User Reviews (181)

Add a Review

  • The violent and rebel twenty-five years old sailor Antwone Fisher (Derek Luke) is sent to three sessions for evaluation with the navy psychiatrist Dr. Jerome Davenport (Denzel Washington), after another outburst and aggression against a superior ranked navy man. Reluctant in the beginning of the treatment, he gets confidence in Dr. Davenport and discloses his childhood, revealing painful traumas generated in his foster house. Meanwhile, he meets Cheryl Smolley (Joy Briant), and they fall in love for each other. Resolving his personal problems, Antwone becomes a new man. This true familial drama is a touching and positive story of a man who finds a friend and is sent back to a regular life. The direction of Denzel Washington is excellent, making sensitive, attractive and with good taste, a story about child abuse. In the hands of another director, it might be a very heavy story. My vote is eight.

    Title (Brazil): 'Voltando a Viver' ('Returning to Live')
  • jotix10028 August 2003
    Not having seen the film in the original theater release, I was happily surprised when the DVD arrived, since this film did not have the wide distribution it merited.

    Denzel Washington directorial debut and the finished product have nothing to envy other films about the same theme by more accomplished directors. The film has a very professional look. It shows that Mr. Washington has learned a lot being on the other side of the camera. He brings a different angle to this film.

    One of the best things the film has is, without a doubt, the fine performance by Derek Luke. He is an actor who, with the right guidance, will go far, no doubt. His take on the troubled young man, at this point of his life, in turmoil and suffering for a bad hand life, up to now, has dealt him, is very true. His Antwone is a fine portrait of a man in pain who is basically very good and has so much to give, but no one seems to see that side of his character.

    At the worst time of his despair, Antwone is sent to Dr. Davenport, played by Mr. Washington, in a very sober, if somehow subdued manner. Because of the angst within Antwone, he misses the opportunity of opening himself to this man, who wants to help, but because of the constrains placed on his office, just have three sessions and then has to dismiss his patient.

    Things work out, as Antwone is able to convince the doctor to keep on working with him. Antwone's past is revealed in detail. The abuse he suffers at the hands of Mrs. Tate, his foster mother, is brutal, to say the least. The attempt at the hand of an older woman in the Tate's household of a sexual molestation, gives Antwone a bitter taste that stays with him throughout his adult life, as he has been scarred by the shame he carries with him.

    Antwone finds love at last with Cheryl, who is patient enough to make him see a different world by the love she and support she gives him.

    The lead performances are very good indeed. Denzel Washington's Dr. Davenport has his own problems too. He is not a happy camper either. He can help Antwone, but he cannot help himself, or his relationship with an adoring wife.

    The talent in the film is incredible. Joy Bryant makes a fine Cheryl. Novella Nelson, who is a fine actress is superb as Mrs. Tate, the abusing foster mother.

    The reunion of Antwone with his unknown family is a bit too sugary and sentimental, but of course, if one is to believe that Fisher finds happiness at last, one has to accept that part of the film as well.
  • This is one of my all time favorites. Simple story about a complicated sailor (Derek Luke)prone to emotional outbursts. He starts seeing a naval psychologist (the fabulous Denzel Washington) who helps him sort through his demons, reflect on his past, and find the family he never knew. Raised in an abusive foster home, he is determined to make something of himself, and try to put the daunting past behind him.

    Along the way he gets a girlfriend who helps him and encourages him to find himself, and search for his roots.

    One of the coolest endings in a movie. I get teary-eyed every time.

    AWESOME movie!!!
  • b_blocke17 September 2005
    This is the ONLY movie I've ever been moved to write about. I rarely even watch movies let alone offer opinions, but this movie is exceptional in so many ways. The acting is powerful and believable (duh.. it's real..), and the entire story is totally captivating. I was watching on satellite and had to endure commercials, and it was sheer torture waiting for the movie to resume.

    This has to be one of, if not THE finest film ever made. Congratulations to EVERYONE, especially MR. Fisher. I'm a 55 year old guy that teaches in Cleveland and I never thought I would cry, but there I was with tears streaming down my face, all alone in my living room late at night. This story should be told and retold for generations to come. Thank you Mr. Fisher, Mr. Washington, and everyone else. This was a life-changing experience - not a movie. God bless you all for putting this together. I just can't figure out why this movie is not huge forever. Well, I suppose I can hazard a guess, but I truly hope I'm wrong - I think we all know what that guess is...

    Thanks again - not just for the movie, but for the most powerful message possible. If you haven't seen this movie, SEE IT NOW! You won't be sorry, but if you don't see it, you'll be missing the experience of a lifetime. BJL
  • jhuni_x27 April 2009
    Warning: Spoilers
    This movie describes the life of somebody who grew up in the worst of circumstances but unlike many people he actually grew up to be a respectable person. Whats more is that this is a true story.

    Antwone Fisher is so innocent and yet he was abused such just because he was not white. Antwone Fisher has been married to the same women for ten years and he never fooled around with women, coke, cigars, weed, alcohol, or any of those things that are very popular in the places he was growing up.

    There is not much more to say about this movie it is excellent. The only rating I can give it is a 10/10.
  • An adaption of the book 'Finding Fish'. This story is about a troubled young sailor Antwone Fisher (Derek Luke) who tells the painful story of his past to a psychiatrist Jerome Davenport (Denzel Washington). A brilliant debut performance by Derek Luke and an always stunning performance by Denzel Washington.

    This movie was incredible on so many levels and I was disappointed that it didn't win an Oscar, I think it was because it was released at a bad time that's why it was overlooked. I strongly recommend this film to everyone, you'll be touched by his story and it really does make the audience become empathetic with this young man that is Antwone Fisher.

    If you like inspirational true stories, then watch Antwone Fisher.

    Thank you
  • Based on a true story, and with a screenplay written by the real Antwone Fisher (who had never before written a screenplay), this movie is also Denzel Washington's first outing as a director, and Derek Luke's first starring role as Antwone. All these firsts made this a movie I wanted to see out of curiosity more than anything else, and in the end I was mildly impressed with it, although the movie is definitely not without its flaws.

    In particular, the first hour or so of the movie is very slowly paced. At times, it was tempting to turn away, but there was enough of interest that kept popping up to make me stick with it. In the end, this turned into an interesting enough journey of self-discovery, as we delve more and more into Antwone's past to try to discover what childhood demons have caused him to grow up into an angry young man. As slow-paced as I thought the movie was it's ironic that I also felt that it moved too swiftly through some things. Antwone's anger seems largely resolved by a handful of sessions with Commander Davenport, the Navy psychiatrist (played by Washington) and we really only see a couple of flashes of anger - hardly enough, in my view, to have him sent off to the psychiatrist in the first place. (I know that the fight depicted was probably one in a series. In real life, it made sense to send him to Davenport, but in the strict context of the movie it seemed a bit extreme.) Antwone's relationship with Cheryl (Joy Bryant) also seemed to develop very quickly. He takes her out once, all of a sudden she's his girlfriend and he's in love, then they're sharing a hotel room. (For a guy who has no experience with romance he's a natural!)

    But in spite of these inconsistencies and the slow pace of the first hour or so, the movie picks up nicely in the second half as Antwone begins to discover who he is and where he came from. The second half is actually quite interesting. Although it doesn't overcome some of the flaws I mentioned above, it nevertheless turns what had been looking for a while like a mediocre movie into a pretty decent one.

    6/10
  • rbrb20 December 2004
    A stunning film of high quality.

    Apparently based on true events which, as told, has the clear ring of truth about it, this movie is highly emotional and deeply moving.

    An abused and neglected child often becomes wayward in adulthood, as one of life's failures, be it as a gangster, drug addict or burden on society.

    Antwone Fisher as a young adult in the navy, is troubled. He is on the brink of being a loser. He is counselled in therapy by a psychiatrist and it is that relationship which takes center stage in the play.

    In flash-backs and therapy the source and remedies to Antwones angst are revealed.

    Outstanding performances from the whole cast. The story is in effect a family tragedy with emotional and physical torment. All the actors give full blooded performances with conviction and realism.

    One message from the movie is the importance of raising children decently.

    The real Antwone deserves success. To have endured wickedness as a child but to rise above that, shows a magnificent character.

    And to all those out there who have endured such torment but to have survived and succeeded: you are all winners. 10 out of 10.
  • Navy sailor Antwone Fisher (Derek Luke) is haunted by his past and starts a fight. He is forced to be evaluated by psychiatrist Dr. Jerome Davenport (Denzel Washington). He is volatile and uncooperative. Eventually he opens up about his abused past. His foster father Mr. Tate was a preacher and his foster mother was very abusive. He falls for fellow sailor Cheryl Smolley (Joy Bryant) but his outbursts continue to hound him.

    This is Denzel Washington's directorial debut and he shows confidence in his work. It doesn't hurt that he's one of the best actors around. He points the camera at himself and Derek Luke. The acting carries the day. He finds a real gem in the newcomer who holds his own against the veteran. There is a genuine spirit about the characters and the performances. Psychiatry sessions are always in danger of being static and that threatens this movie as well. The two actors generate enough energy to stay out of flat waters.
  • I was adopted at birth and certainly did NOT have the problems Antwone fisher had in the movie, but I still share some of the emotions and this movie really helped to bring them out and force me to deal with them. It even caused me to realize that I do have a "missing piece" and I am going to seek out my birthparents now.

    I cried for almost a day after I saw this the first time. Antwone's confrontation with his birthmother juxtaposed with his father's family's reaction to his sudden appearance are powerful for those of us who don't know what will happen if we find our birth parents. And his self-confidence and self affirmations to his mother and against the abusers of his past were so powerful. I could really identify with this and my need to tell people "yeah, I was put aside by my parents when I was born. BUT another set of parents picked me up and loved me. And now I am a success!"

    It also helped my wife understand me and our adopted children, who did go through tragic experiences before they came to our home. And it helped me to realize just how messed up our social system is. If you remember reading the story last year about the foster kid in Florida who was "lost" AND then the "Miranda & Ashley" story in Oregon City where SCF ignored multiple sexual abuse complaints about the man who ultimately killed them AND the week this movie was released, yet another story in New Jersey of three kids who were ignored by the system. One died. The state apparently thought the home they were in was ok because the guardian was employed (as a stripper) and "only occasionally" used heroin!

    There are just so many issues that are brought out in this movie - and they are dealt with so well by the script and by the acting that Antwone Fisher should be a "Best Picture" nominee for sure. No matter if you are adopted or not, it is a heart-tugger that can't be ignored by anyone concerned about children in our society.
  • Somewhere along the way the story of ANTWONE FISHER misses being the sort of film it starts out to be. The boy's miserable past is merely hinted at in a series of abusive moments that don't really correspond to why his anger management problems are so out of control. It takes psychiatric help from DENZEL WASHINGTON to set Antwone on the path of redefining himself as a person.

    And it all comes down to: trace your history, find your mother (he never knew his father who was killed), and reunite with your relatives. It seems a pat solution to a deep rooted problem and it gets rather superficial treatment from director Denzel, who gives it a Hallmark Hall of Fame sort of presentation--shifting midway through the story to sentimental theatrics with Fisher surrounded by a boatload of smiling relatives.

    Nothing about the screenplay is very original--you know, boy with abusive past grows up with a chip on his shoulder--and there are no new discoveries made here by either psychiatrist Denzel or the viewing audience.

    DEREK Luke and JOY BRYANT are fine as the leads who find tender romance together and begin the search for Luke's parent after an abusive foster mother finally gives him the name of his dead father. This leads to a reunion with an aunt and, finally, with the mother who abandoned him. This scene is extremely well acted and poignant, as the mother is unable to say a word to her son as he presents himself to her.

    But at the midway point in the story, where Denzel suggests the boy trace his roots, the story becomes overladen with sentiment to play at the heartstrings. And the final scene, with Denzel relating why his own relationship with his wife has been so strained, is just too pat when it's tied in with his client/patient relationship with Fisher.

    Summing up: A good movie could have been a great one with a stronger story of Fisher's past as the centerpiece.
  • Every one should see this movie because each one of us is broken in some way and it may help us realize 1) My life isn't as bad as I thought it was and 2) How important it is to adopt a child in need. There are so many out there. To think that the movie was actually based on a real person made us think deep about life and how the world has and always will be. Corrupt, but that corruption doesn't have to reach your home. We all have a choice! Definitely recommend this one... and while you're at it, I'd like to throw in "The Color Purple" and "Woman, Thou Art Loosed" by T.D. Jakes.

    These are all movies that are based on life and give us a glimpse of life.
  • Antwone Fisher (Derek Luke) is a navy officer with a short fuse who finds himself being referred to the navy doctor Jerome Davenport (Denzel Washington). At first, Fisher is standoffish and unwilling to open up to Davenport, but Davenport persists with the young officer and eventually Fisher does begin to try to explain some of the reasons for his behaviour. Davenport soon learns that Fisher had a troublesome childhood whilst he was growing up with his foster mother and Davenport believes that it may help Fisher's emotional psyche if he were to try and find his mother and make attempts to reconnect with his family.

    This is actually a nice story and from a narrative point of view it is very well-constructed and structured; essentially we'll witness something happening to Fisher that lands him in trouble and then we get flashbacks from his childhood which establishes motives for his behaviour in later life. The film uses this approach for much of its running time and it does work very well; you get the best of both worlds in some ways by witnessing some powerful dramatic moments and then we get some exposition explaining away why Fisher behaves in the manner that he does. It is a fairly well-written film which does a good job of developing its protagonist (although having the real life Antwone Fisher penning the screenplay probably helped the film a lot in this respect).

    According to the trivia section, the likes of Will Smith and Cuba Gooding JR auditioned for the role, but Washington refused and wanted an unknown actor to portray the lead character - this was probably a risk at the time, but one which, in the long run, probably paid off. Maybe it was budget constraints that forced Washington cast an unknown actor (who knows what sort of salary Smith or Gooding Jr wanted at the time) or maybe Washington knew that a film of this nature didn't have to rely on star power to get people to watch it after all everyone loves an uplifting feel-good story don't they? Whatever his reasons it was probably the right choice and Derek Luke really works hard here in crafting a character who is misunderstood, traumatised, deeply troubled, but he's also a character that is strong-willed and brave.

    From a narrative perspective this film is good and some of Washington's directing is also good, but the trouble with this film is that it does all feel a bit clinical, by-the-numbers and rather safe. It does have the feel of a Lifetime movie and it's clear when watching this film that Washington takes no real risks and whilst it is good in several parts, it is also quite weak in other areas - the film makes a big deal about Fisher meeting his mother and gives a big build-up to this occasion, but when the time comes for Fisher to meet his mother it all falls a bit flat and it doesn't have the emotionally satisfying pay-off that I was hoping for. Fisher's romance with Cheryl is also a weak part of the film which is both undercooked and underwhelming and to me isn't the most important aspect of the story - although it does seem to take up a good chunk of the film.

    Antwone Fisher is a nice uplifting story that will undoubtedly cheer you up if you're feeling down and I suppose in that respect it does its job. Despite my reservations above, I did like the film and I too found it uplifting and enjoyable, but it just wasn't quite the emotional punch to the gut that I was expecting it to be.
  • henry8-319 August 2018
    Based on a true story, Washington's directorial debut is a solid, linear melodrama focussing on the troubled past of Fisher resulting in anger issues which Navy psychiatrist Washington looks to resolve. Nicely played and rarely dipping into sentiment this is a watchable, unremarkable piece albeit the final act is well handled and quite moving.
  • The protagonist, Antwone Fisher is played by the up and coming young actor, Derek Luke. Luke is a young sailor, filled with rage, easily provoked, and often unable to control his emotional outbursts. His temper soon earns him several mandatory sessions with a naval psychiatrist; played by Denzel Washington (he also directed the film). Early on, their personalities clash, but eventually Washington unlocks the two sources of Luke's anger-an abusive childhood and a pervading fear of being abandoned.

    The film takes us on a journey of Luke's life, one marked by periods of intense loneliness and sadness while being driven by a constant search (an obsession) for family. It is through Luke's life that we learn that perseverance can carry us through the periods of darkness and eventually deliver some form of happiness

    By counseling and befriending Luke, Washington enables him to deal with his lifelong sadness and move on. When the film wants to grab at your heart, it succeeds with good writing and convincing performances by Luke and Washington. In a graphic abuse scene from Luke's childhood, Washington artistically and gutterly insures that we not only empathize with Antwone, we personally experience his helplessness. This scene, which showcases Washington's directorial skill, places Luke in a full frontal position, trembling, with the whites of his eyes looking directly at the camera (the viewer). Anyone watching the screen can't help but be mesmerized by the abject fear in Luke's eyes.

    As the film progresses, Washington, the director, introduces two minor twists to the plot. The first highlights Luke's reluctance to trust as he begins dating for the first time. This sub-point is purposeful and displays the infinite lingering effects of Luke's childhood on his adulthood. The second involves martial (family) problems within the psychiatrist's life which, while ironic, is never developed.

    Much like his performance as a compassionate lawyer in Philadelphia, Denzel Washington's screen presence in Antwone Fisher commands our attention and emotions, leaving few dry eyes in the theater. This film's writing, direction and acting exposes our souls and grabs our hearts.
  • =G=22 May 2003
    "Antwone Fisher" tells of a young black U.S. Navy enlisted man and product of childhood abuse and neglect (Luke) whose hostility toward others gets him a stint with the base shrink (Washington) leading to introspection, self appraisal, and a return to his roots. Pat, sanitized, and sentimental, "Antwone Fisher" is a solid feel-good flick about the reconciliation of past regrets and closure. Good old Hollywood style entertainment family values entertainment with just a hint of corn. (B)
  • jmvv-3806421 January 2020
    If there are two movies that made impact and have a special place in my heart, it most certainly are: Antwone Fisher & Forrest Gump. Antwone Fisher is an emancipating story of a struggle of a young black man growing up, standing on the crossroads and fighting the demons of his past. This movie also remind me of another comparable Masterpiece: the Color Purple.

    This movie really deserved Oscars for best directing, story and main character. The way Derek Luke performed his debut movie role was just excellent. And Sir Denzel Washington was sparkling as always: intelligent, sharp, descent, thoughtful and sophisticated. Deep, confronting and inspiring. Thank you for this movie. Respect!
  • Thanos_Alfie16 January 2022
    "Antwone Fisher" is a Biography - Drama movie in which we watch a psychiatrist trying to help a young navy man who is forced on attending therapy after a violent incident. His treatment is not easy as more information from his past are revealed.

    I found this movie very interesting since it was inspired by true events, it had a nice and interesting plot. The interpretations of both Denzel Washington who played as Dr. Jerome Davenport and Derek Luke who played as Antwone Fisher were very good and they both made the difference on this movie. The direction which was made by Denzel Washington was very good and the help that he received from Antwone Fisher the writer, helped him to create this beautiful movie. Lastly, I have to say that "Antwone Fisher" is a nice biography movie and I recommend it to everyone.
  • Continuing my plan to watch every movie in Denzel Washington's filmography, I come to a movie I had never heard of Antwone Fisher

    Denzel Washington's directorial debut, is amazing. It's also amazing to think this was Derek Luke's first movie. Joy Bryant is gorgeous Viola Davis has a small but stand out role, as does Verne's Watson, who I always like to see, and Kevin Connelly from John Q is here, too.

    For his first effort, Denzel does an amazing job, as does all of the actors. Everyone should watch this movie. I'm not going to lie, I teared up at the end, even though I knew where it was going.

    Disappointingly Antwone Fisher only grossed $21 million at the domestic box office and was the first Denzel Washington movie not to finish in the 100 highest grossing movie of the year, since Mississippi Masala in 1991.
  • Antwone Fisher is a rather simple film that is one of those movies where you wish it wasn't based on a true story. Sadly, Antwone Fisher is a real man who used this script to tell his story to the world. It's not easy to watch because Denzel Washington as director does not pull any punches with his portrayal of events and rarely leaves things up to the viewer's imagination. While it's hard to say I liked the movie, I can say there is a cathartic satisfaction that I was able to derive from watching Antwone's journey. It certainly helped that he cast himself as the psychiatrist who works with the young man, because he is always such a comforting presence. I loved every scene with him, and kind of wish he could have taken a more active role in the climax of the movie. Derek Luke is decent in the titular role, but I felt he remained a bit closed off emotionally with his performance even when the scenes started to demand a bit more vulnerability from his character.

    While I appreciate all that the movie is trying to do in order to tell this dark story of a young man who was neglected and abused, but managed to rise above his upbringing, it's not particularly unique. It's an awful thing to say, but there wasn't enough to set this dark story about a traumatic childhood, apart from other dark stories about traumatic childhoods. I did enjoy some of the things Washington did with shot selection and setting up the dreams of a welcoming family greeting young Antwone that is echoed a few other times in the film. I simply wasn't particularly blown away by anything other than Denzel's performance in the movie. They even have the great Viola Davis in there and she only gets 2 lines of dialogue. I kept wanting more from Antwone Fisher, but it seems that the filmmakers' philosophy was to keep it simple. And, admittedly, while I wasn't wowed by the movie, it did bring some tears to my eyes which means they tapped into some real emotions. But it's not a film I expect I would ever want to watch again.
  • In his directorial debut, Denzel Washington takes a true story that also happens to be a very difficult story and brings it to the screen with an honesty that we have come to expect from Washington's acting efforts, but now we see this touch as a director.

    Recently we have seen some of the disastrous results of kids who have fallen through the cracks of public protection. This story tells of a nightmare existence that leaves terrible scars but suggests the triumph of the human spirit in the end.

    We can nit pick on some first effort problems with too many close ups and not the best of editing these scenes but the simplicity of other scenes that project such power cannot be understated.

    If the academy overlooks this film it will be travesty. This film pulls no punches and goes to the cold hard facts of the story with a purity that usually doesn't transcend from a novel to the screen. This , of course , is a tribute to the Director.

    This is a dandy so go see it and tell your friends to go see it too!
  • irusvirus10 June 2023
    A well-done film implementation of a truly shocking biography. Unfortunately, the story is not an isolated case and many children share such a fate. At first I thought that the film would have much more to do with the US Navy, but it only plays a small role as a setting. The film needs much more time to get to the point. After such terrible experiences in childhood, as our main character experienced, it understandably also takes time. I found the film very pleasant in the first half, which the acting and the tempo indicate, but towards the end it became a bit slow and predictable. For his age (2002) I think it's a good movie, which is why I can give him 7/10 stars. But I can't say whether it is really recommended for everyone.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    The story is formulaic and sentimental, but the resolution to Antwone Fisher's (Derek Luke) search for his past is inspiring. The unintended consequences that could have resulted from his goal could have been an affirmation of his fear of the unknown, but instead turned out to be profoundly more worthwhile when Antwone discovered a family he never knew. At the same time, the military psychiatrist who worked with him (Denzel Washington) learned something about himself as well. That undercurrent of Dr. Davenport's emotional distance from his wife (Salli Richardson-Whitfield) was ever present throughout the picture without the viewer ever knowing why until it was brought home in one of the closing scenes. A most telling moment in the picture was when Antwone's mother resisted his attempt to reconcile a troubled childhood past, and he was able to rise above his former chaotic emotions to finally find peace with himself and those who abused him in the past. Based on a true story, one can come away knowing that for some with a strong will and desire to succeed, even the most horrible childhood past can be overcome by compassion and love, and a willingness to change. For those who haven't seen the picture, prepare for an emotional response and keep a facial tissue handy.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    The story is familiar and one can't help but compare this to other psychiatrist films but what the main character reveals from his past is much more horrible than the rest of them. Story takes place in San Diego where Antwone Fisher (Derek Luke) is a sailor that has a bad temper and frequently gets into fights with his fellow seamen so his commanding officer sends him to Navy Psychiatrist Dr. Jerome Davenport (Denzel Washington). It takes a while for Antwone to open up but once he does he reveals a past that it truly heartbreaking. He was born in prison where his mother was an inmate and once she got out she never came for him. His father was killed when he was an infant and he had to live in a very abusive foster home.

    *****SPOILER ALERT*****

    Antwone meets Cheryl (Joy Bryant) and they start to date and this helps him to respond better to people in general and eventually Dr. Davenport tells him that he needs to find his real family for some closure. Antwone and Cheryl fly back to Cleveland where he confronts some of the people from his past so that he can try and track down his mother.

    This is Washington's directorial debut and he does an admirable job of painting a thorough picture of Antwone and even though the film could have benefited from some tighter editing it's still a film that delivers all the emotional goods. Arguably the most impressive thing about this film is the casting of Luke who was a total unknown actor with a mere handful of television credits to his resume and obviously Washington knew he possessed the right goods to pull off the role. Two things seem to hurt this film (Somewhat) and the first is the familiarity of the storyline. We have all seen lots of psychiatrist/patient films like "Good Will Hunting", "Equus", and "Prince of Tides" but this definitely does have something extra to add to the genre. The main flaw of the film comes from the side story of Washington's relationship with his wife and the end speech that he gives Antwone is ridiculous. "Thank you Antwone, for making me a better doctor and a better man", "I salute you". C'mon, did anyone really buy that? But the scene towards the end of the film where he meets his new family packs an emotional wallop that just can't be forgotten. Film is well made and the lead performance by Luke is a real standout.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    Denzel Washington's debut as a director starts off as a lively, if very familiar pairing of troubled seaman Fisher (Derek Luke in a fine performance) and a Navy psychiatrist (well-played by Washington) assigned to find out why his patient has a hair-trigger temper which leads him to violence.

    As Fisher goes through the usual scenes of initial distrust until that first breakthrough, we begin to see the harsh reality of the man's childhood, one marked by abandonment and traumatic physical & sexual abuse at the hands of a foster family.

    In the meantime, we're also provided with Fisher's first romance with a fellow female in the Navy, as well as a glimpse of Washington's troubled marriage.

    Once it's clear that Fisher is on the way to recovery, the film loses it's narrative energy and starts to drag. The story is certainly engrossing in itself, but the presentation (i.e. the direction) is pretty by-the-book, which ultimately grows wearisome.

    While Fisher's story is largely fact-based, the dramatic arc is no different than many other stories of the same nature, so it would have served Washington well if he had shaped the material differently so that it wouldn't seem so familiar - no matter how inspiring. Also, the romance between Fisher and the woman is charming, but pretty mild in its dramatic impact.

    There is one powerful scene near the end where Fisher finally meets the birth mother who abandoned him. Viola Davis, an excellent actress who got a well-deserved Tony Award for her work in August Wilson's "King Hedley II," has few lines in this scene, but she doesn't need them. Her face and body language do more than words could.

    Unfortunately, the effect of this scene is undercut by the next scene, an unbelievable ending in which Fisher is greeted by the entire extended family of his late birth father - somehow, his aunt managed to get the entire clan together in a matter of an hour or so and put together a breakfast feast. "Uplifting"? Yes, but far-fetched. Films don't need to work this hard to drive home the importance of family.
An error has occured. Please try again.