User Reviews (2)

Add a Review

  • Einar and Else have found happiness together, in a marriage that lacks only one thing; a child. Einar, who has a tendency towards melancholy, enters a deep depression, bordering to the psychotic, and the handling of this is the plot of the film.

    One thing about watching a Norwegian film from 1951 is the stiff way they talk and the generally theater like acting. But this one even has a political element, easily fascinating 55 years after (and counting). I can't bring myself to doubt the general concern, implied in the film, for the way people with mental disorders are viewed in society (a theme discussed widely in the film is the "fear most people feel for the insane"). But then again - the glorification of electric shock therapy is just - insane, no pun intended. "It's like antibiotics for the soul". People really did believe that.

    Anyway, Edith Calmar was one of the first recognized female Norwegian film directors, among other things was the first Norwegian AND a very early woman, to direct film noir. I wouldn't really call this film film noir, but you can certainly recognize some of the aesthetic.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    Finding a Nordic and 1950's cinema viewing challenges taking place on ICM,I decided to try to explore Nordic cinema across that decade. Checking my unwatched downloads for 1951, this was the first title to pop up,leading to me visiting the ward.

    View on the film:

    Opening the door and panning towards the character Dr.Lunde speaking directly to the viewer about the events about to be shown, director Edith Carlmar & cinematographer Per Jonson sea-saw between treating the subject of mental health problems with a professionalism in following Dr. Lunde and the nurses talking to each "Forgotten" patient daily in a warm, respectful manner, strangely contrasted by Carlmar and Jonson with abrasive turns into Horror/Thriller territory,covering Dr.Lunde in low-lighting as if he is from a "Mad Scientist" flick,and Einar losing all hope in a final chase.

    Sensitively having Dr.Lunde say to Else/the viewer that there is nothing wrong/should not be a stigma of having to commit a person to a mental health ward, the screenplay by Otto Carlmar goes through similar mood swings as Carlmar's directing. Compassionately presenting Einar as a kind, but troubled manner with deep concerns about mental health issues in his family history, Carlmar goes from one moment having Einar go into in-depth discussions with Dr. Lunde, to Einar being chased to a table for shock therapy.