Okay, this is supposed to be an issue-based film. If so, its issues are hiding under a most preachy, corny story of the innocent girl who is raped and transformed. There are two extremes here. First, our leading lady is naive in the most unbelievable ways, much to the point of thinking that just being kissed by a guy could get her pregnant, and then she is unable to smile. Her second phase of course makes perfect sense considering how atrocious this whole experience was for her, but the transformation is just not convincing enough to me.
Now, I know, this is a Raj Kapoor film, you can always expect superb photography, great music, and indeed, it's all there, but the banality of the story, as well as the exhaustingly long runtime of the film for a story that would require less, makes the entire thing really quite tedious. The film is a visual treat, no doubt, it is beautifully shot, the extravagance of the sets is overwhelming, and even the music helps to create an entertaining picture. But even if all those are well put into place, it can't make up for the missing depth that one expects from The Showman.
Now Prem Rog aims to tackle several social themes, among which the most prevalent is widow remarriage, but it's hard to take it seriously when many of the situations are convoluted, melodramatic, while some of the key characters are mere caricatures. One wishes the whiny background music in the crucial scenes was not there. What's more, the legendary director, probably in order to ease it for the viewers, makes ferocious attempts to overpower this serious issue with some fluffy romance, thereby taking away from the seriousness of the situation.
Prem Rog is pretty Padmini Kolhapure's film all the way and it attempts to repeat her brilliant appearance in Kapoor's Satyam Shivam Sundaram, where she was innocence personified, and probably her raw performance in Insaaf Ka Tarazu (where she played a teenaged rape victim). Sadly, the innocence here is overplayed by the writers, but she rises above the script and is wonderful. It's pretty strange how quickly she lost her stardom following such a spectacular start with a string of both commercial and artistic successes.
Rishi Kapoor gets a very common role for his doing and plays second-fiddle to his leading lady. He does really well, his disappointment early when the girl he loves gets married to another is convincing, and he is good support throughout, as are Nanda and Shammi Kapoor. Prem Rog is among Kapoor's weakest films, frankly, and it just feels like another Hindi melodrama. I'm not saying it's bad or unwatchable, it's Kapoor after all, but despite all its technical brilliance and how stunning it is to look at, it's not fully realised.
4 out of 5 found this helpful