Horatio Hornblower: The Fire Ship (1998 TV Movie) User Reviews (14)

Tests

[TBJCSKCNRRQTreviews · 8/10 · 13 October 2013]

Horatio(portrayed well by Gruffudd, imbuing him with a strong sense of justice, and a smart, outside-of-the-box approach) will be taking the examination for lieutenant. Before that, however, he and the rest of the crew of the Indefatigable suffer under halved rations - the Spanish cease their neutrality in the British/French war, and supply ships are a favored target. When a situation already on the edge of survival sees its few resources disappearing, how will the men cope?

The many dangers and risks of sea-faring continue to be explored, both those that come from the outside and the ones from the inside(not everyone can handle less food). All of the acting and character-writing is compelling, rendering everyone a human being, no one is a mere "type". This is impressive for how many are in the cast - of course not everyone gets equal time for development, but no one is presented as a caricature.

The filming and editing is superb - perspective is used well and the level of detail, the way everything has both a setup and a payoff is impressive. This is highly realistic. It doesn't shy away from the nasty stuff. The themes are strong: human relationships, respect, inner strength, etc.

There is disturbing, bloody, and brutally violent content in this. I recommend this to any fan of drama. 8/10

2nd adventure of a great maritime hero

[TheNorthernMonkee · 7/10 · 16 March 2005]

SPOILERS As the Hornblower series continued with it's second episode, it continued to keep the audience attracted and kept our focus. With a plot dealing more with the negative moments of a time aboard ship, the story is not as fast and tense as the opening part, but it remains well made and entertaining none the less.

As an acting Lieutenant about Captain Pellew's (Robert Lindsay) Indefatigable, Hornblower (Ioan Gruffudd) is working on his exam to become full lieutenant. Unable to find any time to himself on a confined ship however, he also has to face up to rationing and a personal hero in the form of Captain 'Dreadnought' Foster (Denis Lawson).

Reintroduced to Hornblower, we are reminded once more of Ioan Gruffudd's superb acting skills. Stressed and unable to focus, Gruffudd's Hornblower is brilliantly shown to be advancing in age and experience throughout.

Aided by recurring regulars Lindsay, Paul Copley and Sean Gilder, Gruffudd is aided this time by a well played performance by Denis Lawson as the arrogant and 'gung-ho' Foster. It's no wonder with casting and performances like this that the series has become such a success.

Compared with it's previous episode however, this second outing for Gruffudd's Hornblower suffers from the simple fact that the plot is not quite as lively. Whilst brilliantly portraying scurvy and the problems with a ship short on food and with an unhappy crew, it does lack a lot of the excitement possessed by the first encounter. This is not a bad thing since variety and the covering of a wider world is always good, but with the exception of an explosive conclusion, it does feel lacking at times.

All in all, it's difficult to fault any episode of this majestic series. Interesting and addictive from the word go, this series has given joy to countless numbers. In this second episode, we are again given brilliant acting and gritty realism. It's distinctively slower than it's predecessor though. Still, even a slow Hornblower episode is a million times better than most television dramas. Watch and love.

A little bit more polished in direction than The Duel (Even Chance)

[CubsandCulture · 8/10 · 22 February 2021]

Gruffudd continues to give a tremendous performance as the titular hero and if nothing else the coming of age story is engaging. Likewise, the script continues to feel like the novels while expanding the segments in delightful ways. But I still find the production values to be detrimental in that they feel cheap. This film is better than The Duel (Even Chance) because the direction is more sure handed. The film feels like a second go at the cinematic language of this type of story by a director who learned from making the first film.

If America only knew how good this was.

[TexasRedge · 10/10 · 17 April 2002]

If America only knew how good this was,it would be the highest rated Made-For-TV movie series of all time(hard to believe there are more people out there that would rather watch "The Columbo Mysteries" than Horatio Hornblower- that just goes to show the power of major network name-brand advertising.

The Hornblower movie series has been television at its finest. I have seen all 6 of the A&E Horatio Hornblower movies,"The Duchess and the Devil" is my favorite of the 6 films. However I tune in to A&E everytime they air a new Hornblower movie. So far all 6 movies have been based on the Horatio Hornblower adventure novels written by C.S. Forester(the same author who wrote African Queen). Each Movie chronicles the on-going adventures of Horatio Hornblower who is a Brittish Lt. in the Brittish Navy during the late 1790's-to early 1800's during the Napoleonic era in Europe. I sincerly believe that each one of these 6 Films has been good enough to have shown at the movie theaters,if the producers had wanted to. Unlike other Made-For-TV films,The Hornblower films do not have that Made-For-TV feeling to them,like most television movies have.

A common misconception that people who havent seen these movies have is that all 6 of these films go to gether as a mini-series- that is not true. The Hornblower movies are not a mini-series,all 6 of these films are individual movies about the same charactor- with all the same actors playing the same roles in each film(EXAMPLE:think of the James Bond films-They are not sequels, but they are all about the adventures of James Bond- that same principle applies to the Hornblower movies) I give the entire Horatio Hornblower movie series 5 out of 5 stars. Its Perfect entertainment- but you cant please everyone, so for those of you dont like epic battleship battles,historic style drama,high stakes adventure, and danger on the high seas,if you dont like stuff like that-there is always Columbo re-run for you to watch.

Another success

[yaelbenisrael · 14 July 2000]

I do not agree with Altea. The plot of the second episode of "Hornblower" is just as good as that of the first, and is quite far from being flat. Perhaps there is a little too much emphasis on the courage, luck, cleverness etc. of young Hornblower, turning him into a "mr. perfect", but that is understandable, and I think that he is still a very human character, certainly more human than the annoying never-do-wrongs from Hollywood movies. I still think this is one of the best shows I've seen, and I can't wait to see the next episode (hoping that my parents won't forget to tape it for me).

Brilliant!

[annalisa-2 · 10/10 · 12 February 2000]

Although I am not anything like a history-buff, I must say that I loved watching Hornblower. Andrew Grieve did an amazing job. He turned, together with the writer, of course, C.S Forester's book into a completely understandable, exiting adventure. Ioan Gruffudd did a fantastic job playing Horatio Hornblower, but let's not forget the other cast members: Robert Lindsay, Sean Gilder, Colin MacLachlan and all the others were outstanding too. Together they made a wonderful story, which, although it happened about 300 years ago, is still incredibly up to date.

Excellent, interesting and nice film!!!

[kure98 · 10/10 · 20 May 2001]

Only three words to comment an excellent film, a wonderful realization, and a very nice DVD registration. Will you make a spanish subtitles edition? I'm sure it will be a success in Latin America and Mexico. Congratulations!

Plimsoll Line Goof

[tmatthews-98819 · 8/10 · 12 January 2020]

Pretty sure the Plimsoll Line wasn't invented until 1875, so I was pretty surprised to see it near the stem of the Indefatigable.!! Someone didn't have musch attention to detail

The Examination for Lieutenant

[Prismark10 · 6/10 · 12 October 2017]

After a strong first episode, 'The Examination for Lieutenant' is rather flat as Hornblower studies for his exam and then finds that the Indefatigable has a serious supply problem.

The crew are put on half rations which causes problems for some crew members, one of whom has to be punished.

After going with a group of men to find some supplies including cattle, Hornblower finds he and his men might be at risk from the plague and need to be in quarantine.

Hornblowers examination is cut short as he and Captain 'Dreadnought' Foster dash to climb aboard a burning ship to alter its course and stop hit hitting the Indefatigable.

You still see Hornblower reacting to events, showing bravery and thinking through each problem that he encounters. It is worth just to see Captain Pellew's face when he sees Hornblower steering the stricken ship. However it lacked the excitement of the first film and felt overlong.

Classic sea fairing drama!

[salty-9 · 28 May 1999]

Since the series of Hornblower began, I have waited quite anxiously for the next episode. The cast is excellent, the plot well thought out, and the battle scenes terrific. Ioan Grufford is excellent as the young Horatio Hornblower, and it's good to see a Derby actor such as Robert Lindsay back in a major role. Definitely worth watching this episode as it is one of the best for drama and action.

Adventure on the high seas

[salty-9 · 7 June 1999]

Quite an interesting story from the makers of 'Sharpe'. The plot, based on the novels of C.S. Forester, is well acted, especially from young Ioan (Titanic) Gruffudd. The cast, including Derby actor Robert Lindsay, is well suited. The story runs at quite a good pace and the plot keeps you on the edge till the end. Hopefully I.T.V. will make another series of this good sea faring adventure.

A disappointment???

[altea · 21 January 2000]

Having seen the first in the series of 4 movies, I was quite eager to see the next installment of the saga! Well, I have to admit that I was disappointed after seeing it! Disappointed not in the overall production value of the movie, because that was as terrific as the first movie, but in the story department! The story was very flat with almost no tension! In the first movie you had conflicts on several levels like the way of life on the ship, the arguments between the crew, the looming of war...and finally the hate until death between Hornblower and a crew member! In this movie you had almost the exact story items i.c. Hornblower rescues, Hornblower being lucky, Hornblower being alone with a little crew on a boat/ship...even the end of the movie where the captain thanks Hornblower is the same! Conclusion: beautiful movie with a flat story! Hopefully the next movie will have a different structure!

An extremely well cast, acted, and produced historic film.

[oscar-35 · 25 May 2017]

*Spoiler/plot- Horatio Hornblower 2003, Follows the exploits of a young midshipman to become ship's commander. The audience experiences the thrilling adventures of the ultimate high-seas hero in the British Navy at the outset of the French Napoleonic naval Wars.

*Special Stars- Ioan Gruffudd as the series title's name character.

*Theme- Accomplishing your best and being civil while doing that make will make you go far.

*Trivia/location/goofs- Emmy winning TV series. TV movie. Shot mostly on the Black Sea on a Turkish sailing ship.

*Emotion- An extremely well cast, acted, and produced historic film series from the Brits about Brit history. A 'must have' classic adventure series.

*Based On- The famous book British Napoleonic war series of C.S. Forester.

Good but lacked Archie

[slaybelle_15 · 11 November 2001]

Slight, slight spoiler ahead.

To some people I'm sure The Fire Ships is the best Hornblower movie. I think it was very good but lacked something. Archie. Yes I have soft spot for Blond sidekick. I want more Archie if I want anything from Hornblower. And this movie had no Archie.

That isn't saying that this movie was bad overall. The diplomat is funny. Denis Lawson is okay. Horatio wears some very attractive clothes (namely the straw hat and the long pants.) The plot is action packed (but who actually thought that Horatio wouldn't solve all his problems.)

If you watched the first one watch this one. Mourn the lack of Archie and then watch the third one. You'll be happy.