Laura Mayfield-Bennett
Jessica
Theodore (as Willie James Stratford Jr.)
Katie Lapp
Benjamin Lapp
Rebecca Lapp (as Sandra W. Van Natta)
Samuel Lapp
Jacob Beiler (as Jackson Wyatt Lanier)
Bishop John Beiler
Hickory John Beiler
Daniel Fisher
Ephram Yoder
Ella Mae Zook
Benjamin's Daughter
Amanda
Mary Stoltzfus (as Sarah Chambers)
Dylan Bennett
Store Clerk
Preacher Yoder
Amish Elder
Amish Man
Surgeon (as Robert Treveiler)
Trauma Nurse
Nurse Rosie
Young Laura
Young Amish Bachelor (uncredited)
Amish Teenager (uncredited)
Young Samuel (uncredited)
Bus Patron (uncredited)
Self / Nurse (uncredited)
Amish Guy (uncredited)
Amish Man (uncredited)
Amish Woman in Shop (uncredited)
Amish woman (uncredited)
Wedding Guest (uncredited)
Amish Woman in Cab (uncredited)
Amish Man at General Store (uncredited)
Amish Elder (uncredited)
Amish Woman (uncredited)
Noah Beiler (uncredited)
Young Boy (uncredited)
Hotel Guest (uncredited)
Young Amish Woman (uncredited)
Amish Girl (uncredited)
Young Amish Man (uncredited)
Nurse (uncredited)
Young Rebecca (uncredited)