Add a Review

  • Warning: Spoilers
    By way of introduction, it is important to know that Shades of Love is a sequel to Rosamunde Pilcher's "September". It has an entirely different cast from the miniseries based on the book which debuted 14 years earlier. It is not based on a Rosamunde Pilcher novel, but takes her characters from September and projects what may have become of them about 10 years in the future. For those who have read Pilcher's beloved "The Shell Seekers" and "September", it is interesting to note the whiplash inducing turns in the Noel Keeling character. In Shades of Love he is back to Nasty Noel of the first novel. Poor Alexa of September really got the short end of the stick! If you liked her happy ending of September pretend this one never happened. Although fear not! She does come about in the last episode.

    Each of the four parts of this mini-series has some closure while setting up the next episode with some unresolved plot points. We have illicit affairs resulting in pregnancies, adultery, tragic love affairs, boy next door happy love affairs, revenge, forgiveness, betrayal, blackmail, bankruptcy, corporate shenanigans, and 2 cases of grown up children discovering their Mommys and/or Daddys are not who they think they are. All is resolved and ends happily for most after much trial and tribulation. Though Beware: there are several deaths mixed into the pot.

    There are some well known actors in this among the older set, and all do their jobs pretty well, although Harriet Walter is terribly wasted in a nothing part. Rebecca Night, who plays one of the most important roles as Laura, was a disappointment. She had a strangely affected way of speaking which was very distracting and a very placid way about her which was not at all engaging. Rosamunde Pilcher excels at writing about nice and good women that you really root for. The actress just made this character dull. Adrian Lucas was a great villain, and the German actress, Esther Shweins, who played the mysterious Olivia Thorpe in season 2 was a stand out: Class, beauty, charisma, and dignity. She even managed to rise above the gigantic and nonsensical plot hole in the last episode.

    All in all, I enjoyed it for what it was, but did not rise to the quality of "Coming Home," "The Shell Seekers," or any of Rosamunde's other novels on the page. The scenery was beautiful.
  • This is definitely for Rosamunde Pilcher fans and why I never read her books. Dialog is stilted and obvious. Self-indulgent fluff with ridiculous and unbelievable plot motivations. Any surprises would be if the banal DIDN'T happen. British TV requires some patience to "get around to it" - but it usually pays off. Even the beautiful scenery is not worth sitting through this dreck. A fine example of "popular writer throws her weight around to get a sappy movie."
  • Warning: Spoilers
    And, like a train wreck, I just keep watching it. It's true that the Scottish landscapes are lovely, but in nearly every other respect, this is just dreadful. The plot is simultaneously predictable and ludicrous. One man discovers he has a love child he didn't know about? Wow, that was so shocking, let's do it again! Charles Dance is a fine actor, and there are a few others in here that know their business, but so many others are--I almost said "dreadful" again, but there must be some other adjectives to describe this dreck. With the many, many choices of things to watch from so many different venues, I beg you: watch something else. Anything else!