John Book
Rachel
Schaeffer
Samuel
Eli Lapp
Daniel Hochleitner
McFee
Carter
Elaine
Fergie
Stoltzfus
Moses Hochleitner
Bishop Tchantz
Mrs. Yoder
Sheriff
Zenovich
Tourist Lady
Mrs. Schaeffer
Schaeffer's Daughter
T-Bone
Amish
Amish (as Emily Mary Haas)
Town Man
Ticket Seller (as Tom W. Kennedy)
Couple in Garage
Detective
Detective (as Victoria Scott D'Angelo)
Detective (as James Clark)
Custodian
Hoodlum
Counterman
Mother in Station
Little Girl
Amish Farmer Extra in Barn Raising Scene (uncredited)
Perp #2 (uncredited)
Teen at Train Station (uncredited)
Crying Amish Woman at Funeral (uncredited)
Amish Mother (uncredited)
Young Amish Man (uncredited)
Woman in Philadelphia (uncredited)