Dickie Kerr
Buck Weaver
Ray Schalk
Swede Risberg
Eddie Collins
Fred McMullin
Kid Gleason
Lefty Williams
Chick Gandil
Hap Felsch
Eddie Cicotte
'Shoeless' Joe Jackson
Smitty (as Jim Desmond)
Ring Lardner
Hugh Fullerton
Billy Maharg
Arnold Rothstein
Bill Burns
Abe Attell
Sport Sullivan
Heydler
Ban Johnson
Charles Comiskey
Rothstein's Lawyer
Austrian
Ahearn
D.A.
Ben Short
Helen Weaver
Kate Jackson
Rose Cicotte
Lyria Williams
Peewee
Bucky
Scooter
Fan
Writer
Writer (as Michael Harris)
Heckler
Enemy Fan
Browns Umpire
Grabiner (as Merrill Holtzman)
Winslow
Singer
Woman in Bar
Jimmy
Monk
Reds Player
Reds Catcher (as Charles Siebert II)
Cincinnati Umpire
Chicago Umpire
Announcer
Hired Killer
Irish Tenor
Betting Man
Attendant
Reporter
Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis
Judge Friend
Clerk
Nash
Jury Foreman
New Jersey Fan
New Jersey Fan (as Michael Preston)
Newspaper Reporter (uncredited)
Ball Park usher (uncredited)
Scoreboard Kid (uncredited)
Cincinnati Reds Reporter (uncredited)
Reporter (uncredited)
Soldier in Crowd (uncredited)
Usher (uncredited)
Cheering Fan (uncredited)
(uncredited)
Umpire (uncredited)
Young Baseball Fan (uncredited)
Walter 'Dutch' Reuther (uncredited)
Concessions Worker (uncredited)
Reds Player / Hoboken Player (uncredited)