Le bon plaisir (1984) User Reviews (7)

a lost letter

[dromasca · 7/10 · 24 December 2021]

At the end of 'Le bon plaisir' (1984), the film directed by Francis Girod, before the credits, a routine disclaimer is displayed stating that the story and the characters are imaginary. In fact, the relationship between this film and reality is much more complicated and interesting. 'Le bon plaisir' is the screenplay of the novel of the same name published a year before Francoise Giroud, who also wrote the screenplay. These were the first years of Francois Mitterrand's tenure as the first socialist politician to become president of France. Françoise Giroud, a well-known journalist and writer, editor of 'Elle' magazine, co-founder and editor of 'L'Express', was a former Minister of Culture in the center-right governments that preceded the Mitterrand era. It was rumored that the new president had a daughter from a secret relationship outside of marriage. 'Le bon plaisir' is about a French president who has a child from a secret relationship, out of wedlock. Were the book and the movie inspired by these rumors? Worse perhaps, politically tendencious? Or was it just a coincidence? Or one of those cases where reality immitates fiction? The fact is that a decade later, in 1994, President Mitterrand's extramarital affair was revealed. His daughter was 20 years old, so in 1984 she had been exactly the same age as the child in the movie.

The story in 'Le bon plaisir' revolves around a lost letter that triggers a political-sentimental intrigue. The beautiful and elegant Claire (Catherine Deneuve), designer and owner of an elegant apartment in Paris, is robbed of her bag in the street. In the stolen purse there is a letter from her ex-boyfriend who is none other than the President of the Republic, a letter containing a secret that may compromise the career and presidency of the politician. Soon, the interior minister, the secret services, the scandalous press will rush into Claire's life to reveal or protect, at any cost, the secret.

The film begins and develops in its first half as a political thriller, then seems to take the path of a political and 'good feeling' family comedy to end in political drama. The first part seemed to me the best, the story is well written, and the action kept me alert. The comedy part, on the other hand, is too diluted, except for the ridicule thrown at the pompous French republic in which the presidents live in the palaces of dethroned and beheaded kings and adopt their lifestyle. The ending is too short and abrupt to have the desired impact. Catherine Deneuve is beautiful and luminous, in this again it is impossible again not to fall in love with her. Jean-Louis Trintignant struggles with a character which is too schematic, a too dislikable president to be truly detested and who reveals nothing of the reasons why he could have been loved or adored by those around him, let alone elected president of France. Michel Serrault, on the other hand, is excelling in his more consistent role as a devoted interior minister. Also starring are Michel Auclair in an interesting and ambiguous role of a mysterious and highly connected editor and Hippolyte Girardot as the young man who triggers the whole story with a theft in order to satisfy the whim of a girlfriend who has left him in the meantime. 'Le bon plaisir' is a watchable movie even today, an entertainment film that satisfactorily passes the 37-year-old exam (well, except for the phones), but it is also one of those cases where the story around the film is more interesting than the movie itself.

"Tout est imaginaire dans cette histoire"?

[brogmiller · 7/10 · 27 December 2022]

Having held a ministerial position in two governments, Francoise Giroud was well placed to write political satire whilst her writing skills had been honed by working on scripts for some of her country's finest film directors.

She has here adapted her own novel, the subject matter of which is contentious. Although she always denied having any knowledge of the 'hidden child' of President Francois Mitterand, the existence of the child was certainly well-known within the circles in which she moved.

Francis Girod's film is slick, polished, well edited and scored by Genvieve Winding and Georges Delerue and boasts excellent production values but alas lacks an 'edge' and therefore disappoints.

It remains emimently watchable however courtesy of its fabulous cast comprising Jean-Louis Trintignant as the President, Catherine Deneuve as his former mistress and mother of his child, Michel Serrault as Minister of the Interior and Michel Auclair as a gay journalist.

For those interested in trivia, there is no such square in the 14th Arrondissement of Paris named Place Jacques Becker. This has been invented as a touching tribute to the great director for whom both Giroud and Girod had worked in earlier times.

Trintignant's typically complex performance in this has attracted a few unfavourable comments but for this viewer at any rate he is ideal. His character is able, like all those who wield political power, to turn on the charm when required but is at heart utterly ruthless.

After all, in Francoise Giroud's previous book 'Comedy of Power', a portrait of the two presidents under whom she served, Giscard d'Estaing and Jacques Chirac, she observed that "any political leader must possess the killer instinct."

Milk and honey to a Frenchman

[christian_fournier · 7/10 · 12 April 2022]

Other comments I have read in this "User's column" are harsh on the character of Jean-Louis Trintignant as President. It is true that Trintignant overplays a bit, but not by much!

He does not make his impersonation of the President repulsive - at least by my French standards -, although he could have omitted the temper tantrums which (concerning Mitterrand) are implausible.

The depiction of a powerful President living in the trappings of the Republic is milk and honey to a Frenchman who has lived the Mitterrand years. François Mitterrand was a complex and secretive man, very smart and cultivated, devoted to serving his country, faithful in his friendships, but utterly ruthless when political matters were at stake and enjoying every morsel of his power. Although not entirely faithful, I find his depiction by Trintignant quite plausible on the whole.

And Serrault - giving a wonderful portrait as Interior Minister and lifelong friend of the President - could have many models: Michel Poniatowski (Interior Minister under Giscard) comes to mind.

___ .

a letter

[Kirpianuscus · 13 December 2021]

One of seductive films more for actors and their job than for story itself. A letter, containing an embarrasant secret about president, a young thief , a journalist, precise effort of Interior Minister to solve the situation. And the charme of Catherine Deneuve. Sure, the reference to Mitterant simmilar situation can be obvious. But the film works by itself, for the fine exploration of politic and fair answer about compromises.

Routine political film

[bob998 · 6/10 · 3 June 2021]

For once, Francis Girod directed a film in which no one dies horribly (Lacenaire, and the unforgettable Trio infernal). It's a fairly sedate story of a French president with really chilly mien who tries to bury the fact of fathering a child from an adulterous affair with Catherine Deneuve. To help him do this, he has the very capable and sinister Interior minister, played by Michel Serrault, spare no efforts. Capable, with good performances from Serrault and Auclair as a gay publisher, but not really gripping.

Astonishing parallels with Mitterand

[mikec-7 · 8/10 · 5 March 2002]

This movie, made in 1983, relates the story of a French president who has an illegitimate child whose existence becomes a state secret. When the film was released, Mitterand was a newly elected president, but what was not known to the public was that Mitterand had had an illegitimate child whose existence was a state secret up to around the time of Mitterand's death. The secret was known to many journalists and, it would seem, to the makers of this film. There is no way, this could be pure coincidence, there are just too many parallels. It makes very interesting viewing now. Above all there is, as one might expect, superb acting from Deneuve, Trintignant and Serrault. Not to be missed.

Hauntingly Beautiful Movie

[gilbert-07919 · 10/10 · 16 February 2023]

Le Bon Plaisir is simultaneously tense yet relaxed. It's a tribute to the skill of the team that made this film. I can hardly find words to describe. It must literally be seen and heard to be experienced. Not to be missed. A Masterpiece of detached plot development where outcomes and impacts are not neither anticipated nor expected. The movie has a solid plotline, and yet the movie seems to flutter aimlessly in the wind like a flag on a day of gentle puffs of wind. There's an other worldly quality to this film for which I can't yet find a verbal description, but I will try. It's as if the characters are playing themselves in the movie and are aware they are playing themselves and are aware of the impending outcomes of their actions and machinations but are inexorably destined to play out the action over and over like marionettes. It's a very haunting effect.