Charas: A Joint Effort (2004) User Reviews (7)

Surprisingly good

[AishFan · 6/10 · 12 July 2004]

From the cast and look of the movie, this seemed to be another one of those "harsh look at reality" films. This isn't your typical underworld/mafia movie, though. It looks at a new aspect of the underworld--drug smuggling in a specific region of India which supposedly produces the best heroine in the world. You're probably thinking, yeah, and that's supposed to make it any less boring? I actually thought this was an extremely intelligent film.

The plot becomes more and more complex and convoluted as the movie goes on.

It's an interesting search of a British botanist who has been declared missing ever since he entered the notorious jungle taken over by a gangster known as Policeman (who also has a very interesting story), where grows the deadly plant. Songs are lame, except for the title song. Most people will not like this movie, but if you're up for such a fare, you might want to check it out.

So near yet so far

[spyder-19 · 6/10 · 1 June 2004]

Timangshu Dhulia, in my opinion, is one of the more talented filmmakers in the Bollywood jungle. His debut film, Haasil, was quite an honest attempt at showing prevalence of student politics in northern India. It suffered from shoddy editing but the intensity of the director and the actors were enough to hold the movie together. Charas has the same intensity from the actors, particularly Irfan (my favourite). But it seems Dhulia is trying to make a noveau Hare Rama Hare Krishna, what with the choppy editing and the hippie feel to the film. There are moments in Charas when I was completely engrossed and then the next minute the tension falls flat. It was a classic case of so near yet so far.

A definitive watch for those people who think Bollywood is all stereotypical

[shariqq · 7/10 · 8 May 2005]

In my review of ROG, I had mentioned that I have pledged myself to try and watch every movie Irfan Khan acts in. Charas falls within that line of study, and I am again kept far away from disappointment.

Charas, "A work of fiction based on real facts", tells the story of a Heron plantation "somewhere in the hills of India" that produces the best Heroin in the world, the man who runs it and the involvements of other power-players with it - from international Mafia, to cops, to politicians. In midst of all this, a British desi cop is trying to find a lost Englishman with the help of a street-guide from Delhi.

The two lead pairs: Jimmy Shergil as the Brit-desi cop, Uday Chopra as the Delhi-street-smart-guide, Hrishita Bhatt as a girl from the Hills & Namrata Shrodkar as a sort of con-girl play convincing roles for the looks, but not much can be said about their performances. For that matter, none of the performances add any credibility to any of the actors, except for the man - Irfan Khan. Afer watching a few movies of his, I realize he has his own style of portrayal, and he just tweaks a few knobs to become the character he is to. He is something like a desi serious Vince Vaughn - one style, but easily fits anything.

Charas is directed by the wonderful Tigmanshu Dhulia; he also made the taut Haasil with half the stars of this movie. This man belongs to the wave of directors that Bollywood has seen come-up in the past few years. These people work on a script, and then stick to it. They work on smaller budgets, base their story in the real world, and do not have chorus dancers at the drop of every emotion. These movies make a watch, more than anything for their departure from mainstream formulaic commercialism. And Charas falls in the above-average bracket of movies made within the said. Yes, it is lacking in some places, but quite fulfilling too. And most fulfilling in it's telling. The way the story progresses and unfolds is quite a treat. The characters are also quite deep, each driven with his/her own beliefs. I so did not miss any of the Khans . The songs are not speed-bumps but still unnecessary.

On the whole, a definitive watch for those people who think Bollywood is all stereotypical. I've lent the DVD to a friend who "does not believe in Hindi movies".

My Rating --> 3.5 of 5

An engraving masterpiece. Underrated gem.

[sansan-861-763934 · 7/10 · 17 May 2020]

This interpretation for the time it portrays is somewhat what was, no complaints though. Beautifully captured.

A grade movie

[sukhi44 · 10/10 · 17 June 2005]

This movie had it all, action, adventure, thrills and great dialogues. Irfan was as usual top-notch. Songs were entertaining and the plot was intelligently developed by the director. The cast and director have made this film from their heart. But as expected these type of Hindi movies go unnoticed by indians abroad and the west. They only like to watch yash chopra's-Johar-Khan processed so-called emotional family dramas. But which are actually d-grade romantic chick flicks. because of these movies, bollywood is laughed upon and no taken seriously by the west! Well done tigmanshu, irfan and co, after haasil you have delivered again... keep trying, hopefully next time will yield better box office gains.

Eight stars

[nikree · 10/10 · 13 June 2020]

Movie is quiet commendable. Has it's share of flaws but definitely not as depreciated by average ratings.

10/10 for writing But screenplay is debatable, where second half is dragging. Irreparable scenes of characters walking here and there are a few.

But writing, again needs special mention. As the interconnected multiple character world almost created a successful fantasy universe.

This movie is at par could be discussed with other crime bests of bollywood, like sacred games. But because of its imperfections, lags behind.

Movie could be skipped, as not a must watch. But definitely worth watching, if nothing better to do, with a little fast forward in second half is advisable.

It is not as good as Tigmanshu's previous endeavour- Haasil, which was well made, and almost flawless by his times. But this movie, provides a great trajectory for the growth of this director towards making great movies like Sahib Biwi series.

Is desh ke saath mazaak kiya jaa raha hai

[shounak9325 · 10/10 · 28 June 2023]

Ok we live in a country where a masterpiece like charas is rated 5.3 on imdb. There is a monologue in the film, "this country is being joked with". But actually this country is a joke itself.

Irfan's best performance till date, uday & jimmy correcting their mistake of mohabbatein, the most detailed movie on indian drugs ever made. This is a pure classic in all aspects. Dhulia's best as a director. Released much ahead of time. Could be a gem for ott viewing. Released along with another classic Khakee & both failed to create that impact what it was made. But did they actually fail? No, Humanity failed in 2004.