Boxes (2007)

  |  Drama


Boxes (2007) Poster

A woman sifts through boxes filled with memories of her past seeks forgivness from the ghosts who still haunt her.


5.2/10
111

Photos


See all photos

Get More From IMDb

For an enhanced browsing experience, get the IMDb app on your smartphone or tablet.

Get the IMDb app

Reviews & Commentary

Add a Review


User Reviews


21 June 2007 | guy-bellinger
6
| Interesting but slightly disappointing
Jane Birkin has always been one of my favorites. An import from Britain, she has been a popular figure in France for nearly four decades now, first as the sexy/funny companion and muse of major singer-composer Serge Gainsbourg, then as a singer herself and a cinema, TV and theater actress. She also took part in many a radio and TV show, popularizing her comical English accent and grammar mistakes when speaking French. First confined to light comedy or little songs she gradually let the deeper side of her personality show through and recently turned to screen writing and directing for TV. "Boxes" is her first movie for the big screen. She wrote the script, directed and starred. Needless to say I was looking forward to seeing the result of this triple effort but I must admit I was a little let down.

Not that "Boxes" is uninteresting. It is sincere (Jane tells about herself and does not spare herself). It is ambitious and courageous (opting for surrealism, opting out of linear narrative, mixing the living and the dead in the same scenes, filming the naked body of an old woman, tackling unpleasant intimate subjects, …is no easy way out). And although cheaply produced, "Boxes" can boast a dream cast (Geraldine Chaplin, Michel Piccoli, John Hurt, Tcheky Karyo, Natacha Régnier, Lou Doillon, Annie Girardot …).

However, for all these assets, "Boxes" is too imperfect to be memorable.

The first defect is that the story is much too referential to be universal. If you do not know Jane Birkin's life story to the tip of your fingers you are likely to be lost. I personally had no difficulty in identifying Anna as Jane, Max as Gainsbourg,, Camille as Charlotte Gainsbourg, Jean as Jacques Doillon etc., but I was baffled by the characters I had not been introduced to. Who are Madame Martin, Josephine and the small widower? Who do they represent? I was really confused each time they appeared so I can imagine the reaction of someone with no or insufficient information about the main characters…

Another problem is the director's clumsy dealing with the surrealistic form adopted. I am not the kind to balk at non-linear story-telling. I love Buñuel's "El Angel exterminador" or Lynch's "Mulholland Drive" but for a surrealistic work to leave a deep impact it must fascinate. And mesmerized I was not. There is of course a series of strange-looking, cruel-sounding scenes but they are merely flatly juxtaposed. There is no tension rising, no vertigo overwhelming you.

Last but not least, it looks as if Jane Birkin has taken herself too seriously this time. Where has her legendary self-derision gone? Of course life has been difficult for her but a touch of lightness now and then would have been welcome. By exposing her sufferings so unabashedly Birkin borders on self-indulgence.

All in all, "Boxes" is more interesting than successful. At any rate, it is recommended only to those who know Jane Birkin and who love her.

Critic Reviews


More Like This

Pieces of Me

Pieces of Me

Turk's Head

Turk's Head

Insecure

Insecure

Chez Gino

Chez Gino

Carré blanc

Carré blanc

I Used to Be Darker

I Used to Be Darker

Apnée

Apnée

Les Anarchistes

Les Anarchistes

La Rafle

La Rafle

Down by Love

Down by Love

Revenir

Revenir

Orphan

Orphan

Did You Know?


Soundtracks

Getting to Know You
Lyrics by
Oscar Hammerstein II
Music by Richard Rodgers
© 1951 Willamson Music International
Avec l'Autorisation de EMI MUSIC PUBLISHING France
Tous dorits réservés

Storyline

Plot Summary


Genres

Drama

Brett Gelman Shares How "Fleabag" Has Redefined TV

Brett Gelman, who plays Martin on "Fleabag," acknowledges how creator Phoebe Waller-Bridge has moved TV forward and opened up possibilities for women creators.

Watch now

Featured on IMDb

We're updating live with coverage of the Emmys on our homepage. Check back after the show for IMDb LIVE After the Emmys, with exclusive interviews, and more.

Around The Web

 | 

Powered by ZergNet

More To Explore

Search on Amazon.com