Steve / Boss / Bride / Businessman / Chad Anderson / Coronavirus / Guy Who Didn't Need to See That / Jamie / Kasey / Leslie / Lynn / Man / Marty / Scared Guy / Ted / The Burglar / Wrestler / Wrestler #1 (25 episodes, 2020-2021)
Dio Rama / Susan / Harper / Jerry / Mom / Old Biddy / Tammy / The Sitter (22 episodes, 2020-2021)
Jan / Jim / Jo / Charles / Dad / Detective / Detective Two / Mickey / Terry (17 episodes, 2020-2021)
Mr. Serial Killer / Narrator / Ebeneezer Scrooge / John Smith / Quentin / Robert / Secretary / Terry (15 episodes, 2020-2021)
Pano Rama / Cassie / Construction Worker / Karen / Sammy / Woman (14 episodes, 2020-2021)
Jon / Henry / Jeff / Jo / Man 1 / Paul / Tim / Tom / Villian / Voice of Tim (12 episodes, 2020-2021)
Betty / Detective One / Julie / Missionary / Mom / Stacey / Woman (10 episodes, 2020-2021)
Bill / Bob / Dick / Janitor / Lou / Mayor / Mr. Serial Killer's Younger Self (10 episodes, 2020-2021)
Creepy Neighbor / Bill / Contact / Dave / Detective Steve / Guard / Man 2 / Voice of Dave (10 episodes, 2021)
Karen / Sue / June / Kelly / Riley (7 episodes, 2021)
Dr. McClaine / Mrs. Serial Killer / Voice of Swirlies (5 episodes, 2020-2021)
Wrestler / Bronson (5 episodes, 2020-2021)
(4 episodes, 2020-2021)
Soap Giver (4 episodes, 2020-2021)
Sophie / Mrs. Serial Killer (3 episodes, 2020-2021)
Marge (3 episodes, 2020-2021)
(3 episodes, 2020)
Bobby / Sheriff (2 episodes, 2020-2021)
Woman (2 episodes, 2020)
Jack (2 episodes, 2020)
Jill (2 episodes, 2020)
Daughter (2 episodes, 2020)
Girl (2 episodes, 2020)
Husband / Pizza Delivery Guy (2 episodes, 2021)
Lysander St. John (2 episodes, 2021)
Wrestler (1 episode, 2020)
God (1 episode, 2020)
Dora (1 episode, 2021)
Wife (1 episode, 2021)