User Reviews (12)

Add a Review

  • I noticed one of the other reviews on IMDb for this episode REALLY hated this episode--referring to it as 'mumbo jumbo'. Well, I can respect their opinion but I actually liked it. Perhaps this is because I've already seen all the episodes and know where it's all heading. The bottom line is that there is an odd religious angle to the series and it's probably something you'll either love or hate. And, I must admit that there is a lot of stuff that ain't exactly typical of other sci-fi TV shows!

    When the episode begins, Captain Sisko is looking at an odd obelisk that was discovered on Bajor. But soon he becomes VERY transfixed with the object--neglecting sleep, eating or his other duties. It turns out that he's having visions that are being given to him by the Prophets. In fact, one of these leads him to discover a previously hidden holy city--an astounding find indeed. But, it's also very bad because the visions are taking a toll on him and unless they can get him away from the obelisk and operate, he'll die. It's also very bad because the visions don't fit in with the Federation and its plans.

    This is a weird episode full of mumbo jumbo--but I liked it and the overall plot and LOVE where it eventually leads (the final few episodes are mind blowing, believe me). Watch it and try to withhold judgment until you see the rest.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    When the Cardassians return a painting of the Bajoran lost city of B'hala Captain Sisko is determined to find it, there is a clue in the picture and he uses the holosuite to create a three dimensional image of the obelisk which is believed to give the location. Before he solves the mystery there is an accident and soon after he begins to have visions. This is happening at a bad time as Bajor is due to join the Federation and Sisko is meant to be taking a leading role in the ceremony. His visions do lead to the discovery of the city but they also start to make him ill but even though Dr. Bashir says it could kill him he refuses to be treated believing he has more to learn from his visions. Indeed his next vision tells him something that comes as a shock to everybody and will have profound implications for the future of Bajor.

    This was a fairly good episode which returns to a plot thread which started all the way back in the first episode, namely whether or not Bajor would join the Federation. I quite liked the fact that we weren't shown Sisko's visions, this helped maintain a sense of mystery.
  • Hitchcoc29 October 2018
    I will take the word of the reviewer who has seen all the episodes that this is heading somewhere fantastic. Unfortunately, as I make my way through Season 5, another romp in the Bajoran mythos just kind of turns me off. The whole Emissary thing is a bit much. I remember when Ben went to the surface and again got zapped (sort of; he's been zapped on numerous occasions) and the Bajorans embraced him. As I watch them wandering around the space station, it's hard to believe that they ever started a revolution. Sisko gets caught up in the puzzle presented by an obelisk that is found in the Lost City. The results involve the contrived situation of Jake having to make a game-changing decision. I don't know. For me, the Bajorans are so tiresome.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    Well, we are heading into serialized star trek territory and it becomes a bit of a challenge to properly review episodes that end up being only a few brush strokes on a painting. How does one review an episode who's meaning only becomes known in future episodes?!

    If the goal of the episode was to confirm sisko's belief in being the emissary then it was a rousing success but from an engagement point of view I was not exactly on the edge of my seat. Some have stated that this episode was an examination of the reactions from different type of belief systems to the dilemma faced by Sisko's life being in peril if the visions are allowed to continue ----- I suppose that is the case. They took a real soft ball approach to a close examination of the conflicts between these differing view points.

    Not enough in this episode for me. I suppose you can call it a prologue episode.
  • For many lovers of Star Trek, spiritually is an anathema, but there are lines and ties between spirituality and science. This is why they shouldn't be mixed politically, etc., because it is scary.

    DS9 tackles so many themes - alienation, war, parenthood, science, etc....

    This episode is about choice, and the lengths we go for the things we believe in; the end of episode and the choice made ties it all up. Funny thing complexity, it's easily misinterpreted or too often positively adjudicated.
  • geogyf14 February 2014
    Warning: Spoilers
    I really liked this episode of Deep Space 9.

    It sets the tone & the importance of the Emissary even more. This is an episode about faith.

    Faith in believing in something that may surpass you (which is a good thing), and when you go too far for some things in the name of faith.

    Faith is one of the best traits of man and it shapes our very nature (faith in a god, faith in ourselves, faith in humanity etc).

    But like all things, but put too much faith and it may lead into zealotry. In this episode we see all kinds of faith.

    From the prophet (sisko) who is willing to kill himself for visions, to Sisko's family (belief in son/husband), to the simple believer (kira), to the scientific believer or non believer (dax, bashir), to the organized believer (kai winn) and to the neutral observer/non-believer (Admiral Whatley).

    And what a finale from Cpt. Sisko and a honest answer to the admiral.

    Once again, DS9 is dealing with a sensitive matter, and delivers.
  • Bashir's Uniform is "A Little Brighter"- Obviously, because DS9 started using the new First Contact uniforms.

    Ironically, we have to remember something about Bashir, or rather, the "Bashir" who was wearing the new uniform in this and the next three episodes. Because Bashir is also still wearing his Old DS9 uniform- Maybe I should stop there, and wait until everyone has seen "In Purgatory's Shadow" - Then it will become clear how and why Bashir could be wearing a new uniform and an old uniform at the same time. And it is one of those typical things from this show that causes the jaw to drop.

    Now, it offends me when people unfairly pan episodes simply because they are exploring something about Faith. And Worf says it here: During a discussion about the Bajoran's Religion and The Emissary in particular, Kira is being ribbed by O'Brien and Dax. But Worf tells her to take heart, not because he shares the same religion with Kira, but because he believes in FAITH. And if you consider Worf for one minute, if you consider the character from all of The Next Generation, you will realize he is one of the most religious people in the Trek 'Verse. He rigidly adheres to his Klingon heritage, while at the same time religiously adhering to Starfleet's Principles- His Faith allows him to retain Personal Honour even when his own countrymen consider him a pariah.

    But that is because he is a man of Deep Faith and convictions, he never makes fun of anyone Else's religion, be it an Earth religion, or the religion of Bajor. But he won't put up with Hypocrisy, either.

    And the point of this episode is mainly "The Sisko", he has started to accept that he IS "The Emissary" of the Prophets to Bajor, but until now, he was maybe not willing to do everything they are requiring of him.

    Most people of real Faith struggle with this all the time, they question: "Is Ghod/Buddha/Krishna/YWHW/Moroni/etc, really asking me to do this?" - Most of the time, I can tell you from experience, probably not. If you have to think twice about it, it's NOT HIM. It's my personal belief that if Ghod wants something from us, we'll know it- There will be no question about it. The way to tell is that it will be something 180 degrees in reverse of what the person would expect to be asked to do.

    The thing about Trek is that it treats religion with RESPECT, Trek explores our Terran religions by these episodes which tell us about The Emissary, the Prophets and The Bajoran Religion. They even dissect the concept of hypocrisy, in such a way as to not pan any religions of Earth, but to simply ask people, if they are really doing God's Will, or their own, in Ghod's Name? This is something I ask people who wish to put restrictions on me, whose will is it? Gods, or yours? Usually it's their agenda only and God enters into it not.

    The Religion of Bajor also delves into the concept of Prophecy, which most people think has something to do with seeing the future. That's only part of it, Real prophecy is a bit more complicated.

    As far as the DS9 story goes, The Sisko is being shown some of the things that will happen soon, he just doesn't know what it all means. Yet. Some of the blanks are just not filled in. It was a clever way to foreshadow the last episodes of season 5, in the form of Visions from The Prophets.

    If there are any fans of the great J Michael Stracynski show "Babylon 5", you might see a parallel to when Ambassador Mollari is beaten up by G'Kar and sees a vision of "The Shadows" landing on his home world of Centauri Prime. The only difference between B5 and DS9 is that on B5, this is actually SHOWN "as a Vision" that Mollari has. It might have been more effective to show what The Sisko was seeing, but even without any visual cues we understand what will happen.

    Somehow, I felt that Babylon 5 and DS9 were telling a parallel story, many of the same things happen, The Centauri and The Cardassians: They both make the same mistake and both suffer similar consequences.
  • snoozejonc29 December 2022
    Sisko starts to experience visions of prophecy in relation to Bajor.

    This is a very good episode with good character moments.

    It helps to be a fan of the Bajoran religion episodes of DS9, but I think this is a well made and written episode regardless of your feelings on this aspect of the show. I think the dialogue and character arcs are very good and there are some great foundations laid for future plot lines. I did not enjoy it as much the first time but on a recent rewatch I found more to appreciate.

    It is heavily focussed on Sisko and the writers produce several interesting scenes involving this character and others. I love the 'Close Encounters of the Third Kind' tribute. Avery Brooks is mostly great, but strays slightly over the top in one or two instances..Jake, Kai Winn, Kira, Bashir, and Kassidy Yates have good scenes too. Louise Fletcher stands out as always. Themes regarding faith and science are done well, using the right characters.

    For me it's a 8.5/10, but I round upwards.
  • Seemingly all DS9 episodes that try to glorify Bajoran culture end up making them look more and more annoying. Largely, this is because all these efforts are based on ideas with gaping holes.

    Here for example, Sisko gets electrocuted and starts having prophetic visions (no reason why). With these he discovers an ancient Bajoran metropolis. By which I mean he discovers the ruins of one obelisk. In a cave. Because lost cities built on plains have huge caves growing around them. In just about 20000 years, which is how old this city is - at this point we are expected to marvel at the ancient civilisation of the Bajorans, who by the way, in a previous (also bad) episode, were revealed to have built (in fact dysfunctional) light sail spaceships with which they reached Cardassia. Now, these spaceships were 800 years before, yet they had already faded into the sphere of legend and Bajorans couldn't be sure of their existence. Yet this amnesiac people retains evidence of a prehistoric city.

    These are pretty large plot holes but not what makes this episode very bad. That would be the way in which Sisko turns into a "prophets" faithful, and stops Bajor from joining the Federation by warning them about locusts. Yes, locusts. What is really questionable is how and why the Federation would ever even remotely consider the application of a planet whose rulers can be swayed over by a delirious madman warning them about locusts. There have been bad Star Trek episodes over the years, but this one stands out, not as the worst, but possible as the most un-Star Trek like I have seen. Its logic goes against all things Star Trek. To put it simply, Cpt Picard wouldn't let this stand.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    As an ex-Christian I'm particularly sensitive to "mumbo-jumbo" and proselytizing --- I find the Voyager episode "Sacred Ground" particularly distasteful, an episode that seems to be a clear attempt to capitalize on the Touched By an Angel audience; there were several high profile proselytizing programs in the 90s.

    And there is a little of that here in DS9 with a conversation in the control room between those who have faith in religious credos and those who do not.

    But it seems clear to me that these entities the Bajorans worship are real denizens of the Star Trek universe and there is room for them in the Star Trek pantheon.

    The Original Series gave the answer for the origin of classical gods --- as though we, the audience, thought they were any more than drunken religion crafting by ancient Greeks and Romans --- Kirk and crew interact with these beings.

    We also have telepaths and the Q Continuum.

    The "Wormhole Aliens", or "Prophets", are part of the very backbone of DS9 and, (unlike many people, it seems), I prefer the first three seasons of DS9 when the stories were about Bajor and Cardassia and religious power struggles on Bajor.

    And so, with all that in mind, I found Captain Sisko's telepathic or enlightenment journey to be much more believable, effective, and affective than when they tried to do the same thing with Janeway in Sacred Ground.

    I was with the Captain when he refused surgery and I was equally with his son, Jake, when Jake made the call that Bashir should carry out the Surgery, they are delightful and eloquent opposing viewpoints.

    And I even enjoy the pity I feel for the captain as he regrets not being in long enough to see and understand all the mysteries of the universe --- if he'd died how could those revelations have had any meaning?

    He got enough answers.

    And, besides, Winn is correct when she says that Bajor needs time for Bajor, that five years of independence from outside dictation is not enough to establish a strong, new identity that can keep its influence in an organization like The Federation.

    A wonderful episode, 5/5.
  • Zephyr7073 February 2019
    2/10
    nope
    Warning: Spoilers
    While the episode may be fairly well executed and somewhat enjoyable (even if it felt like Close Encounters of the Third Kind), the territory it ventures into goes against what I feel Star Trek stands for. Unless these supernatural visions have a clear explanation in future episodes this does not bode well for the series. Confronting and discussing the idea of faith is not a bad thing if handled properly as done in previous episodes (especially with Kai Winn, who embodies the power hungry organized institution surrounding faith), but this one misses the mark and also really calls into question Sisko's character. 2/10 just so it's one better than the even worse Risa episode earlier in the season, which should never have been produced in the first place.
  • Honestly, watching Avery Brooks try to convincingly emote in this episode is like watching a dishwasher believe by filling up with water it can fool us into thinking it's crying. I don't know if he genuinely has never experienced the full range of human emotions before or if he simply lacks the talent to convey them at will, but it is painful to watch him oscillate between channeling his best Cheshire Cat impression when the script tells him to be "calm" or going full steam ahead into histrionic fits when it demands more of him.

    While I always try to give actors some grace -- particularly in this genre, as the scenarios they are placed in are uniquely different from those any of us will have experienced in real life and require an array of complex emotions to be displayed -- Avery Books cannot even muster up the will to duplicate the charm of a cardboard box. Although he has polluted many an episode of DS9 in which he heavily features, watching this particular episode is a chore thanks to the unfortunate focus on his character throughout and the opportunity it gives him to continuously demonstrate the depths to which his performance can sink.

    Steer clear of this one if you can help it, or at least wait until you have the patience to tolerate his amateur dinner theatre style antics for over half an hour in one sitting.