Eleanor Gehrig
Lou Gehrig
Joe McCarthy
Babe Ruth
Eleanor's Mother
Mrs. Gehrig
Claire Ruth
Dr. Canlan
Dr. Charles Mayo
Dorothy
Kitty McHie
Jennifer (as Jennifer Penny)
Sophie Tucker
Tony Lazzeri
Lefty Gomez
Bill Dickey
Kenderly
Papa Gehrig (as Fred Downs)
John Kieran
Joe Durso
Ed Barrow
Bud
Harry Grabiner
Mr. Twitchell
Nurse #1
Fanny Barrow (as Jan Jordan)
Draftsman (as Jonathan Segal)
Purser
Driver
Nurse #2