Nokes
Tommy
Father Bobby
John
Carol
King Benny
Danny Snyder
Ferguson
Shakes' Father
Fat Mancho
Shakes
Young Shakes
Michael
Young Michael
Young John
Young Tommy
Boyfriend
Male Juror (as Joe Attanasio)
Forensics Expert
Young John's Mother
Juanito (as William Butler)
Rizzo
Juror
Superintendent
Priest
Tony (as John DiBenedetto)
Addison
Business Man #1
Business Man #2 (as Reuben Larry Elliott)
Hot Dog Vendor
Waiter
Man #1
James Caldwell
Judge Weisman
Court Bailiff
Hanging Man
Styler
Dance Judge (as Chuck Lewis Low)
Priest #2 (as Father Peter Mahoney)
Woman at Subway Station
Davy
Nick Davenport (as Daniel Mastrogiorgio)
Sister Carolyn (as Mary McCann)
Guard
Lawyer
Inmate #2
Jury Forewoman
K.C.
Judge #1
Salvatore
Man in Tub
King Benny's Boy
Marlboro
Little Caesar
Mimi
Young Carol
Shakes' Mother
Young King Benny
Frank Magcicco
Man #2
Confessional Woman
Confessional Man
Carlson
Prison Doctor
Warden
Nun
Davy's Sister
Jerry the Bartender
Mrs. Salinas
Carson (as Joseph Urla)
Burly Man (uncredited)
Court Officer (uncredited)
Marine Widow (uncredited)
Market Diner Westie (uncredited)
Juvenile Lawyer (uncredited)
Customer (uncredited)
Kid in Cafeteria (uncredited)
Fat Mancho's Buddy #1 (uncredited)
Neighborhood Boy (uncredited)
Wiseguy (uncredited)
Neighborhood Man (uncredited)
Lawyer (uncredited)
Receiving Communion (uncredited)
Juror (uncredited)
Boy in Cafeteria (uncredited)
Pallbearer (uncredited)