Sylvia Likens (as Ellen Page)
Jennie Likens
Lester Likens
Betty Likens
Gertrude Baniszewski
Paula Baniszewski
Stephanie Baniszewski
Johnny Baniszewski
Shirley Baniszewski (as Hannah Leigh Dworkin)
Prosecutor
Reverend Bill Collier
Marie Baniszewski
Hope Orbach
Mrs. Doyle
Mr. Doyle
Coy Hubbard
Andy
Bradley
Patty
Mary
Teddy
Ricky Hobbs
Sally
Eric (as Scott Reeves)
Officer Waters (as William Carter)
Bailiff
Dog
Jury Member (uncredited)
Defense Attorney (uncredited)
Newspaper Reporter (uncredited)
Juror (uncredited)
Carnie (uncredited)