Miral (2010)

R   |    |  Drama, History


Miral (2010) Poster

A drama centered on an orphaned Palestinian girl growing up in the wake of Arab-Israeli war who finds herself drawn into the conflict.


6.2/10
3,081

Videos


Photos

  • Julian Schnabel and Freida Pinto in Miral (2010)
  • Omar Metwally and Freida Pinto in Miral (2010)
  • Julian Schnabel in Miral (2010)
  • Hiam Abbass and Freida Pinto in Miral (2010)
  • Sean Penn at an event for Miral (2010)
  • Julian Schnabel and Freida Pinto in Miral (2010)

See all photos

Get More From IMDb

For an enhanced browsing experience, get the IMDb app on your smartphone or tablet.

Get the IMDb app

Cast & Crew

Top Billed Cast



Director:

Julian Schnabel

Writers:

Rula Jebreal (screenplay), Rula Jebreal (novel)

Reviews & Commentary

Add a Review


User Reviews


5 July 2012 | ignominia-1
6
| Nice effort but disappointing
I did not know what the movie was about so when it started my first reaction was: "Oh no! not another movie on Jewish suffering!" I was pleasantly surprised to discover that this time the movie was about the Palestinian plight.

Kudos to that I say, nevertheless I found the story confusing. I am a fan of Julian Schnabel's work as director, but I expected more after The Bell-jar and the Butterfly which in my book was a masterpiece.

Miral (not an apt title for the subject matter) takes its time before getting to the main story and protagonist, telling first the tale of 3 other women: Her mother Nadia; Fatima the terrorist; and Hind the school master and surrogate mother to all orphans. Miral's arrival on the scene is almost an afterthought, hinted at by Nadia's vomit attack upon arriving in jail -if she is sickened by fear or by baby is not clear until much later on.

I wished the director let the people speak in Arabic and add subtitles -which were used only in the beginning- it would have made for a less Anglo-centric flavored film and the written text would have allowed the audience to catch important dialog that was otherwise drowned by the soundtrack. What Fatima says to the man who later becomes Nadia's husband, for example, would have explained later events. Same for what was exchanged between Miral and the Intifada member at the funeral, important words muffled in music.

Because of this and the confusing ways of past and present scenes mixing without a clear way to distinguish between them, the storyline of the movie was unclear, and so was its perception similar to walking in the dark, intuiting the outline of things but not getting the full picture.

All actors were good but Hiam Abass who played Hind stood out. Freida Pinto does not look authentic, I read she is of Indian heritage, but her beauty made the distressing story more bearable, if distracting.

Aside from this, it was refreshing to see a movie on this subject matter, produced and directed by major names in the movie industry. To see the Israeli seen as "bad guys" was almost shocking, what with the Jewish propaganda we get out of Hollywood all the time. The world needs to see Palestinian heroes, if nothing else to balance the way Arabs in general are portrayed in the movies. A movie worth seeing if NOT the ultimate picture on the subject.

Metacritic Reviews


Critic Reviews



More Like This

Berlin

Berlin

Before Night Falls

Before Night Falls

Basquiat

Basquiat

The Diving Bell and the Butterfly

The Diving Bell and the Butterfly

At Eternity's Gate

At Eternity's Gate

A Woman

A Woman

My Brother Is an Only Child

My Brother Is an Only Child

9 Songs

9 Songs

My Son, My Son, What Have Ye Done

My Son, My Son, What Have Ye Done

Julian Schnabel: A Private Portrait

Julian Schnabel: A Private Portrait

Valmont

Valmont

To the Wonder

To the Wonder

Storyline

Plot Summary


Synopsis (WARNING: Spoilers)


Genres

Drama | History

Head Back to School With Classic Movies and TV Shows

"The IMDb Show" hits the streets to find out which movies and TV shows about or set in schools are at the top of the class.

Watch now

Featured on IMDb

Join us Sunday, Sept. 22, at 8 p.m. ET/5 p.m. PT for IMDb LIVE After the Emmys, with exclusive interviews, and more. Plus, see what IMDb editors are watching this month.

Around The Web

 | 

Powered by ZergNet

More To Explore

Search on Amazon.com