User Reviews (94)

Add a Review

  • I recently saw I.Q. and even though I'm not a romantic comedy type of gal, I think that it was just a nice and sweet movie to watch. So many movies in my opinion lack honesty. You know that feeling when you're watching a movie and you just feel robbed because it's taking something from the story and it was like the director just threw it together like it was trash? The story between the scientists is a sweet and funny one. How they stuck together and they tried to help Tim Robbins character become smart. I liked the love story between Tim and Meg because it was simple and brought up a good point when it comes to love, "nothing is what it seems". I would recommend this for a Sunday morning.

    7/10
  • Catherine Boyd (Meg Ryan) is the niece of Albert Einstein (Walter Matthau) and engaged to pompous professor James Moreland (Stephen Fry). Catherine and James start having car trouble. Ed Walters (Tim Robbins), Bob Rosetti (Tony Shalhoub), and Frank (Frank Whaley) are working in the garage. Ed falls head over heels for Catherine. Einstein intervenes with his scientist friends Nathan Liebknecht (Joseph Maher), Kurt Gödel (Lou Jacobi), and Boris Podolsky (Gene Saks) to perfect a Grand Design. Louis Bamberger (Charles Durning) is the head of the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton.

    The rom-com formula is often derided but there is a reason why everyone keeps repeating it. Catherine and Ed need much more heat in their first meeting. The romance is too one-sided and sputters along. They really don't have enough time together. Even queen Meg Ryan cannot drive this rom-com at full speed. Ed spends more time with Einstein than her. The standout is Walter Matthau and his gang of elderly gentlemen. They are fun and able to deliver a few funny moments. It's more of a hybrid between a rom-com and a buddy movie. This sorta works and has some fun doing it.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    Australian Fred Schepisi (A Cry in the Dark) directs this comedy/ romance that is fun, relaxing, and set in the spring. You will laugh while watching this movie. Tim Robbins (Shawshank Redemption, Dead Man Walking) is an auto mechanic, Ed Walters, with a high IQ, which gets higher with the help of Albert Einstein, Walter Matthau (Grumpy Old Men) and his academic friends Nathan, Kurt and Boris. You can tell them by their preppie shoes. Meg Ryan (Sleepless in Seattle, You've Got Mail) is Catherine Boyd, Einstein's niece who is a competent, but not so confident mathematician. Perhaps it is because she is surrounded by all that genius. She thinks that if she marries someone with a high I.Q. her kids will have a high I.Q. as well, but she does not knows what she wants. Between Tim Robbins cute smile and Meg's cuteness this is a refreshing movie. I love sweet stories. People all ages should enjoy this movie. Catherine is engaged to the jerk James Moreland, who works in animal behavior, but is very stuffy. This is a love a first sight type situation, between the mechanic and the mathematician. Witty lines and subliminal lines! The cinematography is nice. Princeton, New Jersey is beautiful in the Spring. With much help from all those brilliant men Catherine falls for Ed, without knowing that he is an automobile mechanic.

    Favorite Scenes: Ed taking a multiple choice test in front of a crowd with the help of Einstein, Nathan, Kurt, and Boris. Ed and Einstein riding on the motorcycle. Nathan, Kurt and Boris letting all the research animals free!

    Favorite Quotes: Albert Einstein: "Don't let your brain interfere with your heart". Ed Walters: "When was the last time he said "Wahoo""? Catherine Boyd: "Well I'm sure I don't know". This is a refreshing movie, I recommend it. I have the tape and every once and awhile I will watch it again.
  • UACW3 January 2006
    I believe this will ultimately be regarded as one of Ryan's best, no matter where it stands today or no matter how badly it might have bombed at the box office.

    Why? Because it's unabashedly everything her other 'cute' movies play at doing; because Tim Robbins is simply brilliant; because Einstein's friends are so good; because Tony S is nothing short of brilliant; and because Walter Matthau is perhaps the real star.

    There are memorable quotes you will read about in this section, but they don't really work unless you see them being delivered.

    This is only a romp, and it's only for fun, but it has a strong underlying message delivered by Matthau towards the end.

    It's very well acted; and if you think Ryan's character is a bit unreal, fine: it is. But that's what you get for the price of admission.
  • A genial romantic comedy, "I.Q" is a flirtatious piece of fluff in which an auto mechanic woos the educated daughter of ol' E=MC2 himself, Albert Einstein. No guffaw inducer, but very pleasant fare given a considerable boost by its cast, most notably Matthau who is very good indeed as Mr. Einstein.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    I.Q was the Big Bang Theory of the 1990's. This romantic comedy directed by Fred Schepisi is a very charming film. The film is about friendly garage mechanic, Ed Walters (Tim Robbins) who is trying to impress a smart Princeton University mathematician, Catherine Boyd (Meg Ryan) by acting a newly discovery genius with some help with Catherine's Uncle, Albert Einstein (Walter Matthau) and his buddies, fellow scientists Nathan Liebknecht (Joseph Maher), Kurt Gödel (Lou Jacobi), and Boris Podolsky (Gene Saks). The casting for Albert Einstein's friends almost were originally going to be Peter Ustinov, Barry Humphries and John Cleese. No matter who was cast, they see Edward as someone who would be better suited for Catherine, rather than her stiff and fussy English fiancé, experimental psychology professor James Moreland (Stephen Fry). Things get heat up, when the science community heard about this 'wunderkind' genius work on Cold Fusion power rockets, and seek Edward to help the American take back, the space race from the Russians. I have to say, everybody is just charming. Tim Robbins is a fine actor who is believable, but he was a bit difficult during filming I heard. He said in the '90s nobody would like a character who has a woman fall in love with him because of a lie. That's the whole premise of the film. In my opinion, I didn't mind it, but I think Tim Robbins was right, because not a lot of people end up going to see this movie. Meg Ryan is a hot smart woman who looks wonderful in the poodle skirts. She looks really young in this role. Stephen Fry was pretty good, and at less, the filmmakers didn't make his character too unlikable. Last, I have to say Walter Matthau fit the part. He did a great job to the point that it seem like Albert Einstein was playing himself. For dramatic reasons, I.Q. fictionalizes the lives of certain real people. Albert Einstein did not have a niece by the name of Catherine Boyd. Kurt Gödel was famously shy and reclusive, so he probably wouldn't be hanging out with Einstein and Boris Podolsky. I like how the movie didn't play it safe, by over explaining the calculations of the physics theories. If you don't get the jokes. It's alright. I didn't get some of the things, they were saying, too. Plus, I study physics before, coming into this film. I love to do my research, and I think I learn a lot from this film. I never heard of Hamiltonians, iambic pentameter, zeno paradox and others. The odd humor might leave some people scratching their heads, but overall, most of it was pretty simple to understand. The comedy works as well. I love the debate scene about if time exist or not. The whole I.Q test was funny, but a bit unrealistic. The Spike Jones music scene was pretty odd. The Marlon Brando impression was great. By the way, people, the impression was from 1953's Wild Ones and 1954's On the Waterfront, not 1972's the Godfather. I love the movie soundtrack very much from Jerry Goldsmith. The violin melody of Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star was amazing to hear. Other songs heard was the Alphabet song, and some classical music from Wolfgang Mozart, and Joseph Haydn. Some critics didn't find the movie great, because Einstein in their eyes seem too silly or dumb. I doubt Einstein was such a hard head scientist. Einstein reportedly was playful and fond of jokes that could be seen by some as childish, but in the movie, he was indeed sound smart with all the terminology. I love how they got away with the PG rating with all the sexual innuendos, down speaks, and euphemism. There was a lot of dark humor as well like example, the man stuck in a box without a sense of time. Minus, the historic accuracies, this film is fun to watch. This romantic comedy is full of wahoo!
  • IQ is a cute romantic comedy featuring two great actors that seem to click well on screen. Plot is a typical guy wrong for girl, guy gets girl format, but makes the solid point that one must love with the heart and not the the mind. Addition of Albert Einstein and his band of geniuses provides excellent comic relief. Overall, a good movie. Not great, but good
  • When I first saw this film, I thought it should have come from the children's section - It's very fun and at times humorous, and is actually quite a good story, but it severely lacks the "romantic chemistry" that actors like Meg Ryan and Tim Robbins are capable of delivering. I must note that Walter Matthau is perfect for the part of Albert Einstein, and his performance is extraordinary, but that's the sole exception. This film appears a bit forced, the directing lacks substance, and oh yeah...the music is ridiculously awful, it didn't put me in a very good mood. But if you are not expecting a smart, well-crafted comedy/romance tale, then this certainly can be entertaining, like I said..it should be in the children's section. Einstein and his buddies are a good relief from Tim Robbins' boring, almost tense quest to steal Meg Ryan's heart. A very conflicting film, but as long as it's not taken seriously this can be an alright movie.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    I just watched I. Q. again tonight and had forgotten how much I love this movie. It is wonderfully entertaining and leaves you feeling that all is right with the world. I love the allusions to Mozart all throughout from the opening with "Einstein" playing "Twinkle, Twinkle Little Star" on the violin to him humming Eine Kleine Nachtmusik during the IQ testing of the Ed Walters. I love that a woman is portrayed as intelligent and encouraged to have a career, an especially unique situation for the 1950's, the time in which this movie is set. (I myself have been a teacher but stayed at home to raise my children, so please don't think I am some staunch women's libber.) It's wonderful how a man who is "only a grease monkey" is finally seen to be just as important and worthy as Catherine's fiance, a clinical behavioral researcher. The message to me is that we are not what we do, but who we are is defined by so much more - no labels. There are so many little gags and one-liners that are almost throwaways if you don't watch and listen carefully.

    I did catch a few things in the movie that are not listed on the goofs page. In the scene when Ed Walters is to speak at symposium, there are 3 instruments (protractor, ruler, etc.) hanging on the right from the chalk ledge. In the next camera shot, there only 2. In the credits on our video, it lists Tony Shaloub's character as Bob Watters, not Bob Rosetti as he introduces himself in the movie and is listed here on Imdb.

    I highly recommend this movie. It may be a piece of fluff in some estimations, but has lots more substance than many give it credit for. Not only that, what a great cast is assembled here. Watch it and enjoy!
  • Warning: Spoilers
    Meet Ed. He's an automechanic. He's pretty smart, romantic and just a nice guy. Meet Catherine, whose car breaks down right in front of his garage. She's cute, intelligent and in a loveless relationship. Now... are these two gonna hit it off?

    No surprises so far, but this movie comes with a twist. You see, Catherine (Meg Ryan) is a scientist, and involved with intelligent James (Stephen Fry). It turns out Catherine thinks the brain is the most important thing in a man. And, after all, Ed (Tim Robbins) may be pretty smart (though he barely finished high-school), he ain't no Einstein!

    Oh, speaking of Einstein, he's another character in this movie! It turns out Catherine is his niece. Some coincidence huh. Walter Matthau plays Einstein and you can see he has a lot of fun doing so. Him and his friends (all super-intelligent scientists) provide the laughs, while trying to get Ed and Catherine together.

    Movie starts of fast-paced, then takes a step back. There's a big sub-plot with Ed writing and then defending a theorem he wrote, which is actually an old piece of Einstein, and him taking an IQ test. But the main issue in the movie is if Ed and in particular Catherine finally realise that they are right for each other.

    Good actors make up for a couple of weak points in the story, as this movie is fun but nothing special. 6/10.
  • I was somewhat disappointed in I.Q., having heard a bit of "buzz" about it in recent months. What we have is a neat premise, auto mechanic in 50's New Jersey happens to meet the niece of Albert Einstein, pursues her romantically, and along the way meets Albert and his retired cronies. If I could fault the film for two reasons, they would be a weak script, and lack of chemistry between Tim Robbins and Meg Ryan. On the positive side, Walter Matthau was perfectly cast as the elderly Einstein, who became Ryan's guardian when his brother died. The scenery and evocation of small town 1950's New Jersey, including numerous vintage cars of the era, was very well done. I thought the motorcycle ride was one of the highlights of the film. Tim Robbins' character seems to change abruptly when he undergoes a fashion and hairstyle makeover. Whereas before this he was confident and assertive, through the rest of the story he seems troubled, jittery and low in self-esteem. Something about Meg Ryan's character bothered me, and I never really bought into the notion that this intellectual would be seriously interested in Robbins. Also, I think Einstein's three wacky "buddies" are in way too many scenes for the amount of corny humor they actually provide. To sum up, passable romantic comedy with a happy ending that fans of the genre may enjoy, but it could have been so much better.
  • Maybe I'm being too generous with the rating...but I just love this movie! I've seen it so many times, but every time I see it I fall in love with it all over again. It's just a simple romantic comedy, with nothing huge or monumentous that happens. But I'm a big romantic and this movie *is* romantic. I love Meg Ryan and Tim Robbins, and Walter Mathau is so funny. The scientists make me laugh so much...I definitely recommend this movie to anyone who hasn't seen it. It's such a clean, good movie - and those are so rare now! My 20-year-old brother likes this movie, too, so it's not just a chick-flick. ;-) I recommend it if you need to laugh, or if you're just lonely and need to *watch* a romance, if you yourself can't participate in one. It's a good 'un!
  • Yeah, that's the formula for a romcom (cis, straight) -- girl is with a schmuck; boy enters the equation; boy and girl get together but have an argument which divides them; the schmuck gets dumped; the boy comes back; Happy Ending

    But it's just a plot formula, not a chemistry formula. Why? Because there's no chemistry in this movie, just cold fusion. Ryan and Robbins don't click in this flick. Of course Ryan is the queen of romcom, but I don't remember seeing Robbins in any other romcom. It's just not his thing.

    But Robbins is great in this movie, as are the rest of the cast. Matthau is perfect as Einstein -- funny, adorable, quick witted. There are awkward moments though, like when he was on the boat making the couple get together -- it was like he was some kind of voyeur or something. Weird.

    But the writing was great, plenty of innuendo and double entendras. There were several situations that were contrived and unrealistic, a prerequisite for any great romcom.

    Unfortunately, there was bias in the composition of the cast with only one black person in the entire movie, a minor role as a server in a restaurant at the beginning of the movie, while all of the other characters in the movie (mainly intellectual types) were white.

    Otherwise, it's well worth the time.

    Triggers: Racial bias in composition of the cast; textual content >600 wpm (presentation visuals during the IQ test)

    rating 6/10 (submitted 20200603 7:35 EDT, revised 20200606 5:00 EDT)
  • Tim Robbins is oddly benign here, cast as a garage mechanic in 1950s New Jersey who falls in love with a perky blonde who turns out to be Albert Einstein's niece! Although he's on-screen much of the time, Robbins cancels out the inner-workings of his intense persona and fades into the background (it's easy to forget he's even in the picture!). Lumpy romantic comedy with a gimmick, that being Walter Matthau playing Einstein (who does what he can with a cartoonishly conceived character). Otherwise, it's sugary and sunny, directed rather drowsily by Fred Schepisi, who shows heart but no wit or brains. Meg Ryan is her usual affable self and the chemistry between she and Robbins is charming, like that of an affectionate sister and her big brother. ** from ****
  • I saw "I.Q." again today, and now realize how good a movie it is. In fact, I boosted my rating. Since my first viewing, I have seen a couple of biographical movies about Albert Einstein, and that gave me a framework for better appreciating some of the humor. I own the DVD and, while it has no extras, it is a very nice presentation, and the sound is Dolby 5.1. There was a scene with birds twittering in the surround speakers, thoroughly confusing my cat, Bullet.

    Set in the 1950s, when Eisenhower was president, and both the US and Russia were in a race of sorts to explore space, Tim Robbins plays a mechanic who likes to read astronomy and science for fun. Meg Ryan plays a mathematician who isn't quite sure of herself, and Matthau plays Albert Einstein, her uncle. In a round-about way, Einstein and his fellow Physicists play matchmaker, and try to get Ryan and Robbins together. This is simply a wonderful romantic comedy with no swearing, no sex, and very little innuendo.
  • Fairly good romantic comedy in which I don't think I've ever seen Meg looking any cuter. All the players did a good job at keeping this a lively romp. Of course, in the real world no genius mathematician would even glance at some grease monkey, but that is why I love romantic comedies....one can just totally forget reality and have a good time. Nice film. Damn, Meg is a babe, eh?
  • Warning: Spoilers
    "I.Q." is a simple comedy and light romance with a fine cast of old actors and younger stars of the day. Walter Matthau gives a humorous and warm portrayal of Albert Einstein. Einstein was known to have a sense of humor and wit that complimented his scientific genius. Here are some of his clever and funny quotes. "Gravitation cannot be held responsible for people falling in love." "Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe." "Reality is merely an illusion, but a very persistent one." "Education is what remains after one has forgotten what one has learned in school."

    It's too bad the screenwriters couldn't write in some of Einstein's quips in the script. At least, I didn't see or hear anything that might have been his. But, the situational humor and fun lines they put in work fine. And, Matthau is perfect as the physics genius in his last years. The time of the film would have been the early 1950s since Einstein died in 1955. But the coterie of cronies around him aren't historically placed by age. The script conveniently plucks them from their locations around the U.S. to be residing with Einstein in his New England home. These characters all add to the humor and fun of the film.

    Lou Jacobi plays Kurt Gödel (1906-1978), Austrian born and later American mathematician and logician. Gene Saks plays Boris Podolsky (1896-1966), Russian-born physicist who taught at the University of Cincinnati and then Xavier University in Ohio. Joseph Maher plays Nathan Liebknecht, a fictitious character possibly based on Karl Liebknecht (1871-1919), a German Socialist.

    Meg Ryan is Catherine Boyd, Einstein's niece, who seems to have inherited his genes for genius. Her nose is buried in mathematical theories, and she plays a sometimes flighty character very well. Catherine is engaged to an English psychologist researcher, James Moreland. Stephen Fry plays the stuffy, snobby Moreland very well.

    Tim Robbins has a blue-collar job. He works in a service garage, but besides his brawn, he's something of an automotive engineering whiz without a diploma. His Ed Walters falls for Catherine the first time he sees her. The rest of the story is how Uncle Albert and his cohorts can manipulate things so that Ed can replace James as a match for Catherine. It's not a complex plot or very deep story. But it's fun and innocent. And, worth the time just to watch Matthau bring his wry manner to Albert Einstein's witty and personable character.

    Einstein wasn't just a physics genius and witty professor. He also was a provocative thinker who challenged modernist trends. Here are a few of his pearls of profound wisdom. "Science without religion is lame; religion without science is blind." "Great spirits have always encountered violent opposition from mediocre minds." "Weakness of attitude becomes weakness of character." "There are only two ways to live your life. One is as though nothing is a miracle. The other is as though everything is a miracle." "Peace cannot be kept by force. It can only be achieved by understanding."
  • jenn-742 November 2002
    One of those films with a great central idea and a fantastic cast that somehow just doesn't work. Why? Don't know. Possibly the script? Possibly the lack of chemistry? I've watched it a few times- each time expecting to "get it" this time. Not terrible- but disappointingly mediocre.
  • Likable story of Albert Einstein (convincingly played by the late Walter Matthau) playing "Cupid" for his beautiful young niece (the ever sweet Meg Ryan) and a car mechanic (Tim Robbins) who pretends to be the next "Einstein" to impress Ryan, who seems to be in search of a very smart husband, disregarding all other qualifying character trates.

    The authentic 1950s small-town setting is cute, but the story is so utterly far-fetched that not even a million to one could describe the odds of these events actually happening. The "fuddy duddy team" of grandpa pals act as "council of fairy godmothers" to ensure that two remote stars in the universe eventually meet. -- I liked the actors, but was very disappointed in the thin plot. "You've Got Mail" suddenly seems absolutely believable (NOT!).
  • Bottom line - best romantic comedy ever. This movie accomplishes what all great movies strive for: the creation of a world and time that we want to re-visit and makes us glad to be part of the human race. When I am blue, this movie lifts my spirit and makes me laugh (and that is still true after many viewings - always fresh).

    All of the actors are in top form. The characterizations are so dead on and the characters mesh so well together that you forget the actor (usually difficult to do with Matthau, Robbins and Ryan). The supporting cast is consistently brilliant: Fry ("agae", "a total pygmy package"!), Jacoby & Saks & Maher (the three theoretical physicists as "Greek chorus" - "but time doesn't exist"), Durning ("something we can launch from NJ"), Shalhoub & Whaley (Robbins' boss and co-worker at the service station), and Curits (Eisenhower - how many comedies have Eisenhower??).

    Don't miss this overlooked treasure.
  • Like other charming and sentimental romantic comedies, this one treads the thin line between the right amount of sentiment and charm, and too much damned sentiment and charm.

    Mostly it stays upright, only occasionally lapsing into unintentional bathos. Professor Einstein (Mattau) is compelled by convention to suffer a non-heart attack so that he must spend time in his hospital bed, weakly dispensing endorsements while his friends choke back tears. It's a death bed scene although there is nothing wrong with Einstein. Next time we see him he's back on his feet cranking out common sense and wisdom.

    As for the story, it's not unfamiliar but comes off okay. It's about Einstein promoting the romance between his neice Kathy (Ryan), a mathematical wizard, and a smart but otherwise ordinary garage mechanic (Robbins). She happens to be engaged to an experimental psychologist (Fry) whom everyone seems to dislike because -- well, because he gets in the way of the plot.

    It has its amusing moments. Robbins, the fake physicist, is trying to take a demanding public test on the subject and is signalled the correct answer by Einstein and his four dwarfs in the audience. Any resemblance to "Ball of Fire" is probably not coincidental. That may be the best scene, as the hospital visit is the worst. The dialog has its sparkle too. "If you had a nickel for every nickel HE has -- you would have a lot of nickels."

    Matthau gets Einstein down right, a kind of avuncular archetype. Ryan couldn't be cuter. If she were, she'd deliquesce. Robbins, however, is an inexpressive mope and adds little liveliness to a movie that, at times, really needs some -- the kind that Tony Shalhoub brings to the role of the owner and manager of Robbins' work place.
  • lyninbyron21 January 2021
    The story line was okay and the great cast of characters were entertaining to watch but after seeing Meg Ryan in countless interviews Over the years, behaving surly, bored and on the whole, like a childish brat, she leaves me feeling as though I can't be bothered with her either! Hey Meg, free advice: do interviews with enthusiasm and kindness or don't bother at all! You've come across as a VERY ugly, mean spirited, self involved pain in the behind !!!!
  • indyfam3 January 2005
    This is one of my all time favorites. It is so simple and sweet - definitely a chick flick romantic comedy. I really like a film full of good quotes and this has it... one of my favorites is when Albert Einstein says to Ed Walters "Are you thinking what I'm thinking" and Ed says "Now what are the odds of that happening!" In my opinion, a film is fabulous if you can watch it again and again and get the same amount of enjoyment out of it, and with this one, you can!! I also really enjoyed Walter M.s way of portraying Einstein. I think all the characters fit together really well and the story flows nicely. There are so many times that I find myself smiling right along with the film and quoting my favorite lines as I watch it! I would recommend this movie to anyone who has a heart and enjoys a feel-good romantic comedy now and then!
  • I've never been a Walter Matthau fan, but as Einstein in this film he's brilliantly cast and superb all round.

    Tim Robbins is romancing Einstein's niece, played by Meg Ryan, in this watchable romantic comedy.

    Most of it's complete nonsense of course, but Robbins is his usual excellent self and Matthau impresses.
  • Who would have thought that Walter Matthau could pull off a role as Albert Einstein? But he does. Well. Tim Robbins puts in a decent performance. Meg Ryan is, of course, cute cubed. However, the plot just doesn't carry through to the end. Nothing wrong with this film, but everyone involved has done better work elsewhere.
An error has occured. Please try again.