

    For Frédérique, although a mere two years older, things look quite different. She has become politically active even though politics are forbidden in school. She becomes estranged with her friend in class over political matters and becomes friends with a different girl. She goes camping alone with a boy but grows annoyed of him and drives back home when she hears that a classmate of hers suddenly and mysteriously disappeared. She and the father of the girl who disappeared end up kissing. Etc.

    What they have in common is that they have to deal with teachers and parents. The teachers all have the typical quirks and shortcomings. They dish out unjust punishments because they don't even want to understand the children, they struggle with their own insecurities more than they struggle with the children, and so on. Just your average screwed up teachers mistreating children, but you as a child couldn't tell anybody about it, because who would care? A teacher would have to rape you in front of the class before somebody cares, which - spoiler alert - isn't something that happens in this film. Of course the children are devils too if you let them, and a teacher who isn't respected by the children has to go through hell when all the children in a class behave like maniacs as soon as you are alone with them.

    'Diabolo menthe' isn't an overt period piece. There are references to the Kennedy assassination and to Alain Resnais' "Muriel" (because one classmate amusingly sports that same name) but overall this could pretty much take place today. Presumingly it's set in 1963 simply because writer/director Diane Kurys was around the protagonists' age at that time. This also isn't a denunciation of the education system like 'Mädchen in Uniform' or anything, it's just about the everyday life insanity. They are all real people and the dialogues are simple, very true to life. It's all very unassuming. Very relatable. Very enjoyable.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    There is of course nothing new about autobiographical Art whether it comes in the form of a play (The Glass Menagerie), a novel (Other Voices, Other Rooms) or a film (Le Grand Chemin) and Diane Kurys has devoted more time than most to her childhood and adolescence and arguably mined it more successfully than most. Diabolo Menthe was the very first of her memoirs and it may be significant that the year it appeared, 1977, was the year she made the last of thirteen films as an actress (so far she has directed twelve films). She followed with Molotov Cocktail which I've yet to see, Coup de foudre, which dealt mainly with her mother, and La Baule-les-Pins, which continued the story of the two sisters, Frederique and Anne. Both Coup de foudre and La Baule-les-Pins were excellent so I tended to expect a lot from Diabolo Menthe and whilst it failed - at least for me - to match the high standards of Coup de foudre and La Baule-les-Pins it remains a remarkable achievement with a fine central performance and first-rate supporting actors. In a perfect world all four titles would be issued in a boxed set with a down side of drawing more attention to the fact that in each case the principles are played by different performers, something that although clear is not so glaring when the films are spaced apart as of course they were. Very well worth a look.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    I didn't expect to hear 'Living Doll' (The young ones) and 'Last Night' (Bottom) within the first fifteen minutes of this sympathetic French coming-of-age film, but there it is.

    'Diabolo Menthe' presents the viewer with a series of incidents, accidents and such, spread over the course of one school-year (summer vacation to summer vacation), concerning the goings on of a small family. Mother and two daughters live in the city, father lives at sea (divorce). A lot of it takes place at a girls' school, then some at mother's home, some elsewhere in the city and some at sea. All the time there are things going on (some issues are seemingly bigger than others at first sight, but...), but it is hardly a story, much more like an 'anti-story', which is emphasized when two girls in the end conclude that, whatever things were like at the beginning of the school-year, things may change.

    The setting of a seventies Paris (while the story takes place in '63 / '64) is wonderful (streets, school, apartments), most of the (young) cast act quite 'au naturel' and the dialogues and events have a certain timeless quality to them. The Dutch alternative title was rather unimaginative, so I will leave it unnamed. No: peppermint soda it is! A cool 8 out of 10, well worth staying up late for.

    P.s. Does anyone know how the mother was so quickly cured of her psoriasas (not entirely, but still)? That could be worth gold, I suspect.
  • The director's Entre Nous is one of my favorite movies. I had never seen Peppermint Soda, which I understood was equally autobiographical, so rented it. It's quite different in style from Entre Nous - covers far less time, and the "events" in the two sisters' lives are all quite "micro".

    Yet it's also true that I cannot think of anything that portrays adolescence as it really was (for boys as well as girls) as well as this movie. Kurys has a truly remarkable feel for the extent to which music on the radio was a back-drop, or the way that a long-running dispute with a parent over clothing (in this case, nylons) can punctuate daily life, or the way friendships in school change over time. It's really a brilliant movie - not the most entertaining, but in its way, profound and well worth seeing. You will find yourself liking it more and more and more as the movie develops.
  • Movie of a generation, "Diabolo menthe" was a success as it was one of the first showing its youth with sincerity. It is now a real testimony of what was to be young in the 60's. School, parents, friends, society, it is interesting to see how things has so much changed - and at the same time, not that much: childs are always child, the dreamed discipline of glorious past times doesn't exist, ...

    If the movie is an interesting testimony, I was not thrilled by it as a movie, and, even if the youg actors do not have to blush of their performances, I rate this just as okay.
  • Insight-filled story of one year (1963-64) in the lives of two French sisters, living in Paris with their divorced mother and trying their best to cherish the joy while coping with the pain of growing up. Director Kurys, who dedicated this, her first film, to her own sister "who still hasn't returned my orange sweater," obviously knows whereof she speaks, since the character's ages correspond to her own growing up years. Nevertheless, the actual time period doesn't become clear until late in the movie, and the characters and incidents are certainly universal.

    As the older sister, Odile Michel is lovely, and does a capable job with her role. The gem in this movie, though, is Eleanore Klarwein, who is captivating as the younger, more sensitive sibling who doesn't yet understand all that is going on around her, but struggles onward to meet each day nonetheless.
  • A truly brilliant look into a year in the life of two sisters at an all-girl school in France, 1963.

    Kurys does an amazing job of spinning a narrative out of a string of separate occurrences as we follow these characters through a significant time in their life.

    One can't help but be reminded of their crucial years growing up and amazed out how seamlessly the director was able to put all of these emotions into one film.

    Wonderfully shot through the ingenious eye of cinematographer Philippe Rousselot, this film is a shining gem that leaves an impression.
  • What appears at first to be the French female answer - in director and in main cast - to the 400 Blows (and to an extent too Small Change, which came out the year before this) - ends up having deeper levels if only because a) there are two sisters here, and the structure of this definitely and umabashedly episodic film is split by the younger one in the first half and then more the older in the second (they're only age different by two years but, one thing this filmmaker knows well and wisely, when you're young those two years matter a great deal), and b) it's more politcal and sociolgically a buzz.

    If nothing else there are moments the director stops - amid the many, many of lifes little moments - for a side character to have a monologue or reveal something (ie the girl detailing a massacre she witnessed) that keep it humming with drama amid the lightness and comedy. It's a movie with men who seem threatening and welcoming, perversity is around the corner, but innocence is maintaned despite everything.

    It's a playful, dark, sad, delightful, startling, and full of wisdom. The girl actresses are natural and convincing, even when they have to cry or act besotten or whathaveyou. The drawback overall is it's all too long. But hey, better to have too much than too little.
  • As a child from the late 70s, this movie was a famous experience for me in the 80s. I remember that we talked a lot about if in my family. Honestly, even as a boy, i connect easily with the younger Anne: quiet, daring, lost, arguing with the parents, on charge with her sibling (like a battery) and meeting the inner desire.

    The family life in Paris in the sixties looks like mine, twenty years later in a provincial town: educational system grinding young students, silly teachers, discipline over all, pocket money, letters, nice clothes... So this movie feels amazingly authentic and in addition, it's told with innocence, kindness and modesty.

    But, sadly, this world and this Paris are gone now. Now the benchmark is Ozon Jeune & Jolie in which student girl dreams to become prostitute for sex and money! World has changed for worst but luckily we have still movies like Diabolo Menthe to remember how cool it was.
  • Diane Kurys made her directorial debut with 1977's "Diabolo menthe" ("Peppermint Soda" in English), about a pair of sisters in Paris amid the politically heightened period of 1963-64. This is the first movie of Kurys's that I've seen, so I can't compare to the rest. I also wasn't alive at the time depicted, so I can't judge the authenticity.

    What I can say is that the movie establishes a fine depiction of what it's like to come of age, especially in a less-than-welcoming setting (the school comes across more like a prison). I would've liked it more had it depicted the girls getting into the Beatles - wouldn't that have happened in 1963-64? - but aside from that, the movie gives one a feeling of growing up in the era. A well-made coming-of-age movie, just like "The 400 Blows", "To Kill a Mockingbird" and "Stand By Me". I hope to see the rest of Diane Kurys's movies.