Officer Schmidt / Carl (6 episodes, 2021-2022)
Donny / Holy Driver / Donny G (6 episodes, 2021-2022)
Angela / Angela & Girl Singing (4 episodes, 2021-2022)
Father Mike (4 episodes, 2021-2022)
Luigi Consolo aka The Cleaner / Luigi / Luigi Consolo (4 episodes, 2022)
Tony / Boss Herb Amen / Mob Boss Herb Amen (4 episodes, 2022)
Tina (3 episodes, 2021-2022)
Ms. T / Theresa Tarantini (3 episodes, 2022)
Dominick Palmieri aka 'Paulie' / Dominick Paulie Palmieri / Paulie (3 episodes, 2022)
Ronny Chains (3 episodes, 2022)
Alphonse Marinelli (3 episodes, 2022)
Michelle Stone (3 episodes, 2022)
Johnny Carrataio aka 'Carrot' / Johnny Carrataio aka Johnny Carrot / Johnny Carrot (3 episodes, 2022)
Father Harry (3 episodes, 2022)
Father Tranquille (2 episodes, 2021-2022)
Tyler / Tyler Delesandro (2 episodes, 2021-2022)
Felicity Needler (2 episodes)
Mr. Knees (1 episode, 2022)
Mumbles Polito (1 episode, 2022)
Richie aka 'Crop Dropper' (1 episode, 2022)
Chris Haverton (1 episode, 2022)
Cannonball the Biker (1 episode, 2022)
Luigi Consolo Sr. (1 episode)
Dustin Reynolds aka The Church Cleaner (1 episode)
Father Tom (1 episode)
Father Samuel (1 episode)