User Reviews (18)

Add a Review

  • I watched Halimin Put last night and I can only congratulate Arsen Ostojić on the magnificent job he did by directing this feature film; as one says in Croatian, svaka čast majstore! I always enjoy watching films from the Balkans because of the actors' fascinating acting. Indeed, they act in such a natural way that we have the feeling to be also part of the film and experience the actors' feelings.

    Beyond the tensions and cultural differences that may exist between Christians and Muslims, I really appreciated that Mr. Ostojić dealt with the psychological trauma suffered by people involved (both actively and passively) in a war. We mostly tend to forget that even if a war is over, it actually never ends for those who experienced it as this a hellish moment of life they cannot easily get over. I think the biggest strength of the film lies in the perfect depiction - through the behaviours of the characters - of the psychological ravages each person experiencing war has to cope with once the nightmare ends ; at least this is what made a lasting impression on me.

    I am no film critic, but I was eager to submit my review on this title as it has been quite a while now since I last watched a film of such high quality. There is of course still very much to say about the other very interesting aspects of the film, but professional film critics will do it better than I ever will.

    Keep up the good work, Mr. Ostojić! :-)
  • NicColeB19 April 2013
    Warning: Spoilers
    I truly enjoy watching cultured films, it gives me an insight of someone's life and what they go through. It's heartbreaking for a woman to know they cannot bear children, and then taking on the option of adopting, is a new found challenge. Difficulties arise after husband and son taken were executed by the Serbian military forces.

    The executed weren't able to be discovered or recognized without DNA analytics, and unfortunately Halima had more issues to deal with. One thing, was her husband was discovered via DNA analysis, but her son, she was on a search to find his biological mother. That journey wasn't easy.

    Overall, this was a good film, with brilliant director and producer. The actors were on point with their skills. I felt like I was apart of the film.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    This film is all about humanity and "artificial" divisions between people; divisions that are based on nationality and religion. It partly covers the theme of war, but not in the sense of battles or war strategies, but in the sense of the consequences of war. Artificial or human- made divisions between Muslims and Serbs in pre-war and post-war Bosnia resulted in many tragedies and led to bloodshed. In the 1980s and later on, residents from many parts of Bosnia were supposed to marry their "own" people, Muslims or Serbs, and all people who didn't want to obey this rule, were considered outlaws. Their families rejected them and thought they embarrassed them for life. *Spoilers* "Halima's Path" begins when a young unmarried Muslim woman, Safija, comes to her aunt Halima and tells her that she is pregnant. Not only that, she is pregnant with a young Serb called Slavomir. Of course, her aunt knows it will cause a lot of trouble but still, she shows compassion. Halima and her husband cannot have children and Halima often imagines what it would be like to become a mother. Safija's dad is particularly outraged when he finds out about the pregnancy, the star-crossed lovers and when he meets Slavomir in person. He even beats his pregnant daughter in front of Slavomir and her mother! Being left with no choice, Safija gives birth to a boy named Aron, leaves him with Halima (knowing that Halima and her husband would be loving parents to her son), tells Slavomir that the baby died and leaves with Slavomir to start a new life in a Serbian village. Life is good for some time, but the war changes everything. People start fighting and the old suppressed aggression and hatred between different nations take a deadly toll. Aron's adopted father and his real father fight on opposite sides. And on top of that, Slavomir was forced to kill some prisoners, including his own son... Aron lost his life because of the war and a wicked twist of fate and Halima lost her family: both her son and husband were killed by the enemy. Years later she has to identify their bones... The whole story is heartbreaking and the actors did a marvellous job while portraying the feelings of hatred, fear, anger,parental love and deep and harrowing grief. The most touching and heartbreaking moment in the film is a scene when Halima holds the bones of her son. And screams...because that is the only thing she can do... :( That is probably the saddest and heart- wrenching scene depicted on film. The most serious and one of the best Croatian / Bosnian films ever!
  • ofratko21 January 2013
    Warning: Spoilers
    Was really looking forward to see this movie and it hasn't disappointing me. The movie is tragic story of Halima.Bosnian Muslim who lost her husband and son. It's also story of her niece who found the love of her life in a Serbian man. Something what was not acceptable for her father. Her pregnancy was a god send to Halima as she herself couldn't bear children.But in order to find her son's remains( he was murdered in the war) she must find her niece-his biological mother who is now married to her Serbian husband then boyfriend and hasn't had any contact with her family for 20 years.

    This story is utterly tragic. The acting is brilliant.Alma Prica is incredible as Halima You can feel Halima's love and sorrow for her son. And the need to find his remains to bury him. Also Olga Pakalovic & Mijo Jurisic are brilliant. There is a great chemistry between then and the love story is therefore believable.

    The movie also shows that the concept of multi-ethnic Bosnia and mixed marriages weren't accepted everywhere and not everybody liked the idea. And that not all was peachy before the war. There was mistrust and prejudice. Not even love could overcome it....
  • Halima's Path tackles the subject of the Balkan War, venturing much further than a simple retelling of events. Set in Bosnia, the story unfolds through the masterful use of flashback. Beginning in pre-conflict, multi-ethnic Yugoslavia the film culminates in present-day Bosnia with the tragic repercussions of the war. Halima's seemingly straightforward quest to have the remains of her husband and son identified from those found in a mass grave exposes a richly woven tapestry of events--a tapestry which reveals the very human side of war.

    The film is brilliantly directed by Arsen A. Ostojic, with excellent performances delivered by a stellar cast. Particularly powerful are Alma Prica in the role of Halima and Olga Pakalovic as Safija. The evocative score adds to the authenticity of the film.

    Halima's Path offers a novel look into the personal tragedy of war. This supremely moving film delivers a true emotional punch--be prepared to shed more than a few tears. A true masterpiece.
  • This movie awakens emotion and no matter how hard you try as a strong male not to cry, a few times in this movie that's just not easy. I suggest that women bring to the cinema enough Kleenex.

    Excellently acted, well photographed. Excellent film.

    The film's director, whose two previous films (A Wonderful Night in Split and No one's son) were great to me, did an excellent job, and I think that movie audiences will love this movie.

    Minor objections that some might object to the film's authenticity. It's nonsense like: why they in the woods gives the blinker when hillbillies are not using blinker in the city.

    Regardless of these little things that will be noticed just during second or third viewing of the film this movie is probably the best Croatian film in recent years.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    Anyone who remembers Denis Villeneuve's "Incendies" about the horrors of the war in Lebanon and the quest of two children to find the secrets behind their mother's past during that conflict will undoubtedly resonate with viewers watching Halima's Path.

    The screenplay written by Fedja Isovic, the man behind the brilliant comedy series "Lud, zbunjen, normalan" (Crazy, confused, normal), is a powerful family story set during an evolving time period in Bosnia's recent history. The movie starts off in 1977 in a village in western Bosnia set behind a backdrop of conservative rural ideas and spans 23 years to lead us to year 2000, 5 years after the end of the war that ravaged Bosnia-Herzegovina. Through flashbacks and an invigorating pace we follow Halima's attempt to identify the missing body of her 15 year old son taken by Serb forces in 1993.

    This harrowing tale of love, loss, discovery, family and ultimately Bosnia and the horrors of war is a resounding success and merited an Oscar nomination for best foreign language film. Arsen Ostojic's directing is impeccable and the beautiful camera work aptly compliments the realistic story and the countryside.

    While "Incendies" powerful story understandably made it an Oscar contender, Halima's Path's narrative is stronger and its acting work more genuine and sincere than that of Villeneuve's masterpiece. The lead and supporting characters are almost flawless in their delivery. The only weak point is the child actors, but it doesn't take anything away from the film.

    Halima's Path is a human story, with an emotional level that very few movies are able to reach. It is rich with cues and insights into Bosnian culture and its mannerisms, attitudes and dialect traits. And therein lies the hidden gem, made possible by the brilliant understanding of Bosnian culture and its subtleties by Fedja Isovic, subtleties that will certainly go unnoticed by the Western viewer. The film itself is extremely engaging and never makes you feel like you're watching a movie, instead placing you as a silent observer of a family's trials and tribulations.

    10/10, a total success. A film which will resonate with viewers and stay in your memory long after the viewing experience is concluded.
  • harisib24 January 2013
    I have just saw the movie,it's really one of best that come from the Balkans,the story is centered in west Bosnia,the most actors and actress are Bosnians,but it's directed and produced by Croatians(west neighbors)

    The story is about 2-3 families in a small village,telling how they lived before the war,showing us the differences in two religious families(Serbs and Bosnian Muslims)but also showing us that they have the same mentality.

    Slavomir(Serb) and Safija(Bosnian Muslim) fell in love and she gets pregnant and that can't accept their families. That's why Safija runs to aunt Halima and the new born child gives to her telling the family that the child was dead born. 2 years later Slavomir comes from Germany and meets Safija,they both flee to a far places and begun a new life. But war comes ,Slavomir is recruited to the Serbian army.....many things happens during the war that will leave aftermath to both families.

    The rest(and the most) of the movie continues after 5 years at the end of war,Halima is searching for the bones of 'son' Mirza,and Slavomir is melancholy drinking every day at the tavern,Safija is living with Slavomir and they 3 children....

    What are they secrets and what will be with them at the end ?

    I don't want tell that,watch the movie, it's really a masterpiece,one of the best movies i ever saw.Thanks to our west neighbors for this story and i want to wish you good luck ,i hope this movie will get some awards on international movie competitions. 10/10
  • I am not completely satisfied with this movie for the following 3 reasons: do not like nor understand old movies that much, complicated story, lacks details. Meaning, I could only understand what it is about, but do not understand the ending, and especially who is who, who did what. This is one of those movies that require watching more than once in order to understand them. But good is landscape of villages, especially presence of appropriate fences, buildings, vehicles, crafts, animals, work. Then of multinational and multireligious conflicts, which sounds interesting. Then I liked this is about my place. Then few good small negative behaviors in form of fights, arguments, conflicts, which is all exactly same as in real life. I think older people who live here would understand this better, I may be too young. Also bad that it is too negative, and no real action, except few amateur ones, and in form of historic footage. I expected character in the end to do something bigger.
  • If You don't want to cry skip this movie - it is very good and really deeply touches basic human conflicts that are so common on Balcans, but also universal. It was so difficult to me to explain to a foreigner (I am Serbian grew up in Slovenia during Yugoslavia) what was really going on during the war in Bosnia, Croatia... In short words it is inexplicable. The movie is a really good explanation what is going on during the centuries: how deeply people actually are connected to each other, but in many periods they try to behave as they are not et all. Actors are great and connection to reality is all the time alive. But specially I like dedication of this movie to a woman, who is a special victim in Balcans wars. I felt Halima's story is a very strong symbol for all mothers who pass all kinds of experiences to get a child and rise it - just to lose it for stupid wars, again and again and again...
  • This movie and other similar movies should be played in schools, so that youth could see the stupidity of war, and that they would never reach for wheapon.
  • All in all, IMO, it's just a really bad Croatian movie set in Bosnia. Lousy artificial dialogues, bad acting, confusing message of the film - I gave it a 2.

    Funny trivia, almost all the other reviews are most probably written by director itself ( usually many profiles with only one review uncover that pathetic tactics).

    Just to underline one more time - a lousy movie
  • By Alex Deleon, Los Angeles This film was viewed at the L.A. SouthEast European film festival (SEEFEST) in May 2013. "Halima's Path" is a minor key masterpiece that deals with post war trauma after the Bosnian civil war in two intertwined peasant families -- one Muslim, the other Christian. What makes this film so special apart from the gripping subject matter, is the overall esthetic conception, the brilliant cinematography, the authenticity of the settings (Satyajit Ray would have loved it) -- the absolute world class acting, and the direction, which, as one viewer remarked in a post screening Q and A, "puts Hollywood to shame". Balkan films from Romania, Serbia, Turkey, and even tiny Albania, have circulated in various festivals but Croatia hasn't had very much to offer until the emergence of Zagreb based director Arsen Anton Ostovic, who learned the trade at the NYU film school and has made two other remarkable features before this. Halima's tortuous Path -- on the way to identify the remains of her husband and son exhumed from mass graves -- is Nothing but heart rending as portrayed by actress Alma Prica in a towering performance that is almost too authentic to bear. This is a heavy drama with an intricate plot, many characters in complex kinship relations, and multiple interwoven flashbacks that are sometimes hard to sort out, but the direction is so skillful that the viewer is simply swept up and drawn along in one perfectly constructed scene after another to the shocking conclusion with a deftly touching cemetery coda. Every character is perfectly drawn and portrayed by an amazing ensemble cast, some Croatian, some Serbian, some Bosnian Muslim, and at least one Slovenian. The overall effect is transfixing even if slightly confusing at times, at least to outside viewers not so familiar with similar sounding names and reading the film through English subtitles.. "Halima's Path" is a stunner and jaw dropper, but it may take a second viewing to sort out all the details. Basically, the story is this: -- The film opens with a prequel to the main story in 1977. A title tells us this is western Bosnia where the population is mixed Moslem and Christian (Vlah). On a stormy night a pretty young Moslem woman, Safiya, comes running through the fields to the house of her aunt, Halima, to tell her she is two months late --pregnant - of course unmarried, and afraid her father will kill her if he finds out that the father-to-be is aChristian-- Moreover, she loves the guy! We'll think of something, says Halima. Next we see Safiya jumping off a ladder on the family farm trying to induce an abortion. Ineffective. Her father starts beating her to within an inch of her life with a whip when Slavomir, her handsome Serbian boyfriend shows up. He poleaxes the enraged father, Avdo, with a stick but has to flee when a son pulls a shotgun on him. Jafiya, badly battered, is kicked out and comes back to Halima, her aunt, Avdo's sister, for refuge. The stage is now set for the big secret that will be the fulcrum of the tale. We will later find out that after Safiya secretly gave birth after the failed abortion. Halima who was barren, secretly adopted her niece's child, Mirza, and raised him as her own. Slavomir who has been away in Germany for two years to make money returns in a fancy car to retrieve Safiya. When he asks about their baby Safiya lies and tells him it was stillborn, then runs off with him to raise a new family as a Christian wife in an all Serbian town.

    Flash forward 23 years -- it is now the year 2000, five years after the end of the Bosnian war. In a series of momentary flashbacks we learn that both Halima's husband and son were carried off by Serbian soldiers and shot in an ethnic cleansing massacre. We can also see that one of the soldiers was young Slavo -- Under UN supervision mass graves have been exhumed, the bones carefully laid out in a warehouse mortuary and DNA or blood samples from surviving relatives are needed to identify the bones so they can be reburied properly according to Moslem custom. Salko, Halima's husband, Salko, has been identified but, since she was not the biological mother of Mirza her blood sample won't help. She has to find Safiya who ran off 22 years earlier and hasn't been heard from since....Avdo's wife, Nevzeta, who never agreed to Safiya's expulsion from the family, has heard some things on the grapevine ... Cut to Safiya, now "Sophia", and her family of three daughters somewhere on the Serbian side. Slavomir, who was once so clean cut, has been traumatized by his war experiences in the Serbian military, has become an alcoholic, has grown long hair and a beard, is constantly depressed and looks like Jesus ... Halima now a forlorn pathetic figure who knits sweaters for the dead to keep from going mad, is determined to find Safiya --- . . She will be assisted reluctantly by brother-in-law Mustafa (Brother of her deceased husband) who once despised her for her barrenness but has softened with age. What will happen when she does find Safiya/Sophia...? When director Ostojic remarked that Alma Prica is regarded as the best actress in Croatia and has been so for a long time, I asked him what American actress he would compare her to and the answer was immediate, Meryl Streep! - In any case this is a fantastic ensemble cast all around without a single glitch as far as the acting is concerned. "Halima's Path" is a Croatian Bosnian Slovenian co-production and a pristine example of cross border cooperation in a region that was so recently torn to pieces by a horrendous series of wars, now largely forgotten in the West.
  • Because of the outstanding performance of the film's creators, I lived a period of time in Bosnia, a simple and beautiful life despite the tragedies until the end of the badge.
  • Bosnia is hardly known for its film industry, overshadowed by the last two decades of war. As a lover of foreign films, I must admit that I don't suppose I've even heard the language spoken before in a film, or was aware of movies being made in Bosnia and Yugoslavia. This one really won me over with its cinema verite style, shot on actual 16mm film. It's really refreshing when you see how someone can tell such a compelling story that's so simplistic - the story of a mother in search of her family. There's an air of authenticity in everything here - from the real locations, to the actors who lived through this very divisive conflict in their history. It's truly amazing - almost feels like a realist novel unfolding on screen, as you quickly forget that you're watching a movie.
  • qui_j30 May 2020
    This is a well made film given what must have been a limited budget and resources. It shows the impact of a war that destroyed countless lives in order to satisfy differing religious beliefs, and ethnicity.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    In my experience, movies about the wars of Yugoslavia have been difficult to make for a myriad of reasons. There is no shortage of subject matter, No shortage of reference material, and no shortage of personal memories. Something that happened 30 years ago is still not that long into the past, and you could ascertain this from speaking to anyone who lives in the region.

    What makes it difficult to produce these movies, is that there is actually *too* much to try and make a movie about. If one were to try and depict every horror that decade saw, it would be never-ending. It is also because of this, that writers and directors tend to simply get lost in what their vision is. They want to amplify the feelings of something so painful, so other-worldly, and they lose direction trying to figure out how to convey it in artistic language. It becomes a slog of misery.

    This movie knows what it wants to be. It is excellent. It is also very sad.

    It is a painful work of art, which, at its core, focuses on how the war in Bosnia was one that did not discern with its victims. It is how people who, living all their lives harmoniously with one another, one day decided they had to kill their neighbors. Their best friends. Their own family. It was an event that consumed anyone and everyone, and spat out only husks of people who--though perhaps lucky enough to not die with their fathers or mothers or sons--were unlucky enough to never forget the day they lost them.

    It is difficult to convey to an adequate degree how lost and hysteric the former Yugoslavian people still are about what happened. It is even more difficult to blame them for their feelings--their souls were ripped from their bodies, their sense of home forever changed--there is no longer the same comfort in continuing to live. This is why movies like this keep being made. Because the war only ended on paper. It continues on in their hearts. And it continues to devastate and divide people every day. And millions suffocate on their own memories, desperate to have us understand, and be understood.

    This film is a cautionary tale. It is to beg you:

    Please, learn something.

    Be something more than what we have become.

    More than the sum of a mistake which cannot be erased.

    Your future depends on it.
  • This movie shows how really was the war in Bosnia and Herceovina. How brutal and pointless it was. It shows how neighbor killed his first neighbor and vice versa without asking a lot. Totally without any sense but it just happened and yes it happened just like that. Kids were killed, old people too. Countless lifes lost for what, countless families ripped apart for what. For someone who was sitting in some kind of office 500Km far away and ordering what to do and who to kill. What we have now in 2024. Nothing, what we learned from this war? Almost nothing. That's the shame, we all have to live in shame to the end of our miserable lifes.