The Two Girls (1951)

  |  Comedy

The Two Girls (1951) Poster

A famous singer disappears in a plane crash. Her two little girls are given a new home by their grandfather. Unfortunately the good man has an old housekeeper who goes out of her way to ... See full summary »



See all photos

Get More From IMDb

For an enhanced browsing experience, get the IMDb app on your smartphone or tablet.

Get the IMDb app

Reviews & Commentary

Add a Review

User Reviews

14 November 2017 | dbdumonteil
| Rich people are kind ...
Second remake of a hopeless melodrama ,after Louis Feuillade 's version in the silent era and a talkie in the mid-thirties.Aimed at the children's market ,it bears the appropriate scars of the reactionary time of the French screenwriter/director Feuillade.

Its moral could be :the richer,the kinder .The two gamines are two spoiled children ,who live in a luxury apartment with a TV set in 1951. The wicked governess ,Mrs Benazer is an old maid, who wants to latch on to the granddad's dough (for he has disowned his daughter who - what a shame!- has become a famous Chanteuse ); Suzy Prim makes the best of that part of a villain and gives by far the best performance in a rather bland flick.Treating the children cosseted by their mom like Cinderella or Cosette ,she goes out of her way to discredit them , to punish them and eventually to send them to a reformatory! Needless to say,when Prim is dismissed by the indignant granddad-and how long it takes him to realize his servant's sadism!-,the movie becomes worthless.

The fairy tale side could have renewed such a hackneyed subject: the sudden entrance of the shrew in the bedroom as Ginette is telling her tale to her kid sister Gaby looks like the appearance of a witch ;then the girls lost in the Bois De Boulogne (in chic Neuilly) who meet a prince and a princess .All this could have been fully exploited but nobody at all in the writers team had ever been in the business of supplying real poetry,fantasy ,savor,humor...

And this fairy-like side quickly degenerates into two-bit thriller ,with a strong sense of duty (the father who redeems himself thanks to his daughter's courage) , of bourgeois moral and lots of finer feelings.

Leo Marjane was first a Chanteuse ,her part is very small ,it actually boils down one tune or two ,the lullaby being particularly syrupy and soppy: so, eventually we can forgive Mrs Benazer for breaking the record!

Did You Know?


Plot Summary



Featured on IMDb

See what IMDb editors are watching this month, and visit our guides to what's on TV and streaming, video games, and more.

Around The Web


Powered by ZergNet

More To Explore

Search on