I like Australian movies. They are alive. But Emma's War is a failure. They never made up their mind about whose war they were portraying; Emma's or her mother's. There are many stories in it and it ends with no story. The initial sequences at the Teosophic School are completely pointless and soon forgotten. The episode of Emma's mother and the US sailor has feeling and good performances. But when the family decides to go to the country, the picture becomes a shambles, and a new story emerges, that of the conscientious objector. Did Australia really treat its conscientious objectors as traitors? Anyhow, this third episode is the only one that has any connection with the movie's title. And it is left unresolved. A very fine performance by Lee Remick (how beautiful she still is!), and a very interesting one by the lovely Miranda Otto is all I would save from what is, besides, the slowest and most tiresome picture of recent years.
Add a Review
-
ksaelagnulraon22 December 2001***MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS***
This film, about a fourteen-year-old girl who is sent to a Teosophic School with her younger sister by her mother while her father is away in New Guinea during World War II, is not an auspicious start to Miranda Otto's film career. VERY poorly directed and scripted, it's an immensely disappointing film considering the absolute wealth of material it could have drawn on - for example, the alcoholic mother, the psychological state of the father upon return, and the general attitude towards "conchies" (Conscientious Objectors). Instead, director Jessop focusses on the School for much of the first half, which should have either been such a small focus or, alternatively, the main focus of the film: certainly a story which revolved around a school such as this one, run by a strange old woman, could have made interesting viewing. Jessop also introduces us to the mother's alcoholism - but then doesn't do anything with this information. The father's return is a somewhat minor event. The bombing of Sydney by the Japanese - obviously another minor event. And the conchie, played by Mark Lee - something was going to happen here but it never did. Jessop - a relatively unknown actor who is probably best known for her appearance in THE INNOCENTS - obviously lacks any real understanding of how audiences react. Good on her for having a go, but EMMA'S WAR is one of the worst Australian films I've ever seen, and I've seen over 500, being a huge fan of most of them. Rating: 4/10 -
przgzr22 August 2009For somebody, war is few air-raid alarms during several years. For somebody else, war is years of hiding in a shelter, or even cellars because there is no place in shelters, and leaving the shelter is life threatening, because city is exposed to all day long gunshots or bombing from the other side of river.
But, no matter if living in the middle of battlefield or somewhere far from it, war inevitably changes lives of all people, making them all victims.
We can't blame Australians for having no real war activities on their territory (we can maybe only envy them). And we have to give appreciation to authors who didn't make a typical war movie, who didn't fill it with soldiers and weapons, but shown how the war can touch people who – looking from distance – don't seem to be affected by war at all.
There is something in spirit of the movie that remind us on Weir's "Picnic at Hanging Rock". It is not the same time, not the same part of country, there is no war in "Picnic", but there is something that discretely tells us that it is the same culture, same soul. It is like comparing Boorman's war coming-to-age drama "Hope and Glory" and movies that show same surroundings in times of peace, coming-to-age dramas from suburbs and old fashioned schools like "Kes" or "Ratcatcher".
It is the character (Emma) who is so similar to girls in Weir's movie, it is the school, it is nature; it is also film's rhythm and photography... add some mysticism to "Emma's War" and it could look as if made by same authors.
But, while in "Picnic" the girls disappear, in "Emma's War" it is life that disappears, it is childhood that has to go away – though at Emma's age it would leave soon anyway, war made it vanish in a moment. Yes, we can wish that Anna Frank had no more problems in war than Emma, and that her final fate was no worse than Emma's, but during their war years their problems were similar, their abrupt cutting off ordinary life, their accelerated growing up show that, though the level of real jeopardy can't be compared at all, the human soul passes the same paths and tunnels, hopes and despairs, challenges and compromises.
So, the movie tells us that no matter if Emma lived in Australia or Rwanda, Vukovar or Manchester, Sankt Petersburg or Vladivostok, war would terminate her childhood, ruin her teenage years and leave scars forever.
Lee Remick's character, Penelope in temptations, should have been either given more screen time and better developed, or made just a supporting role. Both due to screenplay and Remick's great acting, Emma's mother Anne becomes the most interesting character, but rather neglected in second part of the movie (Australians are, unlike French, Canadian or Scandinavian directors, more successful in portraying adults than kids and teenagers). If the movie was a bit longer (as it is quite short, 10 minutes more wouldn't make anybody feel bored) we could have seen Anne as a complete personality. But, on the other hand, this movie is "Emma's War", and Lee would have probably transformed it to Anne's war...
But, being Emma's war, it is a real coming-to-age movie, one that would French make with more eroticism, Czechs with more humor, Italians with more noise, Americans... well, Americans probably couldn't make it at all. However, this is Australian movie, the one that only Australians could make. And that is a very, very good recommendation for it. -
p-treasures23 April 2009I found the previous comment rather harsh. Australia produced many wonderful films in the 70s and 80s..many of them to do with adolescence..'The Getting of Wisdom', 'The Year My Voice Broke'etc and 'Emmas War' to me is a little gem! A sensitive tale of innocence in a time of war,beautifully acted by Lee Remick and Miranda Otto and Mel Gibsons brother Donal. The music by John Williams was very moving and I keep humming it to myself. I thought the art direction was particularly good and captured the feel of the period very well in a naturalistic way.A slow moving film,yes..but that added to its charm.A welcome change from bullets and screeching cars!