Benjamin Steed
Mary Ann Steed
Joshua Steed
Nathan Steed
Melissa Steed
Rebecca Steed
Matthew Steed
Lydia Steed (as Sera Bastian)
Jessica Steed
Joseph Smith
Emma Smith
Martin Harris
Carl Rogers (as Curtis Anderson)
Obadiah
Mother Smith
Parley Pratt
John Griffith
George Simpson
Robert Johnson
Caroline Mendenhall
Will Mendenhall (as Connor Chivarria)
Boggs
Mormon Woman
Woman #2
Reverend Samuel Bogart
Brigham Young
Pidgeon
Joshua Sexias (as Andrew Stahl)
Philo Driggs
Annie
Brother Rawson (as Greg J. Welsch)
Bully
Miranda
Eli
Father Smith (as Stephen Ayers)
Jacob Bump (as Jeffrey Ford)
Man (as Sam V. Sharp)
Margaret
Mormon Man
Rachel
Warren Parrish
Little Joshua
Woman
William Smith
Church Elder
Mormon Boy (uncredited)
Man in Church / Man with Rifle (uncredited)
Gunman (uncredited)
Townsperson (uncredited)