One Day You'll Understand (2008)

Not Rated   |    |  Drama


One Day You'll Understand (2008) Poster

A man endeavors to collect memories of his grandparents who died in a concentration camp during the Holocaust.


5.8/10
300

Videos


Photos

  • Jeanne Moreau in One Day You'll Understand (2008)
  • Hippolyte Girardot in One Day You'll Understand (2008)
  • Hippolyte Girardot and Jeanne Moreau in One Day You'll Understand (2008)
  • Jeanne Moreau in One Day You'll Understand (2008)
  • Emmanuelle Devos and Hippolyte Girardot in One Day You'll Understand (2008)
  • Hippolyte Girardot and Jeanne Moreau in One Day You'll Understand (2008)

See all photos

Get More From IMDb

For an enhanced browsing experience, get the IMDb app on your smartphone or tablet.

Get the IMDb app

Reviews & Commentary

Add a Review


User Reviews


19 April 2009 | DICK STEEL
5
| A Nutshell Review: One Day You'll Understand
Based on an autobiography by Jerome Clement, One Day You'll Understand explores the painful journey a man takes in digging up the past to understand his lineage more, where it becomes an obsession to fuss over old photographs and articles in trying to shed light on events rooted in the Holocaust, and having the Nazi war criminal trial of Klaus Barbie simultaneously providing a related backdrop.

But watching this film is also painful for me, not because I don't buy into the theme or feel empathic toward the major human atrocities committed during WWII. It's painful because of the way the film was shot, that I believe perhaps only those who are faced with similar issues, would find the lengthy pauses a provision of space to breathe in. Very little is said, and there are enough long takes here for you to take a break and not miss anything much as well. Lengthy conversational pieces between Victor (Hippolyte Girardot) and his wife and mother dwell more on the mundane issues just like everyday life, and my attention started to wander and admire the household furniture instead.

It's set in Paris with the Jewish family facing a crisis of sorts when Victor disengages from his family and falls deeper into the rabbit hole, and the more interesting events start to pick up only when he successfully tracks down the humble abode his grandparents were found to be hiding in from the Nazi persecution, which begins some flashbacks and re-enactment. Of course one would wonder whether revisiting a place where events took place would result in emotion as seen here, particularly if one was not primarily involved then, but only through reports and accounts read. Which of course stretches your imagination should you feel like buying into this argument.

The story of Victor's grandparents triumphs over that of his current everyday life, which for the most parts is quite an unremarkable and unimpressive story, until a tangent develops and Jeanne Moreau's Rivka starts to assert her presence and the story shifts gears into a more compelling subplot with more emotional impact that calls for your involvement, since it had something to do with the inevitable journey of life at the end of the road, and the leaving of a legacy behind.

As one of the character advised, what's done is done and you cannot change anything, I feel that this film was an exercise in itself in wanting to translate a personal memoir into a movie, but failed to translate the emotions that came along with it in more powerful terms. Definitely not going into my list of Amos Gitai films to recommend.

Critic Reviews


More Like This

Disengagement

Disengagement

Tsili

Tsili

Carmel

Carmel

Free Zone

Free Zone

A Tramway in Jerusalem

A Tramway in Jerusalem

Promised Land

Promised Land

The Square

The Square

Rabin, the Last Day

Rabin, the Last Day

Kedma

Kedma

Alila

Alila

Roses à crédit

Roses à crédit

Kadosh

Kadosh

Did You Know?

'Good Boy' Jacob Tremblay Picks 'Star Wars' Dream Role

Jacob Tremblay, star of the new comedy Good Boys, compares his family to an infamous reality TV show and reveals an unusual pick for the Star Wars character he'd like to play.

Watch now

Featured on IMDb

See what IMDb editors are watching this month, and visit our guides to what's on TV and streaming, family entertainment, and more.

Around The Web

 | 

Powered by ZergNet

More To Explore

Search on Amazon.com