Noah Daly
Lauren Daly
Tommy Daly
Marie Daly
Alison Paige
Detective Cloud
Todd Carlson
Marcus Jones
Jim Daly
Young Noah Daly (as Joe Cipriano)
Sara
Virgil Weaver
Bartender Rick
Bob
Perry (as Glen Hobgood)
Young Lauren Daly
Bill
Peggy
Dale
Brenda
Theatre presenter
Pip
Magwitch
Julie
Gill
AA Counselor
Waitress Suzy
Deb
Officer Kern
Dan
Logan Daly
Nurse Connie
Toddler Noah
Bar Waitress Jules
Mrs. Hubble
Band's Lead Singer
Band's String Player
Audience member
Elkhart Police Officer #2
Estella
Theatre Audience Member
Orphan Girl Playing Go-Fish
AA Member #3
Theater Patron
Hardware Stock boy
Orphan Girl #2
Elkhart Police Officer #1
Miss Skiffins
AA Member #1
Joe Gargery
Older Pip
Mr. Wopsle
Wemmick
Mr. Hubble
Elkhart Police Officer #3
Miss Havisham
Mr. Jaggers
AA Member #2
Herbert Pocket
Mrs. Joe Gargery
Lauren's Security Guard
Baby Noah
Orphan Girl #1
Bar Patron
Mr. Pumblechook
Molly
Mrs. Brandley
Police Dispatcher (voice)
Mrs. Whimple
Biddy Wopsle
Clara
Book Store Owner
Theater audience (uncredited)
Girl on Beach (uncredited)