Simon & the Oaks (2011)

Not Rated   |    |  Drama


Simon & the Oaks (2011) Poster

Two boys come of age in Sweden during World War II.


6.5/10
2,661

Videos


Photos

  • Simon & the Oaks (2011)
  • Simon & the Oaks (2011)
  • Simon & the Oaks (2011)
  • Simon & the Oaks (2011)
  • Simon & the Oaks (2011)
  • Simon & the Oaks (2011)

See all photos

Get More From IMDb

For an enhanced browsing experience, get the IMDb app on your smartphone or tablet.

Get the IMDb app

Reviews & Commentary

Add a Review


User Reviews


10 November 2012 | OJT
4
| Not the least interesting family saga
Maybe I had too much expectations for this, but it was a pain to watch this to the end. I must first of all say that I haven't read the book of which this is based. I understand that this book is re-known, and I also understood that this was nominated to nothing less than 13 guldbaggar in Swedish film.

Well, that's not at all understandable to me. I tend to like films like this, but I'm afraid to say that this film is impossible to get hold of. It's pretentious, both in manuscript and in acting.But far worse is it that it becomes boring when the chemistry between the actors are missing.

What is likable, is Bill Skarsgård. He's the one coming from this alive, due to his charm, though the film can't seem to make the best out of it. Simon is not likable, if still charming. Maybe also with small Isak. A good actor, but not taken care of. I see this as helpless instruction of what must be fine actors to work with.

I tend to see it as Lisa Ohlin is not cut to make films like this. Both on screen writing and in directing this is very flawed. Overacted, constantly staring people is bad enough.

What's even worse is the sense of us not believing one bit of the story. It's too far fetched. It might have worked in the book, but in the film, when something gets remotely interesting, it's a cut into pieces. The clipping work is awful. It tears up what could have been a great scene. Like when Simon is confronting his parents. The next scene is him walking away from the little house with luggage on his bike.

Even more stupid is the thoughtful sequences, which are far-fetched, boring and badly done technically. The whole thing about the oak is also both pretentious and artsy fartsy. It makes you yawn and hate the concept.

What is good, is the environment and filming. Beautifully shot, it is, and so in vain, when the rest is not making up to it. I've read some quite good reviews for this one, but the critics must have been out to lunch. Such a waste. It's not a turkey, but rather a pheasant. I'd rather have chicken, any day.

Metacritic Reviews


Critic Reviews



Details

Release Date:

9 December 2011

Language

Swedish, German, Hebrew, English


Country of Origin

Sweden, Denmark, Germany, Norway

Filming Locations

Berlin, Germany

Box Office

Opening Weekend USA:

$9,964 14 October 2012

Gross USA:

$150,664

Cumulative Worldwide Gross:

$2,594,023

Which Oscar Nominee Did Alan Ruck Get Mistaken For?

Alan Ruck of Ferris Bueller's Day Off and "Succession" plays "Never Have I Ever," where he shares his worst audition and how he was surprised to be mistaken for an Oscar nominee.

Watch now

Featured on IMDb

Join us Sunday, Sept. 22, at 8 p.m. ET/5 p.m. PT for IMDb LIVE After the Emmys, with exclusive interviews, and more. Plus, see what IMDb editors are watching this month.

Around The Web

 | 

Powered by ZergNet

More To Explore

Search on Amazon.com