Chak De India, one of my favorite films, excellently shows how King Khan transforms a pathetic team into world champions, dealing with several realistic dilemmas throughout the journey. Being tolerant enough of DDDG's story having the same goal (no pun intended) as Chak De, I do not like the fact that several scenes, dialogues, and even game strategies are blatantly copied.
For example, the pre-climax speech by the coach is exactly the same. If I'm not mistaken, the order of wins and losses, including two games with previous year's champions in game #2 and the championship round (Aston/Australia), is the same. The unexpected strategy between two feuding players on the team with the more talented one passing to the less one is a xerox copy with the players running at the same angle and are at the exact same position on the field with the same number of opponents guarding each player. The list is endless.
There is only one big part of the plot analogously different from Chak De, and surprise, surprise, it's lifted off of the other Bollywood sports movie of 2007--Apne. This is the bit about racism--losing out at the finals some 15 odd years ago because of racists threatening the coach. Then, the same coach reluctantly comes back to rewrite history. And of course, they have to throw in the random cheap item song "Billo" that jars with the flow of the film.
The saving grace and highlight of this film is John Abraham. His performance is his best 'til date, and his enthusiasm for football shines through the screen. He has now definitely cemented his place in the industry, and people must be eagerly awaiting his future projects. It is also nice to get another chance to see the on-screen chemistry between John and Bipasha after a long time. Bipasha disappointingly doesn't give an impressive performance. Boman Irani isn't bad, but I feel this is the worst of all his performances. Arshad Warsi is cool as always.
Keeping in mind that too many Bollywood films are plagiarized, I would be a hypocrite if I say I don't like dishonest work. This time I had seen the previous work beforehand, contrary to the norm, so it bugged me more. Still, the movie is well-made and a bit entertaining--mainly the second half. The first half is a drag. I wouldn't dish out the extra bucks to watch this if you have already seen Chak De India. However, if you haven't, and for some reason do not want to watch Chak De, then Goal will be an enjoyable film.
8 out of 9 found this helpful